Let’s be real for a second. When Universal announced they were actually doing it—turning the beloved DreamWorks trilogy into a live-action spectacle—everyone collectively held their breath. Remakes are risky. Remaking a movie that many people consider the "perfect" animated trilogy? That’s borderline dangerous territory. But as we get closer to the 2025 release, the focus has shifted from "Why are they doing this?" to "Wait, did they actually nail the casting?"
The live action How to Train Your Dragon characters are stepping out of the stylized, oversized-proportions of animation and into a gritty, salt-sprayed Viking reality. It's not just about finding actors who look like the drawings. It's about finding people who can carry the emotional weight of a boy who'd rather draw than kill, and a father who doesn't know how to speak to his son.
Dean DeBlois is back in the director's chair. That’s the big win here. Usually, these live-action pivots get handed off to a "safe" studio hand, but keeping the original visionary means the DNA of Berk remains intact. We aren't just getting a CGI Toothless; we're getting a reimagining of the bond that defined a generation of fantasy fans.
The New Hiccup: Mason Thames and the Pressure of the Prosthetic
Casting Hiccup Horrendous Haddock III was always going to be the hardest part of this puzzle. You need someone who feels physically out of place in a society of giant, axe-wielding warriors. Enter Mason Thames.
You might know him from The Black Phone. He has that specific kind of nervous energy that feels authentic rather than performed. Honestly, Hiccup isn't just a "nerd." He's a mechanical genius who feels like a disappointment to his lineage. Thames has to balance that biting sarcasm with a genuine sense of loneliness. In the original 2010 film, Jay Baruchel's voice acting gave Hiccup a nasally, frantic quality. Thames doesn't need to do an impression; he needs to embody the physicality of a kid who is constantly looking for an exit strategy until he finds a dragon that is just as broken as he is.
The stakes for Thames are high. He's not just acting against a green screen. He’s carrying the emotional arc of a character who eventually loses a limb—a massive moment for disability representation in mainstream cinema. Seeing that play out in live action will hit differently than it did in animation. It becomes less of a heroic sacrifice and more of a visceral, life-altering reality.
Nico Parker as Astrid: Moving Beyond the "Tough Girl" Trope
Astrid Hofferson is the heart of the Berkian warrior spirit. When Nico Parker was cast, the internet did what the internet does—it reacted loudly. But if you’ve seen Parker in The Last of Us, you know she has this incredible ability to be the smartest person in the room without saying a word.
💡 You might also like: Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Light Trail: Is the New York Botanical Garden Event Worth Your Money?
Astrid in the live action How to Train Your Dragon characters lineup isn't just the "love interest." She's the foil. She’s what Hiccup is supposed to be: disciplined, lethal, and fiercely loyal to the status quo. The chemistry between Parker and Thames has to sell the transition from rivals to soulmates. It’s a slow burn. It’s about Astrid realizing that the world isn’t just Vikings versus Dragons, but something much more complex.
Parker brings a grounded, modern sensibility to the role. She’s likely going to lean into the competitive nature of Dragon Training, making those early scenes in the kill ring feel genuinely dangerous. If she can capture that icy stare Astrid gives Hiccup before she realizes he’s hiding something, the movie is halfway there.
Gerard Butler is Stoick (Again) and Honestly, Who Else Could It Be?
This is the casting choice that basically broke the internet in the best way possible. Gerard Butler is returning to play Stoick the Vast.
Usually, I’m skeptical of bringing back original voice actors for live-action roles. It can feel gimmicky. But Stoick? Stoick is Gerard Butler. The man has the physical presence of a mountain and a voice that sounds like it was forged in a volcano. Seeing him in full Viking regalia—the massive beard, the fur capes, the sheer scale of the man—is going to be a nostalgic gut punch.
But there’s a layer of complexity here. In 2010, Stoick was a booming caricature of a disappointed dad. In live action, that relationship with Hiccup needs to feel more nuanced. It’s not just about yelling. It’s about the silence between them. Butler has the range to show the fear behind the fatherhood. He’s a leader who thinks he’s losing his son to "madness," and Butler’s ability to play vulnerable tough guys is exactly what the live action How to Train Your Dragon characters need to feel "real."
The Supporting Cast: Bringing the Humor to Life
The "Gang" provides the much-needed levity in a story that can get pretty dark. We’ve got Nick Frost as Gobber the Belch. Just let that sink in. Frost is a comedic legend, and his chemistry with Butler is going to be the highlight of the village scenes. Gobber is the bridge between Hiccup and Stoick, and Frost has that "weary uncle" vibe down to a science.
📖 Related: Diego Klattenhoff Movies and TV Shows: Why He’s the Best Actor You Keep Forgetting You Know
Then you have the rest of the dragon riders:
- Julian Dennison as Fishlegs: This is inspired casting. Dennison (Hunt for the Wilderpeople, Deadpool 2) is naturally hilarious but can also play the "walking encyclopedia" role with total sincerity.
- Bronwyn James and Harry Trevaldwyn as Ruffnut and Tuffnut: The twins are the chaotic energy of Berk. Trevaldwyn, in particular, has a very specific brand of awkward British humor that should translate well to the mindless bickering of the Thorston twins.
- Gabriel Howell as Snotlout: The arrogant, slightly dim-witted rival. Snotlout is a tough one because he can easily become annoying, but Howell needs to find the charm in the bravado.
Why the Physicality of These Characters Matters Now
In animation, dragons are cute. Even Toothless, with his cat-like movements, feels "safe." In live action, these are multi-ton apex predators. The human characters have to react to that weight. When Hiccup reaches out his hand to touch Toothless for the first time—the iconic "Forbidden Friendship" moment—the scale of the dragon compared to Mason Thames’ frame is going to be terrifying.
That’s the secret sauce. The live action How to Train Your Dragon characters aren't just there to look like the cartoon; they are there to make us feel the danger. If a Monstrous Nightmare breathes fire at Snotlout, we need to see the singed fur and the genuine panic. The stakes feel higher when the characters look like people we could actually know.
The costume design is also leaning into the "lived-in" aesthetic. We aren't looking at clean, plastic-looking armor. This is worn leather, rusted metal, and grease-stained wool. It’s the "Star Wars" approach to fantasy—everything looks used. This helps ground the characters in a world that feels like it has a history long before the movie starts.
The Toothless Factor: The "Character" We Haven't Seen Yet
We can't talk about characters without talking about the dragon that started it all. While not a human "actor," the live-action Toothless is being handled with a mix of high-end CGI and practical animatronics where possible.
The challenge for the human actors—specifically Mason Thames—is reacting to something that isn't there during filming. The original film relied heavily on the eyes of the dragon to convey emotion. In live action, if they go too realistic, they risk losing that "Night Fury" personality. If they go too "cartoony," he won't fit the world. The design needs to strike a balance between a black leopard and a prehistoric reptile.
👉 See also: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
What This Means for the Future of the Franchise
Universal isn't just making one movie. They are testing the waters for a full-scale cinematic universe. If these characters resonate, we’re looking at How to Train Your Dragon 2 (the best one, don't @ me) and The Hidden World in live action within the next decade.
The transition of the live action How to Train Your Dragon characters represents a shift in how studios view "kids' movies." They are treating the source material with the same reverence usually reserved for Dune or Lord of the Rings. That’s a good thing for fans. We don't want a shot-for-shot remake that feels hollow. We want a version that justifies its own existence.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Viewers
If you're tracking the development of this film, there are a few things to keep in mind to manage your expectations and get the most out of the release:
- Watch the "Last of Us" and "The Black Phone": If you want to see the dramatic range of Nico Parker and Mason Thames, these are the projects that prove they can handle the "heavy" stuff Hiccup and Astrid require.
- Don't expect a 1:1 musical score: John Powell is returning (thank the gods), but expect the "Test Drive" and "Romantic Flight" themes to be rearranged for a more cinematic, orchestral feel rather than the bright, poppy energy of the original.
- Look for the practical effects: Rumors from the set suggest they’ve built massive parts of the Berk village. Pay attention to the background—the world-building in live action is often where the real magic happens.
- Prepare for a tonal shift: The live-action version is likely to be slightly "older" in its execution. The humor will still be there, but the threat of the Red Death and the Viking-Dragon war will feel much more visceral.
The success of these characters hinges on one thing: sincerity. If the actors believe in the bond between Viking and Dragon, we will too. The "Forbidden Friendship" isn't just a plot point; it's the soul of the story. Based on the cast we have, it looks like Berk is in very capable hands.
Keep an eye on the official trailers dropping later this year to see the first footage of Thames and Butler together. That’s when we’ll truly see if the Haddock family dynamic translates to the real world. For now, the casting choices suggest a movie that respects the original while carving out its own rugged, dragon-scale path.