Sunday night. You’ve probably got a plate of wings getting cold or you’re checking your fantasy score for the tenth time in an hour. Then that familiar theme music hits. For millions of people, the NBC Sunday Night Football cast is basically the soundtrack to the end of the weekend. It’s the biggest show on television, and honestly, the chemistry in the booth is just as important as the game on the field.
But things have changed a lot lately.
The days of Al Michaels and Cris Collinsworth being the "only" duo people associate with the peacock network are fading into the rearview. We’ve seen a massive reshuffling of sports broadcasting chairs over the last couple of seasons, with massive contracts and surprise retirements keeping everyone on their toes. If you're wondering who’s calling the plays, who’s patrolling the sidelines, and who’s arguing at the halftime desk, let’s break down the current roster.
The Voice of the Game: Mike Tirico and Cris Collinsworth
Mike Tirico is the guy now. It felt like a long time coming, right? He spent years as the "heir apparent" to the legendary Al Michaels, and since taking over the lead play-by-play role, he’s brought a different kind of energy. Tirico is polished. He’s smooth. He has that rare ability to make a regular-season blowout feel like the Super Bowl without sounding like he's trying too hard.
Then there’s Cris Collinsworth.
Love him or hate him—and NFL Twitter usually has plenty to say about his "sliding" into the frame—the man knows his football. He’s a former wide receiver, and he sees things before they happen. When a quarterback makes a subtle adjustment at the line, Collinsworth is usually the first one to point out the safety cheat or the nickel corner's positioning. He’s the color commentator who brings the "PFF" (Pro Football Focus) era of deep-dive analytics into a conversational format.
👉 See also: Dodgers Black Heritage Night 2025: Why It Matters More Than the Jersey
They’ve got rhythm. It’s not just about calling the snap; it’s about the banter in between.
The Sideline Perspective: Melissa Stark
The NBC Sunday Night Football cast wouldn’t be complete without the person actually standing in the freezing rain or the 100-degree humidity. Melissa Stark returned to the fold a couple of seasons ago, replacing Michele Tafoya, and she hasn't missed a beat. Stark actually worked for SNF in the early 2000s, so her "return" was more of a homecoming.
Her job is basically high-speed journalism. She’s getting the injury updates that determine your fantasy week and the quick quotes from coaches who definitely don't want to be talking to anyone while their team is down by two scores.
The Studio Crew: Football Night in America
Before the kickoff even happens, you’ve got Football Night in America. This is the most-watched studio show in sports, and the cast here is a mix of veteran news anchors and guys who have Super Bowl rings in their closets.
- Maria Taylor: She’s the quarterback of the studio. Since moving over from ESPN, she has become the face of NBC’s NFL coverage. She has this way of commanding a room full of retired athletes and keeping the conversation from veering off the rails.
- Jason Garrett: Yeah, the "Clapper." The former Cowboys coach joined the crew and brought that "coach's eye" to the highlights. He’s surprisingly good at breaking down why a play failed without being overly mean about it.
- Devin McCourty: One of the newer additions. Fresh off a stellar career with the Patriots, McCourty brings that modern defensive perspective. He knows the schemes that teams are running right now, not ten years ago.
- Chris Simms: He’s the polarizing one. Simms isn't afraid to have a "hot take," especially when it comes to quarterback rankings. He does the heavy lifting on the pre-game analysis, often clashing with the more traditional views on the set.
- Jac Collinsworth: Cris’s son has been carving out his own path, often handling the on-site hosting duties and interviewing fans or players before the game kicks off.
The Rules Expert: Terry McAulay
We have to talk about the refs. Or rather, the guy who explains why the refs just ruined your night. Terry McAulay is the officiating expert for the NBC Sunday Night Football cast. When there’s a controversial fumble or a "what is a catch?" moment, Tirico throws it up to the booth for Terry to explain the rulebook.
✨ Don't miss: College Football Top 10: What Most People Get Wrong About the 2026 Rankings
It’s a thankless job. Usually, by the time Terry starts talking, half the stadium is booing and the other half is confused. But having a former referee who can translate "legalese" into English is essential for modern broadcasts.
Why This Specific Cast Works (And Why It Doesn't for Some)
Broadcasting is subjective. People get attached to voices. When Al Michaels left for Amazon, there was a genuine sense of mourning among some fans. Al is the "Miracle on Ice" guy. He’s a titan.
But Tirico and Collinsworth represent a shift toward a more data-driven, fast-paced era of football. They don't linger on the past as much. They are focused on the "why" of the modern game.
One thing NBC does better than almost anyone else is the production value. It’s not just the cast; it’s the way the cast is utilized. The "Snick" (Sunday Night Football) cameras are famous for their depth of field and cinematic look. When the NBC Sunday Night Football cast is talking over those visuals, it feels less like a sports broadcast and more like a weekly event.
The "Rules" of the Booth
It’s worth noting that the chemistry isn't accidental. The lead producer, Rob Hyland, has spoken before about how they prep. This isn't a "show up and talk" kind of gig. They spend all week in meetings with coaches and players from the two featured teams. If you hear Collinsworth mention a specific conversation he had with Patrick Mahomes on a Friday, that’s the result of hours of prep that most people never see.
🔗 Read more: Cleveland Guardians vs Atlanta Braves Matches: Why This Interleague Rivalry Hits Different
Looking Toward the Future of the Cast
We’re seeing a trend in sports media where the "cast" is expanding beyond just the TV screen. NBC has been leaning heavily into Peacock, their streaming service. This means you’ll often see members of the NBC Sunday Night Football cast appearing on digital-only shows or pre-game "second screen" experiences.
Is the roster set in stone? Probably not. The "Big Three" networks (and now streamers like Netflix and Amazon) are constantly poaching talent. But for now, the Tirico-Collinsworth-Stark trio is the gold standard for NBC.
Actionable Takeaways for the Dedicated Fan
If you want to get the most out of the broadcast and the insights this cast provides, don't just watch the game—engage with the tools they use.
- Follow the Sideline Reports Early: Melissa Stark often drops "nuggets" during the first quarter about conversations she had during warmups. These are often indicators of a player's health or a specific team strategy that the commentators will circle back to later.
- Watch the "Low" Camera Angles: NBC is famous for their "SkyCam." When Collinsworth is explaining a hole in the zone, watch the players' feet, not the ball. He’s usually pointing out the leverage of the defenders.
- Check the Pre-Game "Football Night in America" for Matchups: The studio crew usually spends about 15 minutes specifically on the "matchup of the night" (e.g., an elite Edge Rusher vs. a rookie Left Tackle). That one segment usually dictates the narrative of the entire game.
- Listen for the "Terry Signal": If Tirico says "Let's go to Terry," pay attention to the exact wording the ref used on the field. McAulay is great at explaining the nuance of the rule, which is often different from what the fans think the rule is.
The NBC Sunday Night Football cast has the task of keeping 20 million people entertained for three and a half hours. It’s a mix of journalism, entertainment, and high-level sports analysis. Whether you’re there for the tactical breakdown or just the atmosphere, knowing who is behind the mic helps you appreciate the machine that is primetime NFL football.