You’ve seen the movies. The bleeding walls, the flies, the red-eyed pigs, and that iconic gambrel roof that looks suspiciously like a pair of glowing eyes. It’s the ultimate campfire story. But for the people who actually have to pay the property taxes on 112 Ocean Avenue, it’s just home. People always ask who is living in the Amityville house now, usually expecting a tale about a brave paranormal investigator or a family living in a state of constant terror.
The reality is a lot more boring. And a lot more expensive.
Currently, the house is owned by a private family who bought it back in 2017. They didn't move in to hunt ghosts. They moved in because it’s a massive, beautiful colonial waterfront property in a high-end Long Island neighborhood.
The Current Owners and the 2017 Sale
In February 2017, the house sold for $605,000. That might sound like a steal for a big house on the water, but you’ve got to remember the "stigma discount." The house had been on the market for months, originally asking $850,000.
The buyers? Their names were eventually tied to Caroline and Christopher D’Antonio.
They aren't celebrities. They aren't reality TV stars. They are just people who wanted a nice place to live. When they bought it, the listing didn't even mention the hauntings or the 1974 DeFeo murders. It focused on the "large boat house," the "stately center hall colonial" vibes, and the "formal dining room."
Since taking over, the D’Antonios have been incredibly private. You won't find them doing interviews with Ghost Hunters. They don't let camera crews in. Honestly, the biggest nightmare they face isn't a demon in the basement; it’s the tourists.
Imagine trying to drink your morning coffee while someone from three states away is standing on your sidewalk taking selfies. It happens every single day. Even now, decades after the Lutz family fled the house in 1976, the "Amityville Horror" brand is so strong that the owners have to deal with constant trespassing.
✨ Don't miss: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
Why the Address Isn't 112 Ocean Avenue Anymore
If you try to GPS your way to 112 Ocean Avenue, you might get a little confused. One of the previous owners—specifically James and Barbara Cromarty, who bought the place right after the Lutzes left—got so fed up with the attention that they petitioned to have the address changed.
It is now officially 108 Ocean Avenue.
They also changed the windows. Those famous "eye" windows on the top floor? Gone. They were replaced with square ones to make the house look less like the poster for a horror movie. It worked, mostly. From the street, the house looks like any other wealthy suburban home. It’s grey. It’s clean. It has a nice lawn.
The Cromartys lived there for ten years. Ten years! If the house was truly a portal to hell, they probably wouldn't have stayed for a decade. Barbara Cromarty famously used to say that the only weird things happening in the house were caused by the people ringing the doorbell at 3:00 AM.
The Chain of Title: Who Else Lived There?
To understand who is living in the Amityville house now, it helps to look at the people who came before the D'Antonios. There is a very specific pattern: people buy it, stay for a few years, realize the "horror" is mostly just annoying teenagers on Halloween, and then they sell.
- The DeFeos (1965–1974): The tragedy that started it all. Ronald "Butch" DeFeo Jr. murdered six members of his family. This is the only part of the "horror" that is 100% undisputed fact.
- The Lutzes (1975–1976): George and Kathy Lutz stayed for 28 days. They claimed levitation, green slime, and demonic pigs. Their story became the book and the movie.
- The Cromartys (1977–1987): They sued the Lutzes, claiming the haunting stories were a hoax that ruined their privacy. They won a settlement.
- Peter and Edith O’Neil (1987–1997): A quiet decade. No reports of ghosts.
- Brian Wilson (1997–2010): Not the Beach Boy. Just a guy who spent hundreds of thousands of dollars renovating the place. He added a sunroom and fixed up the boat house.
- Caroline and David D’Antonio (2010–2017): Wait, the names look familiar? Caroline D’Antonio has actually been associated with the house through two different purchase cycles. The 2017 sale was essentially a formalization of ownership after David passed away.
The common thread? Nobody besides the Lutzes ever reported anything supernatural.
The Ghost Tourism Problem
The town of Amityville hates the house.
🔗 Read more: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think
Well, maybe not the house itself, but the reputation. The local police department is known for being very "proactive" about moving people along if they linger too long on Ocean Avenue. There are no signs pointing you toward the house. There are no gift shops.
If you go there today, you’ll see "Private Property" and "No Trespassing" signs everywhere. The current residents have high fences and security cameras. They have to. Because "who is living in the Amityville house now" is a question asked by thousands of people every month, and some of those people are bold enough to try and peek through the windows.
It’s a weird life. You’re living in a piece of American pop culture history, but you can’t enjoy the fame because the fame is based on a mass murder and a (likely) fabricated ghost story.
Is the House Still "Haunted"?
Most paranormal researchers today, like those who have followed the work of the late Hans Holzer or the Warrens, are split. The Warrens (of The Conjuring fame) insisted until their deaths that the house was demonic. They famously took a photo of what they claimed was a "ghost boy" on the staircase.
But science and investigative journalism have been less kind to the legend.
William Weber, the defense attorney for Butch DeFeo, eventually admitted that he and the Lutzes "created this horror story over many bottles of wine." They needed a way to explain DeFeo’s actions and a way for the Lutzes to get out of a mortgage they couldn't afford.
The people living there now seem to fall firmly on the "it’s just a house" side of the fence. You don't spend over $600,000 to live in a place where you're terrified to go into the basement. You buy it because you like the view of the Amity Creek.
💡 You might also like: Black Red Wing Shoes: Why the Heritage Flex Still Wins in 2026
What You Should Know If You Visit Amityville
If you’re planning a trip to see the house, don't.
Seriously.
The residents of the street are tired. The people in the house are tired. You can’t see much from the road anyway because of the landscaping. If you want the "Amityville experience," you’re better off watching the 1979 original film or the 2005 remake. The house used in the 2005 movie isn't even in New York; it’s in Wisconsin.
Quick Facts About the Current State of 112 Ocean Ave:
- Market Value: Estimated around $850,000–$1.1 million in 2026.
- Security: High-end surveillance and frequent police patrols.
- Interior: Completely renovated. The "Red Room" from the books was actually just a small closet space under the stairs that the Lutzes painted red. It’s been gone for decades.
- Neighborhood: Extremely quiet, wealthy, and protective of their privacy.
Actionable Steps for the Curious
If you are fascinated by the Amityville case, stop looking at the current house and start looking at the history.
- Research the DeFeo Trial: If you want the real story, look into the court transcripts of Ronald DeFeo Jr. The real horror was a human one, not a supernatural one.
- Check Local Records: The Suffolk County historical archives have fascinating details about the construction of the house in the 1920s.
- Respect the Owners: If you do drive by, stay in your car. Do not block the driveway. Do not walk onto the lawn. The quickest way to get a ticket in Amityville is to loiter on Ocean Avenue.
- Explore the Town: Amityville itself is a charming village. Visit the local shops and parks instead of fixating on a private residence.
The answer to who is living in the Amityville house now is simply a family that wants to be left alone. They are the latest in a long line of owners who have tried to reclaim the property from its own legend. Every year they stay there without a "demonic possession" is another nail in the coffin of the 1970s hoax. It’s a beautiful home with a dark past, currently being used for nothing more sinister than family dinners and weekend boating.
---