So, you’re scrolling through Disney+ or catching a random cable rerun and you see Kristen Bell staring down Odette Annable while Jamie Lee Curtis and Sigourney Weaver trade insults in the background. It hits you. The cast of You Again is actually insane. How did this movie happen? Honestly, looking back at 2010, this film was a lightning strike of multi-generational star power that we rarely see in mid-budget comedies anymore.
It’s one of those "wedding-gone-wrong" movies, sure. But the pedigree of the actors involved makes it feel like a heavy-hitter ensemble. You have a literal scream queen, an alien-slaying sci-fi legend, a TV sweetheart, and the grandmother of all comedy legends, Betty White.
The Core Rivalry: Kristen Bell and Odette Annable
At the center of the storm is Kristen Bell playing Marni. Before she was the voice of Anna in Frozen or the soul-searching Eleanor in The Good Place, Bell was the queen of the relatable underdog. In You Again, she plays a successful PR executive who is still deeply scarred by her high school years. It’s funny because Hollywood always tries to make beautiful people look "ugly" with glasses and some frizz, and they did exactly that here.
Then you have Joanna, played by Odette Annable (then Odette Yustman). She’s the "Queen Bee" who made Marni’s life a living hell. The twist? She’s marrying Marni’s brother. Annable plays the "reformed" mean girl with just enough sugary sweetness to make you wonder if she’s actually changed or if she’s a total sociopath. Their chemistry is fueled by a very specific kind of female-led slapstick that feels a bit like a relic of the late 2000s, but it works because they both commit 100% to the physical comedy.
The Heavyweights: Jamie Lee Curtis vs. Sigourney Weaver
This is where the cast of You Again moves from "typical rom-com" to "must-watch trivia."
Jamie Lee Curtis plays Gail, Marni’s mom. She’s stable, kind, and seemingly over her own high school drama. That is, until Ramona shows up. Ramona is played by Sigourney Weaver. Seeing Ripley and Laurie Strode on screen together is a geek’s dream, but instead of fighting xenomorphs or Michael Myers, they are fighting over who was more popular in 1977.
✨ Don't miss: Chase From Paw Patrol: Why This German Shepherd Is Actually a Big Deal
Weaver is magnificent as the wealthy, jet-setting aunt. She plays it with a cold, effortless superiority that contrasts perfectly with Curtis’s more frantic, "I’m fine, everything is fine" energy. There’s a scene where they both show up in the same dress—a classic trope—but they sell it so well because they are, well, legends. They represent a bridge between the classic Hollywood era and the modern leading lady.
Don't Forget the Men (Though the Movie Sorta Does)
While the women drive every single plot point, the male supporting cast is surprisingly solid. James Wolk plays Will, the brother caught in the middle. You might recognize him from Mad Men or Watchmen. He has that "Golden Retriever" energy that makes it believable that he’d be totally oblivious to his fiancée’s past as a bully.
Then there’s Victor Garber. He plays Gail’s husband. Garber is one of those actors who just brings instant class to any set. He doesn’t have a ton to do, but his presence grounds the family dynamic. And we have Kyle Bornheimer, who plays the ex-boyfriend. He’s a veteran of the "bumbling but well-meaning guy" role, and he executes it perfectly here.
The Betty White Factor
We have to talk about Betty White.
She plays Grandma Bunny. This was released right in the middle of the "Betty White Renaissance"—shortly after The Proposal and her iconic SNL hosting gig. She gets the best lines. Obviously. She’s the one who reveals that even she has a lifelong rivalry with a woman named Bunny (played by Cloris Leachman in a brilliant, uncredited cameo).
🔗 Read more: Charlize Theron Sweet November: Why This Panned Rom-Com Became a Cult Favorite
Having Betty White and Cloris Leachman—two Mary Tyler Moore Show alums—facing off one last time is the kind of meta-casting that keeps this movie relevant for TV history buffs. It’s a tiny bit of magic tucked inside a movie about a wedding rehearsal dinner.
Why the Ensemble Worked (and Why It Didn't)
When critics looked at the cast of You Again, the consensus was a bit split. On one hand, how can you go wrong with this much talent? On the other, the script—written by Moe Jelline—sometimes felt a little too thin for the caliber of actors on screen.
Directed by Andy Fickman (who did She's the Man), the movie leans heavily into the idea that high school never ends. It’s a universal truth, but it’s also a bit exhausting. The cast saves it. They elevate material that might have been "Straight-to-DVD" in other hands.
- Kristen Bell brought the vulnerability.
- Jamie Lee Curtis brought the physical comedy (the dance-off scene is iconic).
- Sigourney Weaver brought the intimidation factor.
- Betty White brought the heart (and the snark).
The Legacy of the Performers
If you look at where the cast of You Again went after 2010, it’s actually impressive.
Kristen Bell became a household name. Odette Annable moved into major TV roles like Supergirl and Walker. Sigourney Weaver returned to the Avatar franchise, proving she’s still the queen of the box office. Jamie Lee Curtis eventually won her Oscar for Everything Everywhere All At Once, proving that her comedic timing in movies like this was just one facet of a massive career.
💡 You might also like: Charlie Charlie Are You Here: Why the Viral Demon Myth Still Creeps Us Out
One thing that people often forget? The cameo by Kristin Chenoweth. She plays Georgia King, the wedding planner/dance instructor. Her energy is at a 15 out of 10 at all times. It’s a small role, but she manages to steal every scene she’s in with her operatic voice and frantic movements.
Finding the Movie Today
If you’re looking to rewatch it, You Again usually lives on Disney+ or is available for a few bucks on Vudu/Amazon. It’s a comfort movie. It’s not trying to change the world. It’s trying to show you that even the most successful people in the world are still, deep down, terrified of their high school bullies.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Lovers
If you're diving back into the world of this 2010 ensemble, here is how to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch for the Cameos: Beyond Cloris Leachman, keep an eye out for Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson in an uncredited bit. He worked with director Andy Fickman on The Game Plan and Race to Witch Mountain, so he popped in as a favor.
- Compare the Generations: Use this as a double feature with The Women (1939) or Steel Magnolias. It’s a great study in how Hollywood writes female-ensemble comedies across different decades.
- Check the Soundtrack: The movie uses "We Are Family" and "Toxic" in ways that are very "of their time," but they highlight the theme of female rivalry vs. sisterhood.
- Look at the Fashion: The "same dress" subplot is a great example of 2010 formal wear trends—lots of satin and bold, solid colors that haven't necessarily aged perfectly, which adds to the comedy.
This film remains a time capsule of a specific moment in Hollywood where the "Chick Flick" was a powerhouse at the box office, driven not by superheroes, but by the sheer charisma of women who knew exactly how to land a punchline.