You probably remember Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson in the original 2010 movie. He had the wings, the tutu, and that weirdly charismatic "hockey player turned magical sprite" energy. But then 2012 rolled around and we got a sequel. It was direct-to-video. It didn't have The Rock. Instead, it had a very different kind of star. When people look up the cast of the Tooth Fairy 2, they’re usually trying to figure out if they actually saw what they think they saw—Larry the Cable Guy taking over a franchise originally built for a global action icon.
It’s a weird pivot. Honestly, it’s one of the most drastic tonal shifts in a sequel ever.
Larry the Cable Guy as Larry Guthrie
The centerpiece of the cast of the Tooth Fairy 2 is, of course, Larry the Cable Guy (born Daniel Lawrence Whitney). He plays Larry Guthrie. Unlike the first film’s protagonist, who was a professional hockey player, Guthrie is just a regular guy in a small town who is desperately trying to win back the love of his life.
He's not a superstar athlete. He's a guy who works at an auto body shop.
The plot kicks off when Larry tries to impress Brooke (played by Erin Beute) by volunteering at her after-school program. In a moment of classic "bad timing," he tells a kid that the tooth fairy isn't real. The "Higher Ups" in the tooth fairy world don't take kindly to that. Suddenly, Larry is cursed—or drafted—into becoming a real-life tooth fairy. He’s got the pink tutu. He’s got the tiny wings. He’s got the Southern accent that makes the whole visual even more surreal.
Larry brings his trademark "Git-R-Done" energy to the role, which is basically what you'd expect if you've seen his stand-up or his work as Mater in Cars. He’s self-deprecating. He fumbles through the magic. It’s physical comedy through and through.
The Supporting Players: David Mackey and Erin Beute
Every comedy needs a foil. In this movie, that’s David Mackey. He plays Beauregard "Bo" Billings, the local politician who is also Larry’s rival for Brooke’s affections.
Mackey plays the part with that perfect level of "smarmy guy you want to see trip over a rug." He’s the opposite of Larry—polished, rich, and seemingly perfect. It creates the classic underdog dynamic that these types of family comedies thrive on. You’ve seen this trope a thousand times, but Mackey leans into it well enough to make the stakes feel real for a movie about a man in a leotard.
💡 You might also like: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Then there’s Erin Beute as Brooke.
She’s the heart of the film. While the movie is mostly about Larry’s magical mishaps, Beute has the thankless job of being the "grounded" character. She’s the one Larry is trying to prove himself to. Her performance is sincere, which helps balance out the more cartoonish elements of the script. Interestingly, Beute has had a solid career in television, appearing in shows like The Vampire Diaries, but this remains one of her most prominent film roles.
The Magical Oversight: Brady Reiter as Nyx
You can’t have a tooth fairy movie without the bureaucracy of the fairy world. In the first film, we had Julie Andrews (an absolute legend) as the head fairy. In the cast of the Tooth Fairy 2, that authoritative role is handled by Brady Reiter, who plays Nyx.
Except there’s a twist.
Nyx isn't an older, wiser mentor. She's a young girl. She’s the one who assigns Larry his "missions" and keeps him in line. This creates a funny power dynamic where a middle-aged man with a thick Nebraska accent has to take orders from a child in a high-fashion fairy outfit. Reiter plays the role with a stern, no-nonsense attitude that works surprisingly well against Larry’s bumbling.
Why the Change in Direction?
People often ask why the cast of the Tooth Fairy 2 didn't include any returning members from the original. Usually, when a studio moves a franchise to the "Direct-to-DVD" or digital-only market, they look for a different type of star power.
Dwayne Johnson was becoming the biggest movie star on the planet in 2012. He was busy joining the Fast & Furious franchise and filming G.I. Joe: Retaliation. He wasn't coming back for a sequel that didn't have a theatrical release budget.
📖 Related: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
Fox opted for a "spiritual sequel" approach.
By hiring Larry the Cable Guy, they targeted a very specific demographic: families in the Midwest and South who loved Blue Collar Comedy. It was a business move. It changed the movie from a high-budget fantasy comedy into a low-budget, slapstick-heavy family flick. It’s also why the setting moved from a cold, professional hockey environment to a warm, sunny Florida small town (the movie was filmed largely in the Pensacola area).
The Rest of the Ensemble
Rounding out the cast of the Tooth Fairy 2 are several character actors who fill out the small-town vibe.
- Gabriel Suttle as Gabe: The kid who Larry accidentally traumatizes by doubting the tooth fairy. His performance is the catalyst for the entire plot.
- Bob Small as Father In Law: Adds to the family tension that Larry is trying to navigate.
- Lucius Baston as the Scared Dad: A brief but funny moment that highlights just how terrifying a 250-pound man in wings actually looks when he breaks into your house.
Behind the Scenes: Direction and Production
The movie was directed by Alex Zamm. If that name sounds familiar, it's because Zamm is the king of the "sequel you didn't know existed." He directed Inspector Gadget 2, Woody Woodpecker, and Beverly Hills Chihuahua 2. He knows how to work with a smaller budget and how to get a specific type of performance out of comedic leads.
He didn't try to make this Citizen Kane.
He made a movie where a guy falls off a roof and lands in a cake. Sometimes, that’s exactly what the audience is looking for on a Saturday afternoon.
Realism Check: The Impact of the Sequel
Let's be real for a second. Tooth Fairy 2 currently sits at a very low rating on most review sites. Critics weren't kind. But "cast of the tooth fairy 2" remains a popular search because the movie has had a long life on streaming services and cable TV.
👉 See also: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
It’s one of those movies that kids discover on a whim.
For the actors involved, it was a paycheck and a chance to do some physical comedy. For Larry the Cable Guy, it was an attempt to see if his brand of humor could carry a live-action family franchise. While we never got a Tooth Fairy 3, this film remains a curious artifact of the early 2010s home video market.
How to Watch and What to Look For
If you’re going to sit down and watch it, don't expect the production value of a Marvel movie. Look at the practical effects. They used real rigs to fly Larry around, which adds a bit of genuine physical grit to the comedy.
Pay attention to:
- The Costume Design: The contrast between Larry’s rugged look and the delicate fairy gear is the main visual gag.
- The Florida Scenery: Unlike many movies that fake their locations on a soundstage, you can really feel the Gulf Coast atmosphere here.
- The Cameos: Keep an eye out for small appearances by local Florida talent who were cast during the production in Pensacola.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Fans
If you're a fan of the cast of the Tooth Fairy 2 or just curious about how these sequels get made, here are a few things you can do to dive deeper into this weird niche of cinema:
- Check the Credits for Alex Zamm: If you enjoyed the vibe of this movie, look up his other work. He specializes in "rebooting" franchises for home audiences, and there is a weirdly consistent style across all his films.
- Compare the "Rule Sets": Watch the 2010 original and the sequel back-to-back. It’s fascinating to see how the "mythology" of the tooth fairy changes between the two movies. The sequel actually expands on the "Fairy World" bureaucracy more than the first one did.
- Look for Behind-the-Scenes Clips: There are several featurettes available on the DVD and some streaming platforms that show Larry the Cable Guy doing his own stunts. Watching a grown man in a harness trying to maintain his dignity while wearing wings is arguably funnier than the movie itself.
The cast of the Tooth Fairy 2 might not be winning Oscars any time soon, but they delivered exactly what was asked of them: a lighthearted, slightly ridiculous movie that keeps the kids entertained for 90 minutes. Whether you love Larry the Cable Guy or just stumbled upon this movie while scrolling through a streaming library, it’s a fascinating example of how Hollywood keeps franchises alive through unexpected casting choices.