Robert Thorogood has a type. If you’ve spent any time at all watching Death in Paradise, you know exactly what that type is: sunny locales, impossible "locked-room" puzzles, and a detective who feels just a little bit out of step with the rest of the world. But when he moved the action from the Caribbean to the sleepy banks of the Thames, he needed a different kind of magic. He found it in the cast of The Marlow Murder Club. Honestly, it’s the kind of casting that looks perfect on paper but feels even better on screen. You’ve got a retired archaeologist, a dog walker, and a vicar's wife. It sounds like the setup for a joke, but in the hands of Samantha Bond and her co-stars, it’s a masterclass in cozy crime chemistry.
Marlow isn't just a backdrop. It's a character. But the people walking its streets—and occasionally dragging bodies out of its river—are why people are tuning in.
Samantha Bond is the heart of the cast of The Marlow Murder Club
Most people know Samantha Bond as Miss Moneypenny from the Brosnan era of Bond films, or perhaps as Lady Rosamund from Downton Abbey. She has this inherent air of authority. It's in her posture. So, casting her as Judith Potts was a stroke of genius. Judith is the fulcrum of the entire show. She’s a 70-something retiree who lives alone in a slightly crumbling mansion, drinks whiskey, and swims naked in the Thames.
She's brilliant.
Bond plays Judith with a sharp, unsentimental edge that keeps the show from becoming too "twee." When she hears a gunshot from her neighbor's garden, she doesn't call the police and hide under the covers. She gets in her boat. That’s the energy Bond brings to the cast of The Marlow Murder Club. She isn't playing a "sweet old lady." She’s playing a woman who has spent her life digging up the past and has zero patience for people who lie to her in the present.
The nuance in Bond's performance comes through in her solitude. You see glimpses of a woman who is fiercely independent but perhaps a little bit lonely, even if she’d never admit it. It’s a physical performance, too. Watching her navigate the river or march across the Marlow bridge, you realize she’s the engine of the narrative.
Jo Martin and Cara Horgan: The unlikely allies
A detective trio needs balance. If everyone is as sharp and abrasive as Judith, the audience gets a headache. That’s where Jo Martin and Cara Horgan come in, rounding out the lead cast of The Marlow Murder Club with completely different vibrations.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Jo Martin plays Suzie Harris. You might recognize her as the Fugitive Doctor from Doctor Who or from her long stint on Holby City. Here, she’s a dog walker. It’s a great pivot for Martin, who usually plays characters with immense power or gravitas. Suzie is salt-of-the-earth. She’s the one with the local connections, the one who knows whose dog is barking at 3:00 AM and which neighbor is cheating on their taxes. Martin brings a warmth and a "no-nonsense" humor that grounds the more intellectual leaps Judith makes.
Then there’s Becks Starling, played by Cara Horgan.
Becks is the Vicar’s wife. On the surface, she’s the "perfect" pillar of the community, but Horgan plays her with this wonderful, simmering anxiety. She’s a woman who has spent her life trying to please everyone else and has completely lost track of what she actually wants. Joining a murder investigation is her version of a mid-life crisis. Horgan has been in things like The Death of Stalin and The Sandman, and she has this ability to look both terrified and exhilarated at the same time.
The chemistry between these three is the real "hook." It’s not just about the mystery. It’s about three women from different social strata—the posh retiree, the struggling dog walker, and the repressed vicar’s wife—finding a weird, bloody common ground.
Natalie Dew as the actual professional
We have to talk about DS Tanika Malik.
In many cozy mysteries, the professional police are portrayed as bumbling idiots just to make the amateurs look better. Thankfully, the cast of The Marlow Murder Club avoids this trope by casting Natalie Dew. Tanika isn't incompetent; she’s just overwhelmed. She’s a young detective sergeant trying to prove herself in a new post while dealing with a short-staffed department and, frankly, three meddling women who keep finding evidence before she does.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Dew brings a weary, relatable energy to the role. She’s the audience’s proxy. When Judith bursts into the station with a theory about a wedding ring or a rare coin, Tanika’s reaction is a mix of "Please go away" and "Wait, that actually makes sense." It’s a delicate balance to play the "straight man" in a comedy-drama, but Dew makes Tanika feel like a real person with a real job, rather than just a plot device to hand out files.
Supporting players and the Marlow atmosphere
The world of Marlow feels lived-in because of the supporting actors. You’ve got Mark Fleischmann (who you might know from Being Human or The Princess Switch) playing Giles Wright. Then there’s the various suspects and victims that populate the episodes.
The casting directors, Serena Hill and her team, clearly looked for actors who could inhabit the "middle England" vibe without falling into caricatures. Even the minor roles, like the local shopkeepers or the suspicious wealthy neighbors, have a layer of British eccentricity that feels authentic to the Thames Valley setting.
- Samantha Bond: The intellectual leader.
- Jo Martin: The street-smart muscle and heart.
- Cara Horgan: The meticulous researcher (and the one who brings the snacks).
- Natalie Dew: The bridge between the "amateurs" and the law.
Why this specific cast works for the "Cozy Crime" genre
Cozy crime is a tricky beast. If it’s too dark, you lose the "cozy." If it’s too light, there’s no stakes. The cast of The Marlow Murder Club manages to walk this tightrope because they take the emotions seriously even when the situations are slightly absurd.
When Judith discovers the first body—her neighbor, Stefan Dunwoody—Samantha Bond doesn't play it for laughs. She plays the genuine shock and the cold, hard resolve of someone who wants justice. Because the actors believe in the world, we believe in it too.
Thorogood’s writing often relies on dialogue-heavy scenes where characters sit around a kitchen table or a pub garden to deconstruct the clues. This requires actors who can make exposition sound like natural conversation. You see this especially in the scenes at Judith’s house. The way the three women interact—talking over each other, bickering about who is in charge—feels like real female friendship in its early, awkward stages.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
What most people miss about the show's casting
A lot of viewers focus on the "Bond Girl" connection with Samantha Bond. But the real depth of this cast lies in their stage backgrounds. Bond, Martin, and Horgan are all seasoned theater veterans. You can tell. They have a timing that you don't always get with purely screen-based actors.
There's a specific rhythm to a Robert Thorogood script. It’s fast. It’s wordy. If the actors can’t keep up with the "ping-pong" nature of the dialogue, the whole thing falls flat. This cast doesn't just keep up; they set the pace.
They also manage to make Marlow feel like a place where secrets actually happen. It's a beautiful town, sure, but the cast brings out the shadows. You see it in the way Becks looks at her husband, or the way Suzie reacts to the mention of certain local figures. It’s the subtle stuff—the stuff between the lines—that makes the show more than just a 2D mystery.
How to watch and what to look for next
If you're just diving into the show, keep an eye on the power dynamics. At the start, Judith is very much the "boss." But as the series progresses, the cast of The Marlow Murder Club shifts. Suzie and Becks start to push back. They bring their own expertise to the table. By the time you get to the finale of the first series, they aren't just Judith's helpers—they’re a team.
The show originally aired on Drama and UKTV Play in the UK, and Masterpiece on PBS in the US. Because of the success of the first series, a second was commissioned quickly.
Actionable insights for fans of the show
If you’ve finished the first series and are looking for more, here is how you can deep-dive into the world created by this cast:
- Read the Books: Robert Thorogood wrote the novels before the TV show existed. The characters in the books are slightly different (Judith is even more eccentric), and it’s fascinating to see how Samantha Bond adapted the literary version of Judith Potts for the screen.
- Explore the Filmographies: If you enjoyed Jo Martin, check out her episodes of Doctor Who to see her incredible range. For Samantha Bond, go back and watch her in Downton Abbey to see her play a very different kind of aristocratic rebel.
- Visit (or Google Map) Marlow: The show uses real locations. You can actually see the Marlow Bridge and the Two Brewers pub (though they use different names or interiors sometimes). The cast spent a lot of time in the town, and the local "feel" is genuine.
- Watch Death in Paradise: If the "vibe" of the mystery feels familiar, it's because it's the same creator. While the cast is different, the structure of the clues and the "big reveal" at the end follows a similar, satisfying pattern.
The cast of The Marlow Murder Club succeeds because it respects the audience. It doesn't treat the "older woman" detective as a gimmick. It treats her as a formidable, intelligent, and slightly dangerous person. Whether they are rowing down the Thames or breaking into a suspect’s office, these women prove that the most interesting people in the room are often the ones the world has stopped noticing.