Holiday movies are weirdly comforting. We know exactly how they’ll end within the first five minutes, yet we keep coming back for the cozy sweaters and the inevitable snow-dusted kiss. Rekindling Christmas, which hit screens in 2020, leans hard into those classic tropes but stands out because of its specific chemistry. If you’ve been scrolling through streaming services and wondering why the faces in the cast of Rekindling Christmas look so familiar, it’s probably because this group has deep roots in television history and the indie film circuit. It isn't just a random assortment of actors; it’s a mix of soap opera veterans and rising stars who actually seem to like each other on screen.
The Leading Duo: Ashley Atwood and Jesse Metcalf
The heart of the story rests on Annika and Jesse. Ashley Atwood plays Annika, a single mother and a successful career woman who has her life mostly figured out—until her high school sweetheart rolls back into town. Atwood brings a certain groundedness to the role. She doesn't play Annika as a helpless romantic. Instead, she’s skeptical. Honestly, that’s what makes the performance work. You can see the conflict in her eyes every time Jesse tries to charm his way back into her life. Atwood has been around the block in Hollywood, appearing in projects like Poison Ivy: The Secret Society and various short films, but this role allowed her to flex those "girl next door with a spine of steel" muscles.
Then there’s Jesse Metcalf. No, not that Jesse Metcalfe from Desperate Housewives (note the spelling difference), but the talented Jesse Metcalf who plays the former football star in this film. In the movie, his character—also named Jesse—is a retired NFL player returning home after an injury. It’s a classic "hometown hero" arc. Metcalf plays the role with a blend of regret and hope. He’s got that athletic build that makes the football backstory believable, but he’s also got a softness that works for the more emotional beats of the film.
The chemistry between these two is the engine of the movie. If they didn't click, the whole "rekindling" premise would fall flat. You've probably seen movies where the leads feel like strangers forced to hold hands. Here, it feels like there’s actual history. They argue like people who have known each other since they were sixteen. It's subtle, but it's there.
Supporting Cast and Familiar Faces
While the leads do the heavy lifting, the supporting cast of Rekindling Christmas adds the necessary texture to the small-town setting. One of the most recognizable faces is Michael Pare. If you’re a fan of 80s cult classics, you’ll know him from Streets of Fire or The Philadelphia Experiment. In this film, he plays Marshall. Seeing a grizzled veteran like Pare in a Christmas rom-com is a bit of a trip, but he brings a gravitas to the screen that anchors the more lighthearted moments. He’s the kind of actor who doesn't need a lot of lines to make an impact; he just has "that look."
Then we have Sal Velez Jr. playing the role of T.J. Sal is one of those "hey, I know that guy" actors. He’s been in high-profile projects like The Way Back with Ben Affleck and the Netflix series Black Summer. His presence in a holiday movie might seem unexpected given his history with gritty dramas, but he fits right in. It’s a testament to the casting director that they pulled in actors with such diverse backgrounds.
🔗 Read more: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
- Thomas Douglas as James: He plays the role with a steady hand, providing that secondary support that every Christmas movie needs to feel "full."
- Nicole Danielle Moore as Sarah: She brings a bright energy to her scenes, acting as a foil to some of the more serious emotional stakes.
One of the standout younger performers is Christian Ganiere, who plays Annika’s son, TJ. Child actors can be hit or miss—let’s be real. But Ganiere is genuinely charming. He avoids the "too precocious for his own good" trap that ruins many holiday films. His interactions with Jesse Metcalf’s character are some of the most heart-tugging parts of the movie because they represent the potential for a new family unit. Ganiere actually has a pretty solid resume for a young actor, including a stint on Grey's Anatomy and Stranger Things. He knows how to hold his own against seasoned adults.
Why This Specific Cast Works
Most people watch these movies for the "vibes," but the cast of Rekindling Christmas works because they treat the material with respect. It’s easy to wink at the camera in a TV movie, but these actors play it straight. When Annika talks about her fears of getting hurt again, Atwood isn't just saying lines; she’s tapping into something real.
The film was directed by James Ganiere, who clearly had a vision for a more intimate, character-driven story. By casting actors like Michael Pare and Sal Velez Jr., he elevated the project above the standard "cookie-cutter" holiday fare. There’s a grit to the performances that matches the cold, wintery aesthetic of the film. It's about second chances, and everyone in the cast seems to understand that theme on a personal level.
The Small Town Dynamic
The ensemble really shines when they are all together in the "hometown" scenes. Whether it’s at a local diner or a community event, the background actors and secondary leads create a sense of place. You actually believe these people live in this town. They don't look like models who just stepped off a runway in Los Angeles; they look like people who buy groceries and deal with car trouble.
Behind the Scenes Connections
Interestingly, the film has some family ties. As mentioned, the director is James Ganiere, and the young star is Christian Ganiere. This often leads to a more relaxed atmosphere on set, which usually translates to better performances. Actors tend to take more risks when they feel comfortable with the production team. You can sense that comfort in the way the scenes breathe. There’s no rush to get to the next plot point. They let the moments land.
💡 You might also like: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The script was written by Nicole Franslev and James Ganiere, based on the book by JT Clark. Having the author’s source material usually helps the cast understand their characters’ motivations more deeply. In interviews, many cast members have noted that the "rekindling" aspect wasn't just about romance, but about rekindling one's own sense of purpose. That's a deep theme for a Christmas movie, and the cast carries that weight well.
Where Are They Now?
Since Rekindling Christmas wrapped, the cast hasn't slowed down.
Ashley Atwood continues to be a staple in independent cinema and has moved into more producing roles. She’s a powerhouse who really understands the business side of the industry. Jesse Metcalf has stayed active in the TV movie circuit, becoming a reliable lead for various networks.
Michael Pare is... well, he’s Michael Pare. The man never stops working. He has dozens of projects in various stages of production at any given time. If you like his work in this film, you should definitely check out his more recent thrillers where he often plays the law enforcement figure or the mysterious stranger.
Common Misconceptions About the Movie
A lot of people confuse this film with other "Christmas homecoming" movies because, let’s face it, the titles are all very similar. You’ve got A Christmas Rekindled, Christmas Rekindling, and about five other variations.
📖 Related: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
However, the cast of Rekindling Christmas is what distinguishes this 2020 release. It isn't a Hallmark original, though it shares that DNA. It’s a bit more independent in its spirit. One common mistake is thinking the lead is the Jesse Metcalfe from John Tucker Must Die. It’s a different guy! Once you get past that confusion, you can appreciate Jesse Metcalf’s performance for what it is: a nuanced portrayal of a man trying to find his footing after his primary identity (football) is taken away from him.
Actionable Insights for Fans of the Cast
If you enjoyed the performances in Rekindling Christmas, there are a few ways to dive deeper into their work and this genre:
- Check out the book: The movie is based on the novel by JT Clark. Reading the book gives you much more insight into the internal monologues of Annika and Jesse that the actors had to portray.
- Follow the Indie Scene: Ashley Atwood is a great example of an actor making waves in the indie world. Look for her name in film festival lineups; she often picks projects with strong female leads.
- Watch Michael Pare’s Classics: To truly appreciate his role as Marshall, go back and watch Streets of Fire. It shows the incredible range he has, from a young action hero to the seasoned mentor figure he plays here.
- Look for Christian Ganiere in Horror/Sci-Fi: If you liked the kid, he’s actually done some great work in much darker genres. It’s a total 180 from his role as TJ, but it shows his versatility.
The best way to support these actors is to watch their projects on official streaming platforms rather than bootlegs. Most of this cast populates the world of VOD (Video on Demand) and independent streaming services like Tubi or Freevee. Keeping their viewership numbers up helps them get cast in the next holiday favorite.
Ultimately, the cast of Rekindling Christmas succeeded because they didn't treat the movie like "just another gig." They brought a level of sincerity that makes the film rewatchable every December. Whether it's the chemistry between the leads or the veteran presence of Michael Pare, there is enough talent on screen to satisfy even the most cynical holiday movie viewer. Next time it pops up on your feed, give it a look for the performances alone; they’re doing more work than the script even asks for.