Holiday movies are usually pretty predictable, right? You get the snow, the cocoa, the inevitable misunderstanding, and a happy ending. But when Netflix dropped the news about the cast of Our Little Secret, people actually sat up and paid attention. This isn't just another generic "small town girl meets rugged lumberjack" story. It’s got real star power. We're talking Lindsay Lohan levels of star power.
Honestly, the casting is the main reason this movie works at all. If you’ve spent any time on TikTok or X lately, you know that the "Lohanance" is in full swing. Lindsay is back, and she's leaning hard into the cozy rom-com genre that we all secretly love, even if we pretend we're too cool for it. But who else is hiding in this ensemble? It’s a weirdly perfect mix of 2000s nostalgia, Broadway royalty, and some fresh faces that keep the energy from feeling too "throwback."
The Heavy Hitters: Lindsay Lohan and Ian Harding
Let's start with the elephant in the room. Lindsay Lohan plays Avery. After her success with Falling for Christmas and Irish Wish, she’s basically the new queen of Netflix holidays. In this one, she’s stuck in a nightmare scenario: spending Christmas with her boyfriend’s family, only to realize her ex-boyfriend is also there. And he’s dating her boyfriend’s sister. It’s messy. It’s awkward. It’s exactly what you want on a Tuesday night in December.
Then you have Ian Harding as Logan, the ex. If you grew up watching Pretty Little Liars, you know him as Ezra Fitz. He’s got that "charming but slightly annoying" vibe down to a science. The chemistry between Lohan and Harding is the engine of the movie. They don’t feel like strangers; they feel like two people who actually have a complicated, irritating history. That’s a hard thing to fake in a made-for-streaming movie where the filming schedule is probably about three weeks long.
Kristin Chenoweth Steals Every Single Scene
You can’t talk about the cast of Our Little Secret without mentioning Kristin Chenoweth. She plays Erica, the terrifying, high-maintenance matriarch of the family. Honestly? She’s a riot. Chenoweth is a Tony and Emmy winner, and she brings that massive Broadway energy to a character that could have been a flat "mean mom" trope. Instead, she’s sharp, funny, and deeply intimidating in a way that only a 4-foot-11 powerhouse can be.
She’s the foil. Every time Avery (Lohan) tries to blend in, Erica is there with a biting comment or a suspicious look. It’s a great bit of casting because it forces Lohan to play the "straight man" to Chenoweth’s absurdity.
🔗 Read more: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
The Supporting Players You Definitely Recognize
The rest of the family and social circle is filled out by people who make you go, "Wait, I know them from that one thing!"
Take Jon Rudnitsky, who plays Cameron, Avery's current boyfriend. He’s a Saturday Night Live alum, so he brings a bit of improvisational looseness to the role. He has to play the guy who is blissfully unaware that his girlfriend and his sister's boyfriend used to be a serious item. It’s a thankless job, but he makes it likable.
Then there’s Katie Baker as Emily, the sister. She has to navigate the weirdness of being the "new" girlfriend to the ex-boyfriend. It’s a bit of a tangled web. You also get appearances by:
- Tim Meadows (another SNL legend, keeping the comedy stakes high)
- Dan Lauria (The dad from The Wonder Years—pure nostalgia)
- Chris Parnell (Seriously, how many SNL people are in this?)
- Henry Czerny (The guy who is usually a villain in Mission: Impossible or Ready or Not, but here he's just... a guy)
It's a bizarrely over-qualified cast for a Christmas rom-com. Usually, these movies are filled with actors you've never seen before and will never see again. This feels like a reunion of everyone you liked on TV between 1995 and 2015.
Why This Specific Cast Works for Netflix
Netflix has figured something out. They know that Gen Z and Millennials are obsessed with "comfort watches." By assembling the cast of Our Little Secret with these specific names, they are hitting multiple demographic buttons at once.
💡 You might also like: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
You have Lohan for the Millennials who grew up on Mean Girls and The Parent Trap. You have Ian Harding for the PLL crowd. You have Chenoweth for the theater nerds. And you have the SNL alumni for the people who just want a decent laugh. It’s a calculated move.
But it’s not just about marketing. The movie works because these actors know how to handle the material. They know it’s cheesy. They know the plot relies on people not just having a basic conversation like normal humans. But they commit. When Chenoweth delivers a line about Christmas decorations, she acts like it’s Shakespeare. That commitment is what separates a "bad-good" movie from a "just bad" movie.
A Subtle Shift in Lindsay Lohan's Career
It’s interesting to watch Lohan in this. She’s transitioned into this "relatable adult" phase of her career. She isn't playing the ingenue anymore. In Our Little Secret, she’s a woman dealing with professional stress and relationship baggage. She looks comfortable. There’s a scene where she and Harding have to hide in a closet—classic trope—and her comedic timing is still as sharp as it was in 2003.
The direction by Stephen Herek probably helps. He directed The Mighty Ducks and Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure. He knows how to pace a movie so it doesn't drag, even when the script is hitting the usual beats.
Breaking Down the Chemistry
Is there "spark" between the leads? Kinda. It’s more of a "simmering resentment that turns into warmth" spark.
📖 Related: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
Logan (Harding) and Avery (Lohan) spend most of the movie trying to sabotage each other’s secrets while simultaneously protecting them. It creates a "us against the world" dynamic that usually wins audiences over. If they didn't have that chemistry, the whole premise—that they have to hide their past to avoid ruining Christmas—would feel too frustrating to watch. Because they're charming together, you're willing to go along with the ridiculousness of the lie.
What Most People Get Wrong About These Movies
A lot of critics look at a movie like this and dismiss it because it’s not "prestige cinema." But the cast of Our Little Secret proves that even "light" entertainment benefits from heavy-duty talent.
People think these roles are easy to play. They aren't. Being likable while your character is lying to everyone they love is a tightrope walk. If Lohan or Harding played it too smug, we’d hate them. If they played it too guilty, the movie would be a bummer. They hit that sweet spot of "stressed-out mess" that makes the audience root for them.
The Verdict on the Ensemble
If you’re looking for a deep, philosophical exploration of the human condition, you’re in the wrong place. But if you want to see Kristin Chenoweth be a menace while Lindsay Lohan tries to survive a holiday from hell, this cast delivers exactly what's on the tin.
The real standout, honestly, is the pacing. The supporting cast, especially the SNL vets, keep the side plots moving so you don't get bored of the central "secret." It’s a fast-paced 100 minutes that doesn’t overstay its welcome.
How to Watch and What to Look For
- Pay attention to the background: Some of the best lines come from Tim Meadows and Chris Parnell in the periphery.
- The "Nostalgia" factor: Look for the ways the wardrobe subtly nods to Lohan's earlier fashion eras without being too obvious about it.
- The Ending: Without giving it away, it’s one of the few holiday movies that actually acknowledges that sometimes things stay a little messy.
To get the most out of the experience, don't take it too seriously. The cast of Our Little Secret certainly didn't, and that's why it's a fun ride. If you're planning a movie night, pair this with Lohan's other recent Netflix hits for a full "Lohan Comeback" marathon. It's the best way to see how she's evolved her screen presence over the last few years while staying true to that comedic energy that made her a star in the first place.