Ever sit through a holiday movie and realize you recognize everyone, but you can’t quite place where you know them from? That’s usually the vibe with The Borrowed Christmas. It’s one of those indie holiday films that pops up on streaming services every December, and honestly, it’s got a weirdly cozy charm despite—or maybe because of—its modest production.
You’ve got the typical "grumpy rich guy" trope, a local business owner with a heart of gold, and a bunch of kids who basically drive the plot. But who are these people? Let's talk about The Borrowed Christmas cast because the mix of seasoned character actors and newcomers is actually what keeps this movie from being just another generic TV flick.
The Anchors of the Story: John-Clay Scott and Others
At the center of this whole thing is John-Clay Scott. He plays John Dale, a man who has everything but feels like he has nothing, especially when the holidays roll around. Scott isn't a household name like Tom Hanks, obviously. But he’s one of those actors who has been around the block. You might have spotted him in The Ultimate Gift or even older projects like The Last Castle.
He brings a certain gravity to the role. It’s hard to play "lonely billionaire" without coming off as a caricature, but he does it with a sort of quiet, tired energy that feels real.
Then you have Jeannine Kaspar. She plays Martha, the woman who runs the "Borrowed Christmas" shop. Kaspar has a pretty solid resume beyond this film. If you’re a fan of gritty TV, you might recognize her from Loudermilk or her guest spots on House of Cards and Law & Order: Special Victims Unit. She’s the emotional glue here. In the movie, her character is tasked with "renting" out a family and a Christmas experience to Dale. It’s a bizarre premise if you think about it too long, but she makes it feel grounded.
The Supporting Players You Might Recognize
It’s the ensemble that fills out the town.
- Valerie Whittington: She plays Sarah. Whittington is a veteran in the industry, having appeared in classics like The Outsiders (she was Bernie) and The Georgia Peaches. Seeing her in a small-budget holiday film is a nice nod to film history buffs.
- Grant Pfost: He plays the young kid, Jimmy. Child actors in these films can be hit or miss, but Pfost handles the "earnest kid" role without being too saccharine.
- The Rest of the "Borrowed" Family: The movie relies on a group of kids and actors who represent the family John Dale "borrows." Most of these are local talents or actors who specialize in faith-based and family-friendly cinema, which was the primary target audience for the production company, Crystal Creek Media.
Why the Casting Works for This Specific Movie
Low-budget holiday movies often fail because the acting feels stiff. The Borrowed Christmas avoids that trap mostly because the lead actors actually have chemistry. They don't overact.
👉 See also: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
Honestly, the film’s director, Dale Fabrigar, has a knack for this. He’s directed a ton of these types of movies—D-Railed, Lonely Boy, The Onania Club—so he knows how to get a performance out of a cast on a tight schedule. He chose people who look like they belong in a small town. They don't look like "Hollywood" versions of normal people; they look like your neighbors.
That’s a big part of the appeal.
The Production Context
You have to understand where this movie came from. It wasn't a massive Warner Bros. release. It was filmed primarily in Northwest Arkansas. If you look closely at some of the background scenes, you’ll see local landmarks from Siloam Springs and Fayetteville.
Because it was a local production, a lot of the background The Borrowed Christmas cast and minor speaking roles were filled by people from the community. This gives the movie a "community theater" feel, but in a high-def, professional way. It adds a layer of authenticity that you don't get when a movie is filmed on a backlot in Burbank.
The film is based on a book by Jerry B. Jenkins. If that name sounds familiar, it should. He’s the guy who co-wrote the Left Behind series. Knowing that helps explain the tone of the movie. It’s wholesome. It’s got a message. The actors knew exactly what kind of movie they were making, and they leaned into the sincerity of it.
Common Misconceptions About the Cast
People often confuse this movie with other "Borrowed" or "Christmas" titled films. There are about fifty movies with "Christmas" in the title released every year.
✨ Don't miss: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
- Is it a Hallmark movie? Surprisingly, no. While it feels like one, it was produced by Crystal Creek Media.
- Is David Tennant in this? No. People often confuse this with The Nativity or other UK productions because of the title's similarity.
- Was it filmed in a studio? Nope. As mentioned, the cast was on location in Arkansas, dealing with real weather and real buildings.
Behind the Scenes Dynamics
Talk to anyone who has worked on a Fabrigar set, and they’ll tell you it’s fast-paced. When you have a cast like this, there isn't time for fifty takes.
John-Clay Scott and Jeannine Kaspar had to do a lot of the heavy lifting. The script requires John Dale to go from a cynical loner to someone who appreciates the "borrowed" family. That transition happens mostly through facial expressions and subtext, not just dialogue. If the actors weren't up to the task, the whole movie would have collapsed under the weight of its own premise.
Martha, played by Kaspar, serves as the audience surrogate. She’s the one asking the questions we’re all thinking. "Why would a grown man want to rent a Christmas?" Her performance makes the answer feel poignant rather than creepy.
The Impact of the Script on the Acting
The dialogue isn't Sorkin-level sharp, but it’s functional. It gives the actors room to breathe.
One of the most interesting things about The Borrowed Christmas cast is how they handle the theme of "belonging." In the film, the characters are essentially performing for each other. Dale is performing as a father figure; the kids are performing as his children. There’s a meta-layer to the acting here. The actors are playing characters who are also "acting" within the story.
It’s actually kinda brilliant if you look at it from a technical standpoint.
🔗 Read more: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Where Are They Now?
Since the film came out, the cast has moved on to various projects.
- Jeannine Kaspar continues to work steadily in television and independent film. She’s become a bit of a staple in the indie circuit.
- John-Clay Scott remains active in the Southeast acting community and continues to take roles in faith-based and family dramas.
- The Child Actors: Many of the kids in the "borrowed" family have either returned to normal life or moved into theater. This is common for regional productions where the talent is sourced locally.
What You Should Take Away
If you’re planning to watch The Borrowed Christmas this year, don't go in expecting a $100 million blockbuster. Go in for the performances.
The cast does a lot with a little. They take a story about a lonely man and turn it into a genuine reflection on what family actually means—even if that family is "borrowed" for a weekend. It’s about the intention behind the holiday, not just the decorations.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Actors
If you're a fan of the film or interested in how these types of movies are put together, here are a few things to keep in mind:
- Watch the background: Since this was filmed on location, pay attention to the set dressing. It’s a masterclass in how to make a small budget look like a million bucks.
- Follow the actors on social media: Many of the cast members from The Borrowed Christmas are very active and often share behind-the-scenes stories about the filming process in Arkansas.
- Check out the director's other work: If you liked the tone of this film, Dale Fabrigar has a massive filmography that spans multiple genres. It’s interesting to see how he directs different types of casts.
- Look for regional film festivals: Films like this often get their start or find their audience through regional festivals. It’s a great way to support the "non-Hollywood" side of the industry.
The real magic of The Borrowed Christmas cast isn't their fame—it's their ability to make a high-concept, slightly wacky premise feel like a story about people you actually know. That's a harder job than it looks. Next time it pops up on your feed, give it a shot and see if you can spot those Arkansas landmarks in the background. It’s worth it for the cozy factor alone.