So, you just finished the show. Or maybe you're sitting on your couch wondering if it's worth the binge. Either way, the heavy lifting in Amazon Prime Video’s reimagining of the 1992 classic isn't just the baseball—it's the people. A League of Their Own 2022 cast had some massive shoes to fill, considering they were following up on icons like Geena Davis and Lori Petty. But honestly? They didn't just fill them. They bought a whole new pair of cleats.
Abbi Jacobson didn't just co-create the thing; she anchored it as Carson Shaw. You might know her from Broad City, where she was basically the queen of awkward-yet-lovable chaos. Here, she trades the New York City streets for a dusty diamond in Rockford, Illinois. It’s a huge shift. She plays Carson with this nervous, fluttering energy that feels painfully real for anyone who’s ever been terrified of their own desires.
Then there’s Chanté Adams. Man, she’s a powerhouse. Playing Max Chapman, she carries the entire weight of the "parallel story" that the original movie mostly ignored—the fact that Black women weren't allowed in the AAGPBL. Her performance is the heartbeat of the show.
Why the A League of Their Own 2022 cast works so well
It’s about chemistry. Pure and simple. When you look at the Peaches, they don’t feel like actors who met at a table read three days before filming. They feel like a team.
D'Arcy Carden plays Greta Gill, and if you were a fan of The Good Place, prepare to be shocked. Gone is the "not a girl" Janet. Instead, we get this glamorous, sharp-edged, deeply protective woman who knows exactly how to navigate a world that wants to put her in a box. The tension between Carden and Jacobson is what drives the emotional stakes of the first season. It’s messy. It’s beautiful.
But it’s not just the leads.
- Gbemisola Ikumelo as Clance. Honestly, she might be the funniest person on the show. Her friendship with Max is the most grounded relationship in the series.
- Roberta Colindrez as Lupe. She brings this quiet, simmering intensity. She’s the pitcher with the chip on her shoulder, and every time she’s on screen, you feel that pressure.
- Kelly McCormack as Jess. She’s the rough-and-tumble shortstop who looks like she walked straight out of a 1940s newsreel.
- Priscilla Delgado as Esti. The youngest, the one struggling with the language barrier, providing a lot of the heart.
Let’s be real for a second. Some people wanted a shot-for-shot remake of the movie. They wanted a new Tom Hanks. They didn’t get that. Instead, Nick Offerman stepped in as Dove Porter. It’s a different vibe. He’s not a lovable drunk; he’s a guy who’s kind of a jerk and then, well, he just leaves. It’s a subversion of what we expected.
💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Breaking down the Rockford Peaches lineup
When you look at the A League of Their Own 2022 cast, you’re seeing a deliberate attempt to represent the people who were actually there in history but erased from the celluloid version.
Kate Berlant plays Maybelle Fox. If you know Kate’s comedy, you know she’s a master of the "hyper-specific weirdo." She brings this manic, nervous energy to Maybelle that provides much-needed levity when things get heavy. And they do get heavy. The show deals with racism, homophobia, and the sheer physical toll of playing professional ball in skirts. Yes, skirts. They really played in those.
Melanie Field plays Jo Deluca. She’s Greta’s best friend, the muscle, the broad with the big heart and the even bigger swing. Her chemistry with D'Arcy Carden feels like a lifelong bond. You believe they’ve traveled the country together, dodging trouble in every city.
The Max Chapman storyline actors
The show is basically two shows in one. While the Peaches are playing at the stadium, Max Chapman is trying to find any way to pitch. This is where the A League of Their Own 2022 cast really shines in terms of depth.
Saidah Arrika Ekulona and Alex Désert play Max’s parents. Her mom, Toni, owns a salon and wants a stable life for her daughter. Her dad, Edgar, is the supportive bridge. The scenes in the salon feel lived-in. They feel warm. Then you have Max’s Uncle Bertie, played by Lea Robinson. This was a massive moment for TV—a trans-masculine character in a 1940s period piece. Robinson plays Bertie with such dignity and joy that it completely changes Max’s perspective on what her life could actually look like.
It’s rare to see a show give so much real estate to the "supporting" cast. But here, nobody feels like a sidekick. Even the "antagonists"—if you can call them that—like the rigid chaperones or the skeptical scouts, are played with layers.
📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
The controversy and the cancellation
It’s impossible to talk about the A League of Their Own 2022 cast without mentioning the elephant in the room: the show was canceled. Then it was renewed for a short final season. Then it was canceled again.
Fans were devastated. The cast was vocal. Abbi Jacobson didn't hold back on social media, calling out the "bullshit" of the decision-making process. The show had a massive, dedicated following, specifically among the LGBTQ+ community, because it was one of the few pieces of media that didn't treat "being different" as a tragedy. It treated it as a community.
People often ask if the show failed because of the cast. No. Absolutely not. The performances were universally praised. Most critics pointed toward "internal restructuring" at Amazon and the 2023 strikes as the real culprits. It’s a shame, honestly, because the ensemble was just hitting their stride.
Where are they now?
Since the show ended, the A League of Their Own 2022 cast has stayed busy.
- Chanté Adams has moved on to major film projects and continues to be one of the most sought-after young actresses in Hollywood.
- D'Arcy Carden is everywhere, from voice acting to guest spots on hit comedies.
- Abbi Jacobson is likely working on her next big creative swing. She has a knack for finding stories that feel personal but look universal.
It’s interesting to see how the fans have kept the show alive. There are still active hashtags, fan art, and "Save the Show" campaigns years later. That doesn’t happen unless the actors made you care.
Real history vs. The show's fiction
Did the A League of Their Own 2022 cast represent real people? Sorta.
👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
The characters are fictional, but they are composites of real women. Max Chapman is heavily inspired by Mamie "Peanut" Johnson, Toni Stone, and Connie Morgan—three women who actually played in the Negro American League because they weren't allowed in the women’s league. Carson Shaw is loosely based on the real-life letters found by the creators, detailing the secret romances that happened behind the scenes of the AAGPBL.
The show did the work. They consulted with Maybelle Blair, a real-life original player who came out as gay at the age of 95 during the show's promotion. Having her blessing meant everything to the cast. It gave the whole project a level of legitimacy that a standard reboot wouldn't have had.
Looking back at the ensemble's impact
The legacy of the A League of Their Own 2022 cast isn't just a single season of television. It’s the way they opened the door for more diverse period pieces. We're used to seeing the 1940s as a sepia-toned world of straight, white people in suits and dresses. This cast showed the color, the queer joy, and the grit that actually existed.
If you haven't watched it yet, don't let the "canceled" status scare you off. The eight episodes we got are a complete journey in many ways. You get to see a group of women find themselves on a baseball diamond. You see them fail. You see them win.
Actionable insights for fans and creators
If you’re a fan of the show or someone looking to break into the industry, there are a few things to take away from how this cast and show were handled:
- Follow the actors' social media: Many of the cast members, like Kelly McCormack and Gbemisola Ikumelo, are also writers and directors. Following their work is the best way to support the "spirit" of the show.
- Research the real AAGPBL: The National Women’s Baseball Hall of Fame has incredible resources. The real stories are just as wild as the show.
- Support diverse storytelling: The reason shows like this get canceled is often "data-driven." If you want more shows with casts like this, watch them early, talk about them online, and show the "algorithm" that there is an audience for it.
- Check out the 1992 film again: It’s a great companion piece. Seeing the two versions side-by-side helps you appreciate the risks the 2022 cast took.
The Rockford Peaches might not be taking the field for a Season 2, but the impact of that 2022 lineup is pretty much set in stone. They took a beloved property and made it something entirely their own, which is about the hardest thing to do in Hollywood. They swung for the fences. In my book, they hit it out of the park.