If you spend any time on the "Stoolie" side of the internet, you’ve probably heard Dave Portnoy mention the First Lady of Barstool. He isn't talking about a current girlfriend or some new corporate executive. Honestly, he’s talking about Renee Portnoy.
Even though they split up nearly a decade ago, the answer to who is Dave Portnoy's wife is still technically Renee. It’s a weird situation. Most people assume that when a high-profile couple announces a separation in a blog post—which Dave did way back in 2017—a divorce follows a few months later. That didn't happen here. As of early 2026, they are still legally husband and wife, and the reasons why are actually pretty wild.
The First Lady of Barstool Explained
Renee Satterthwaite met Dave long before he was "El Presidente" with a $150 million net worth. We're talking 2005. Back then, Barstool Sports was a gambling newspaper Dave was hand-delivering in South Boston. Renee was actually one of the people he recruited to help pass out those papers.
They got married in 2009. For years, she was the steady hand behind the scenes while Dave was busy picking fights with NFL commissioners and eating pizza. Fans loved her. She was dubbed the "First Lady" because she was there during the "hamburger days"—the lean years when Dave couldn't even afford a decent lunch.
📖 Related: Is There Actually a Wife of Tiger Shroff? Sorting Fact from Viral Fiction
Renee isn't just a "celebrity wife" type, though. She’s a serious equestrian and has spent years working in the horse supply industry, specifically with a company called SmartPak. She also runs her own dog rescue, Renee Rescues. While Dave is out being loud on social media, she’s mostly kept to herself in Nantucket or Florida, focusing on animal welfare.
Why the Divorce Was Actually Denied
So, why are they still married? It basically comes down to a judge in Massachusetts being confused by how much they trust each other.
Last year, Dave revealed on The Sage Steele Show that they actually tried to get a divorce. They walked into court with an agreement they both liked. But the judge looked at Dave’s massive wealth—which includes a $42 million Nantucket estate and a $14 million Miami mansion—and decided the deal wasn't "equitable" for Renee.
👉 See also: Bea Alonzo and Boyfriend Vincent Co: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The court basically told her, "He’s worth way more than what you're asking for, you need to take half."
Renee's response? She didn't want half.
Because they couldn't agree to the court's version of fairness, the judge denied the divorce. It’s a bizarre "problem" to have. Dave has been very open about the fact that Renee still has full access to his bank accounts. He trusts her implicitly. He’s said multiple times that if she wanted to empty his accounts and disappear, she could. She just doesn't.
The Current State of Dave's Love Life
Just because he’s still legally married doesn't mean Dave is living a solitary life. He’s had a few high-profile relationships since the split.
✨ Don't miss: What Really Happened With Dane Witherspoon: His Life and Passing Explained
- Silvana Mojica: They dated for about three years, starting in 2021. It was a very public relationship, often featured on the BFFs podcast. They broke up in late 2023 because, as Dave put it, they wanted different things in the long run.
- Camryn D'Aloia: In April 2025, Dave finally confirmed he was dating Camryn (often called "Cam"). She’s much younger than him—about 22 years—and works in social media marketing. They were first spotted at a Celtics game, which Dave initially tried to play off as "unfortunate" because he didn't want the paparazzi attention so soon after his previous breakup.
Interestingly, Dave’s exes seem to stay in the orbit. He even let Silvana stay at his Montauk house over the summer in 2024 while he was in Nantucket. He’s a loyalty guy. If you were there for him, he seems to take care of you.
What This Means for the Future
Technically, Dave and Renee plan to try the divorce process again in Florida, where the laws might be a bit more flexible regarding their "fluid" financial arrangement. But there's no rush. They are still best friends.
If you're following the saga of who is Dave Portnoy's wife, the takeaway is that it’s a legal title more than a romantic one at this point. They’ve built a life and a fortune together, and they seem content to let the legalities sort themselves out whenever the courts catch up to their unique friendship.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Follow the Philanthropy: If you want to support the causes the "First Lady" cares about, look into Renee Rescues or the animal welfare organizations Dave often promotes, like the LifeLine Animal Project.
- Check the Jurisdiction: If you’re ever curious about their status, keep an eye on Florida court filings rather than Massachusetts, as that’s where they’ve indicated they will file next.
- Watch the Podcasts: Dave usually drops these personal bombshells on the BFFs podcast or high-profile interviews like Club Shay Shay, so those are your best bets for real-time updates.