Honestly, if you’ve been keeping up with the Charleston social scene lately, you know the vibe has shifted. For years, the biggest question in the Bravo universe was when Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo would finally get engaged or, at the very least, live in the same zip code. But that chapter closed at the end of 2024. Now, heading into 2026, the Southern Charm star isn't just sewing pillows alone in his big house. He’s moved on.
So, who is Craig Conover dating now? It basically comes down to one name that surfaced shortly after his public breakup: Natalie Buffett.
The Post-Paige Era
The split from Paige DeSorbo was a "mature conversation," according to her Giggly Squad podcast, but the aftermath was a bit messy. Craig admitted on Watch What Happens Live that he was "shocked" by the timing, even though fans saw the long-distance friction coming from a mile away. While Paige is now reportedly seeing Joe D’Amelio, Craig didn't stay single for long.
By March 2025, reports started swirling that Craig was seeing Natalie Buffett. If that name sounds familiar, it's probably because she previously dated Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott. She’s a 27-year-old model and influencer with a degree in civil engineering. Kinda the perfect mix for Craig, right? Brains and the aesthetic that fits the Charleston high life.
✨ Don't miss: The Billy Bob Tattoo: What Angelina Jolie Taught Us About Inking Your Ex
Why the Natalie Buffett Romance is Different
Craig hasn't been shy about why things are working with Natalie. During a spring 2025 appearance with Andy Cohen, he mentioned he was "very happy" and that he’d been reminded "everything happens for a reason."
- Location, Location, Location: Unlike the constant NYC-to-Charleston flights that defined his time with Paige, Natalie has been spotted spending significant time in the South.
- The Age Gap: Some fans on Reddit pointed out that Natalie is about ten years younger than Craig, which has sparked its own set of debates.
- A Shared Future: One of the biggest dealbreakers with Paige was her hesitation toward marriage and kids on Craig’s timeline. Natalie, meanwhile, has been seen in recent Southern Charm Season 11 episodes engaging with the "settling down" conversation in a way that seems more aligned with what Craig wants.
Wait, What About the Other Rumors?
You might have heard other names. In August 2025, some fans thought they saw Craig holding hands with Elizabeth Turner, a Guess model and PhD student. There were also some weirdly persistent rumors about him and his Southern Charm castmate Salley Carson after they were seen buying chickens together. Yeah, chickens.
But as of early 2026, those seem to be "friend group" distractions or short-lived flings. The most consistent presence in his life—and the one he’s actually admitted to being happy with on TV—is Natalie.
🔗 Read more: Birth Date of Pope Francis: Why Dec 17 Still Matters for the Church
The Southern Charm Season 11 Drama
If you’re watching the current season of Southern Charm, you’ve seen the "complicated love dynamic" Craig mentioned in recent interviews. He’s essentially navigating being a single man in Charleston for the first time in years, and it's chaotic. There’s a triangle (or maybe a square?) involving new cast members like Charley Manley and the aforementioned Salley.
However, Craig has been pretty firm about not wanting to get "sucked into the tornado" of certain castmates' drama. He told Austen Kroll in a recent episode that he’s over the chaos. This tracks with his public comments about being in a stable relationship with someone who isn't necessarily a permanent fixture of the Bravo drama machine—at least not yet.
What This Means for Your Watch List
If you're looking for the "actionable" takeaway here, it's that the Craig we knew—the one waiting by the phone for a text from New York—is gone. He’s focused on his five-year plan, which includes potentially spending more time out of the country and growing his brand, Sewing Down South.
💡 You might also like: Kanye West Black Head Mask: Why Ye Stopped Showing His Face
The relationship with Natalie Buffett seems to be his "stable base." While Paige DeSorbo has officially moved on and even defended her right to "giggle" through her own new relationship, Craig is leaning into the life he always said he wanted: a partner who is actually present in his daily life.
To stay truly updated on the status of this relationship, keep an eye on his Instagram stories around the weekend. That’s usually where the "soft launches" and vacation tags happen before they hit the tabloid cycle. Natalie and Craig were spotted in Colorado together for New Year's, which seems to be their "spot."
It’s clear Craig Conover isn't looking back. Whether Natalie becomes the one to finally get that "hubby" title remains to be seen, but for now, the pillow king of Charleston is definitely not sleeping alone.
Check out the latest episodes of Southern Charm on Wednesdays to see the messier parts of this transition play out in real-time.