The room is small. It’s crowded. You can almost smell the bitter herbs and the dusty air of a first-century Jerusalem upper room. When people search for the cast of The Chosen Last Supper, they usually aren't just looking for a dry IMDB list. They want to know how these specific actors—men we've watched for four seasons—managed to take the most famous meal in human history and make it feel like a gut-punch instead of a Sunday school painting.
It’s heavy.
Jonathan Roumie sits at the center, obviously. But the magic of this specific sequence in The Chosen isn't just about Jesus. It’s about the faces surrounding him. It’s about the way Paras Patel’s Matthew looks like he’s trying to memorize every word because his world is ending, or how Shahar Isaac’s Simon (Peter) is vibrating with a mix of ego and terror. This isn't Leonardo da Vinci’s version where everyone is posed perfectly on one side of a long table. This is messy. It's real.
The Core Twelve: Breaking Down the Cast of The Chosen Last Supper
Most of the guys at the table have been with us since the beginning. Jonathan Roumie plays Jesus with this incredible, weary tenderness that defines the scene. By the time they get to the Last Supper, the character knows what's coming. Roumie plays that burden perfectly—he's not a stoic statue; he’s a man saying goodbye to his best friends.
Then you have Shahar Isaac as Simon Peter. Throughout the series, Shahar has played Peter as the "tough guy" with a soft heart and a massive impulsive streak. During the Last Supper, you see that impulsiveness turn into a desperate kind of loyalty. It’s in the eyes.
Paras Patel as Matthew is perhaps the biggest fan favorite in this scene. His portrayal of Matthew as someone on the autism spectrum adds a layer of literalism to the Passover Seder that makes the "this is my body" moment hit differently. When Matthew looks at Jesus during the Last Supper, he isn't just seeing a Messiah; he’s seeing the only person who ever truly saw him.
The "Sons of Thunder" bring the heat, too. Giavani Cairo (Thaddeus) and Jordan Walker Ross (Little James) have fewer lines, but their presence matters because they represent the "everyman" at the table. Little James, specifically, has become a symbol for many viewers living with chronic pain or disability. Seeing him at that table, being served by Jesus, is a core emotional pillar of the sequence.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Abe Martell (Big James) and Noah James (Andrew) round out the inner circle. Noah James plays Andrew with a perpetual sense of anxiety that feels incredibly relatable in this high-stakes environment. He’s the guy wondering if they’re all about to die, and honestly, he’s right to worry.
The Judas Factor: Luke Dimyan’s Performance
You can’t talk about the cast of The Chosen Last Supper without focusing on Luke Dimyan. Playing Judas Iscariot is the ultimate "thankless" job in biblical acting. Everyone knows what you’re going to do. The audience hates you before you even open your mouth.
But Dimyan does something sneaky. He makes Judas sympathetic, or at least, understandable. In the lead-up to the Last Supper, we see his disillusionment. He isn't a cartoon villain twirling a mustache. He’s a guy who thinks he’s smarter than everyone else and believes Jesus is "missing the moment" to take political power. When he leaves the table, it doesn’t feel like a monster exiting; it feels like a tragedy. The way the rest of the cast reacts to him—or fails to see what’s happening—is one of the most tense bits of television produced in the last decade.
Why This Scene Breaks the Traditional Mold
Usually, when Hollywood does the Last Supper, it's very formal. People speak in King James English. They move slowly. It feels like a museum.
The Chosen creator Dallas Jenkins and his writing team (Ryan Swanson and Tyler Thompson) went the opposite direction. They leaned into the Jewishness of the event. This is a Seder. There’s joking. There’s confusion. There’s wine.
The cast had to balance the ritual of the Passover meal with the impending doom of the Passion. Joey Vahedi as Thomas brings that trademark skepticism. Thomas isn't "doubting" yet, but he’s the guy asking the logical questions that everyone else is too scared to ask.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Then there’s Yoshi Barrigas and later Reza Diako as Philip. The transition of actors for Philip was a talking point for fans, but by the time the Last Supper rolls around, the character's role as the "bridge" between the group and the outside world is firmly established.
And don't forget George H. Xanthis as John. The "beloved disciple" is often portrayed as feminine or weak in classical art. Xanthis plays him with a youthful, almost intense devotion that makes his proximity to Jesus at the table feel earned rather than just symbolic.
Behind the Scenes: The Weight of the Roles
Talking to the actors in interviews (like those on the The Chosen official YouTube channel or various podcasts), you get the sense that filming this was exhausting. They weren't just reciting lines; they were sitting in the culmination of years of character work.
The production design by James G. Gerber and the costumes by Cecile Walker play a huge role in helping the cast "get there." The textures of the tunics, the weight of the ceramic cups—it all grounds the performances. When you see Alaa Safi (Simon the Zealot) sitting there, you see a man who used to carry a dagger now holding a piece of matzo. That's a massive character arc told through a single casting choice and a seat at a table.
It's actually kind of wild how much the show relies on non-verbal acting here. Because the Last Supper is so dialogue-heavy in the Bible, the show has to find ways to fill the gaps between the famous verses. You see it in the way Austin Reed Alleman (Nathaniel) watches the door. You see it in the way the disciples argue about who is the greatest—a moment taken straight from the Gospel of Luke that most movies skip because it makes the apostles look like jerks. But this cast leans into the "jerkiness." It makes them human.
A Legacy of Casting
What really sticks with you about the cast of The Chosen Last Supper is the diversity. Not just in terms of ethnicity—which is much more historically accurate here than in the "Blue-Eyed Jesus" films of the 50s—but in terms of personality.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
You have:
- The intellectual (Matthew)
- The hot-head (Peter)
- The skeptic (Thomas)
- The dreamer (John)
- The political radical (Simon the Zealot)
Seeing these wildly different archetypes forced into a room together for a final meal is why the show works. It’s a chemistry experiment that finally boils over.
The show hasn't shied away from the fact that these men were flawed. Vanessa Benavente, who plays Mother Mary, isn't at the table for the meal itself in the traditional sense, but her presence in the periphery of the story adds the "mother’s heart" element that anchors the men's performances.
Key Takeaways for Fans and New Viewers
If you're re-watching the scene or preparing for it, keep your eyes on the background.
- Watch the reactions, not just the speaker. When Jesus says someone will betray him, don't look at Jesus. Look at the faces of the Twelve. The confusion is palpable.
- The seating arrangement matters. It’s not accidental. The proximity of John and Judas to Jesus is a direct nod to historical theories about how a triclinium (a U-shaped Roman-style table) would have been set up.
- The physical touch. This cast is very "touchy-feely." They hug, they lean on each other, they wash each other's feet. It breaks down the "holy icon" barrier and makes them feel like a family.
The brilliance of the cast of The Chosen Last Supper lies in their ability to make a 2,000-year-old story feel like it’s happening for the first time. You aren't watching a reenactment; you're eavesdropping on a private moment.
To get the most out of these performances, it's worth looking into the "Deep Dive" videos released by the show's creators, where they break down the Midrashic influences and the historical research that went into the script. Understanding the Passover rituals being performed by the cast adds a whole new layer to why they look so solemn or why certain prayers are being chanted.
Ultimately, the cast succeeds because they don't play the "ending." They play the moment. They don't act like they know Sunday is coming; they act like Friday is the end of the world. And that is why we keep watching.
Actionable Insights:
- Study the Seder: To truly understand the cast's movements, look up the "Haggadah" or the order of a traditional Passover Seder. It explains why they drink multiple cups of wine and the significance of the bread.
- Follow the Cast: Many of the actors, like Paras Patel and Jonathan Roumie, share behind-the-scenes insights on their social media about the emotional toll of filming the Passion sequences.
- Watch for the Foot Washing: Pay close attention to the sequence in Season 4/5 where the foot washing occurs. It’s the best display of the cast’s ensemble chemistry outside of the meal itself.