The original film was a weird, sticky, practical-effects-heavy dream for horror fans. André Øvredal and Guillermo del Toro managed to take those traumatizing Stephen Gammell illustrations and turn them into something that actually felt like the books. But it’s been years. We’ve been waiting. Everyone wants to know who will make up the cast of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 2 and if the original kids are coming back to face whatever ink-drenched nightmare crawls out of the page next.
Honestly, the sequel talk has been a bit of a rollercoaster. It was officially greenlit back in 2020, with Øvredal returning to direct and Dan Hageman and Kevin Hageman handling the script. But then, the world stopped. Hollywood shifted. Now, as we look at the potential lineup, we have to balance what’s been "confirmed" in trades like Deadline with the reality of how much time has passed since the first film hit theaters in 2019. Those "kids" aren't exactly kids anymore.
The Returning Survivors: Who is Locked In?
If you watched the first movie, you know the ending wasn't exactly a closed door. Stella, played by Zoe Colletti, drove off with her father and Ruth (Natalie Ganzhorn), determined to find a way to bring back her friends who were absorbed by the book. It’s basically a guarantee that any discussion regarding the cast of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 2 starts with Zoe Colletti.
Stella is the heart of the franchise. She’s the writer. She’s the one who understands the mechanics of Sarah Bellows’ wrath. Without her, there isn't really a sequel—at least not a direct one. Reports suggest she is expected to return to lead the search for Auggie (Gabriel Rush) and Chuck (Austin Zajur).
Then there’s Ramón. Michael Garza’s character was a massive fan favorite. His chemistry with Stella provided the emotional anchor that kept the movie from just being a series of monster set-pieces. Since Ramón was drafted at the end of the first film, a sequel would likely have to address his time in the Vietnam War, or perhaps his return. This adds a layer of period-piece complexity that most horror sequels usually ignore.
The Problem with Aging Cast Members
Here is the thing.
Time moves faster than production schedules. Gabriel Rush and Austin Zajur, who played the "disappeared" friends, have grown up. If the sequel picks up exactly where the first one left off, the production might face a Stranger Things or IT: Chapter Two situation where the actors look significantly older than the timeline allows.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
There are a few ways the writers could handle this:
- The Time Jump: They set the movie in the early 1970s, allowing the actors to age naturally.
- The "Limbo" Effect: Since the characters were taken by the book, they could argue that time works differently inside Sarah Bellows' realm.
- Recasting: This is the nuclear option. Fans usually hate it, but if the story demands a 13-year-old and the actor is now 24, it’s a tough sell.
Most insiders believe Øvredal will stick with his original players. The chemistry was too good to mess with. Plus, Guillermo del Toro is known for his loyalty to his performers.
New Faces and New Monsters
You can't have a horror sequel without fresh meat. While no official names have been dropped for new characters in the cast of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 2, the source material gives us some massive clues. Alvin Schwartz wrote three books. There are dozens of stories left to adapt.
Imagine a new group of teenagers in a different town who stumble across the aftermath of the Mill Valley incident. Or, more likely, Stella meets other "victims" of urban legends as she travels the country looking for a way to break the curse.
Stories likely to influence new casting:
- The Dream: This features the pale woman with black hair. We saw her in the first movie, but a new cast member could play the "dreamer" who encounters her in a different context.
- The Dead Man's Hand: This would require a more adult-leaning cast, perhaps bringing in older actors to play high-stakes gamblers or skeptical townies.
- High Beams: A classic "killer in the backseat" story that would need a strong female lead for a tense, claustrophobic sequence.
The Creative Backbone: Behind the Scenes
While we focus on the actors, the "cast" of a movie like this includes the creature performers. Javier Botet, the man who played the Toe Monster, is a legend in the industry. He’s the guy you call when you need something to look physically impossible. Whether he returns as a new entity or a recurring nightmare is a major point of interest for the sequel's production.
The Hageman brothers have mentioned in various interviews that they want to dive deeper into the lore of the Bellows family. This means we might see more flashback sequences. If that happens, we’ll need actors to play younger versions of the town's founding families, or perhaps more of Sarah Bellows herself.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
It's a tricky balance.
You want to honor the books, but you also have to build a cohesive cinematic universe. The first film was a "greatest hits" album. The second one needs to be a deep cut.
What’s Taking So Long?
It’s frustrating. We know.
The delay in finalizing the cast of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 2 comes down to rights, studio shifts, and the sheer scale of the practical effects required. Paramount took over the project from CBS Films, and whenever a property changes hands, there’s a period of "development hell" where scripts are poked and prodded.
Øvredal confirmed in late 2023 and early 2024 that the project is still very much alive. He’s been busy with The Last Voyage of the Demeter, but Scary Stories remains a priority. The script is reportedly in a place where they are happy with it, meaning casting calls are likely the next big hurdle.
Anticipated Character Arcs
If the sequel follows the breadcrumbs left in the first film, the character arcs will be much darker. Stella is no longer a shy girl hiding in her room; she’s a survivor with a mission. Ramón isn't just a drifter; he’s a veteran (or soon to be one). This shift in tone suggests that the cast of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 2 will need to bring a more mature, seasoned energy to their roles.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
We’re looking at a movie that deals with grief and the refusal to let go. That’s heavy stuff for a "kids' horror" flick. But that’s exactly why the first one worked. It didn’t talk down to the audience.
Summary of Known Details
To keep it simple, here is the current state of the production:
The director is André Øvredal. He’s back. The writers are the Hageman brothers. They’re back. The expected returning cast includes Zoe Colletti, Michael Garza, and Natalie Ganzhorn. The plot will likely involve the search for the characters taken by the book in the first film, specifically targeting stories from More Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark and Scary Stories 3: More Tales to Chill Your Bones.
Production hasn't officially moved into the "active filming" stage yet, which is why a formal cast list hasn't been plastered across every billboard in Hollywood. We’re in the quiet phase before the storm.
Next Steps for Fans
If you want to stay ahead of the curve on the cast of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 2, you should keep a close eye on the social media accounts of Zoe Colletti and André Øvredal. Often, these actors drop subtle hints—a photo of a script, a reunion dinner, or a visit to a prosthetic makeup studio—long before a press release hits the wire.
Additionally, revisiting the original Alvin Schwartz books is the best way to predict who might be cast next. Look for characters in stories like "The Bride" or "The Window." These are prime candidates for the sequel's centerpiece scares.
The wait is long, but for a franchise that relies on the "slow creep" of ink on a page, maybe that’s just part of the experience. Keep your eyes on the trades, but keep your lights on tonight. You never know what’s writing itself into existence.