You know that feeling when you're watching a movie and you keep thinking, "Wait, I know that person from somewhere"? That happens a lot with the Significant Other cast. It’s a lean, mean production. No massive ensembles. No distracting cameos from A-listers trying to steal the spotlight. Just a handful of people in the woods, which is exactly why the performances had to be top-tier for the movie to even function.
Most people recognize the leads immediately, but the "how" and "why" of their casting is actually what makes this Paramount+ original work. It’s a sci-fi horror blend that dropped in 2022, and honestly, if the chemistry between the two main actors had been off by even an inch, the whole twist-heavy plot would have crumbled like a stale cracker.
The Heavy Lifters: Maika Monroe and Jake Lacy
If you’re a fan of "elevated horror" (whatever that actually means these days), you know Maika Monroe. She’s basically the modern queen of the genre. From her breakout in It Follows to the chilling Longlegs, she has this specific way of looking terrified yet incredibly capable at the same time. In Significant Other, she plays Ruth.
Ruth is complicated. She’s dealing with intense anxiety and a massive life decision, and Monroe plays that vulnerability without making the character feel weak. It’s a tough balance. One minute she’s hyperventilating in a tent, and the next, she’s fighting for her life in the Oregon wilderness.
Then you have Jake Lacy.
If you watched the first season of The White Lotus, you probably spent six hours wanting to punch his character in the face. He’s the master of playing the "nice guy who might actually be a jerk." In the Significant Other cast, he plays Harry, Ruth's long-term boyfriend. He’s cheery. He’s supportive. He’s... maybe a bit too much? Lacy’s performance is the anchor of the movie because he has to flip between being a lovable goofball and something much more sinister once the plot starts to unravel.
Why this duo works
The director duo, Dan Berk and Robert Olsen, clearly knew what they were doing here. They needed actors who could carry a film with almost no other dialogue for 90 minutes.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
- Maika Monroe brings the indie-horror credibility.
- Jake Lacy brings that mainstream, deceptive charm.
They aren't just reading lines; they're playing off each other's physical energy. When they're hiking through those massive trees, you can feel the tension. It’s uncomfortable. It’s real. It feels like a real couple on a trip that is slowly going south.
The Supporting Players (The ones you might have missed)
While Monroe and Lacy take up 95% of the screen time, the rest of the Significant Other cast serves as the "canary in the coal mine" for the audience. They are the reality check.
- Teal Sherer as Dolores: You might recognize her from her work in The Guild or her advocacy for performers with disabilities. In this film, she plays a hiker that Ruth and Harry encounter. Her presence provides a brief moment of "normalcy" before things get weird.
- Loudon McCleery as Jimmy: He’s the other half of the hiking couple.
These roles are small. Really small. But in a movie that feels so isolated, seeing other humans is like a jolt to the system. It reminds the audience that there is a world outside of Ruth and Harry’s psychological breakdown, which actually makes their isolation feel even more claustrophobic.
The Oregon Landscape as a Character
Okay, it’s a bit of a cliché to say "the setting is a character," but in this case, it’s true. The movie was filmed in the Pacific Northwest—specifically places like Silver Falls State Park and the Oregon coast. The towering Douglas firs and the constant dampness aren't just background scenery. They are part of the cast.
The environment dictates how the actors move. You see them slipping on mud, struggling with steep inclines, and getting lost in the repetitive nature of the forest. The cinematography by Kevin Sarnoff uses the scale of the trees to make the Significant Other cast look tiny and insignificant. It’s a visual representation of how small Ruth feels in her own life.
Behind the Scenes: The Directorial Vision
Dan Berk and Robert Olsen didn't just stumble into this. They’ve worked with Maika Monroe before on Villains (2019), which also featured a small, tight-knit cast. That history matters. There is a shorthand between a director and an actor that you can’t fake.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
They knew Monroe could handle the physical demands of the role. The movie involves a lot of running, falling, and getting dirty. It’s not a "glamour" role. Honestly, half the time, Monroe looks exhausted, which is exactly how someone would look if they were being hunted by an alien entity while having a panic attack.
Addressing the "Twist" and Performance
Without spoiling the whole thing for the three people who haven't seen it, the movie shifts gears about halfway through. This is where the Significant Other cast—specifically Jake Lacy—really earns their paycheck.
Lacy has to change his entire acting style mid-movie. He goes from a "human boyfriend" to something... else. It’s a masterclass in subtle physical acting. His posture changes. His vocal inflections get just a little bit flatter. It’s creepy precisely because it’s so close to his original character but just "off" enough to trigger your uncanny valley response.
Why people are still talking about this cast
Usually, "straight-to-streaming" movies are forgotten in a week. Significant Other stuck around because the performances felt personal.
- It deals with the fear of commitment.
- It looks at how we don't really know the people we love.
- It uses sci-fi tropes to talk about real-world anxiety.
When Ruth talks about her fear of getting married or her history with her parents, Monroe makes it feel like a heavy drama. Then, ten minutes later, she’s dealing with extraterrestrial goo. The cast bridges that gap between "ridiculous sci-fi" and "grounded human emotion."
How to watch and what to look for
If you’re going back for a rewatch, or seeing it for the first time, pay attention to the first 20 minutes. Look at the way Lacy’s character, Harry, reacts to Ruth’s rejection of his proposal. The way he handles that disappointment sets the stage for everything that follows.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
You can find Significant Other on Paramount+. It’s a quick watch—only 84 minutes. In an era where every movie is three hours long, that brevity is a blessing.
Next Steps for Fans of the Cast
If you liked Maika Monroe here, you absolutely have to watch Watchman or The Guest. She specializes in these "final girl with a brain" roles. For Jake Lacy fans, check out his turn in A Friend of the Family on Peacock. He plays a much darker, much more manipulative version of the "nice guy" trope he explored in Significant Other.
If you're interested in the filming locations, a trip to Silver Falls State Park in Oregon is the move. Just maybe don't go alone, and definitely don't follow any weird glowing lights into the woods. Pack a raincoat, some sturdy boots, and maybe skip the marriage proposal until you're back in a well-lit restaurant.
The real takeaway from the Significant Other cast is that you don't need a hundred actors and a billion-dollar budget to make a compelling movie. You just need two people who are willing to get very muddy and very weird in the woods for a few weeks. It’s a reminder that character-driven horror is often the most effective kind, especially when the "monsters" we’re fighting are just as much inside our heads as they are in the trees.