You know that feeling when you're scrolling through a streaming service and a movie poster just looks familiar? That's exactly how most people end up finding The Holiday Exchange. It’s one of those cozy, romantic comedies that leans heavily into the "city person meets country person" trope, but what keeps people watching isn't just the snowy scenery or the predictable (yet satisfying) plot. It’s the actors.
Finding the full list of the cast of The Holiday Exchange can be a bit of a hunt because there are actually a few movies with very similar titles. We aren't talking about the Kate Winslet classic The Holiday. We’re looking at the 2024 Tubi original that caught everyone by surprise with its genuine charm and surprisingly sharp chemistry between the leads.
It’s easy to dismiss these seasonal rom-coms as fluff. But honestly? The performances in this one elevate it. Let’s get into who these people are and where you’ve definitely seen them before.
Taylor Frey Leads the Way
Taylor Frey plays Wilde in the film, and if he looks familiar, it’s probably because he’s been a staple in the holiday movie circuit for a while. But he’s not just a "Christmas movie guy." Frey has some serious credits to his name, including a role in It Chapter Two and a long history on Broadway in shows like The Book of Mormon and How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.
In The Holiday Exchange, Frey brings a specific kind of neurotic energy that works perfectly for a character swapping his high-paced life for something slower. He isn't just playing a caricature; he makes the transition feel earned. Most actors in this genre play the "stressed executive" with one note—constant yelling into a cell phone—but Frey adds a layer of vulnerability that makes you actually root for him to find love.
He’s also a producer on the film. That’s a detail most people miss. When an actor is also producing, they usually have a much tighter grip on the tone of the movie. It explains why the dialogue feels a bit more natural and less like a greeting card than some of its competitors on other networks.
Sam Doane and the Rest of the Crew
Opposite Frey is Sam Doane, who plays Oliver. The chemistry between Wilde and Oliver is the engine of the entire movie. If that didn't work, the whole thing would fall apart like a soggy gingerbread house. Doane has a grounded presence that balances out Frey’s more frenetic energy.
The supporting cast of The Holiday Exchange is equally interesting. You have Rick Cosnett, who many fans will recognize immediately from The Flash or The Vampire Diaries. Seeing Cosnett in a holiday rom-com is a bit of a pivot from the high-stakes supernatural drama he’s known for, but he fits right in. He has this effortless charisma that makes the small-town setting feel lived-in rather than like a movie set.
✨ Don't miss: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
Then there's the veteran presence. Camilla Banus, a long-time favorite from Days of Our Lives, brings that daytime TV polished professionalism to the screen. She knows how to hit an emotional beat without overdoing it.
Why This Specific Cast Matters
Usually, holiday movies are cast based on who is available in Vancouver during a specific two-week window in July. You can often tell when the actors just met five minutes before the cameras started rolling.
This movie feels different.
The cast of The Holiday Exchange seems to actually enjoy being in each other's orbit. There is a specific scene in the kitchen—no spoilers, but it involves a bit of a mess—where the timing is so tight it almost feels improvised. That kind of rapport is rare in a production that likely had a very tight shooting schedule and a modest budget.
It's also worth noting the diversity in the casting. The film doesn't make a "big deal" out of its LGBTQ+ lead characters; it just treats the romance with the same sincerity and tropes as any other holiday movie. This shift in the genre has been happening over the last few years, and seeing established actors like Frey and Cosnett lead the charge is a sign of where the industry is heading.
Behind the Scenes: The Director’s Vision
Jake Helgren directed this one. If you watch a lot of TV movies, you know Helgren’s name. He’s a veteran of the genre. He knows exactly how to light a room so it looks like there are a thousand candles burning, and he knows how to coach his actors to deliver lines that could be cheesy in a way that feels heartfelt.
Helgren often works with the same rotation of actors. This creates a "repertory theater" feel. When you see the same faces popping up in different configurations across several movies, it builds a sense of familiarity for the audience. It’s comforting. It’s the cinematic equivalent of a warm blanket.
🔗 Read more: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
Spotting the Supporting Players
It isn't just the leads. Look closely at the background and the secondary characters. You’ll see:
- Kyle Dean Massey: Another Broadway powerhouse (Pippin, Next to Normal). His inclusion is a nod to the theater community that Frey is so deeply embedded in.
- Tess Kartel: She brings a certain spark to her scenes that keeps the momentum going during the middle-act "slump" that most rom-coms suffer from.
The casting director clearly had a mandate: get people who can actually act, not just people who look good in flannel.
Where Can You Watch Them Next?
If you enjoyed the cast of The Holiday Exchange, you don't have to wait until next December to see them again. Taylor Frey is constantly working, both in front of and behind the camera. Rick Cosnett is a regular at fan conventions and continues to take on roles that challenge his "pretty boy" image from his early CW days.
Many people don't realize that these holiday movies are often filmed in the middle of summer. Imagine wearing a heavy wool coat and a scarf in 90-degree heat while fake snow is being blown into your face by a giant fan. That takes a specific kind of talent—or at least a very high tolerance for sweating.
Common Misconceptions About the Movie
A lot of people confuse this film with The Holiday, as I mentioned earlier. Others think it’s a sequel to something else. It’s not. It stands alone.
Another misconception is that it’s only available on one platform. While it’s a "Tubi Original," distribution rights for these kinds of movies are fluid. You might find it on Amazon Prime, or even aired on local cable networks during the "Christmas in July" marathons.
Navigating the Holiday Movie Landscape
The reality is that there are hundreds of these movies produced every year. Most are forgettable. What makes the cast of The Holiday Exchange stand out is the lack of cynicism.
💡 You might also like: America's Got Talent Transformation: Why the Show Looks So Different in 2026
Sometimes, actors in these projects look like they’re just checking a box or waiting for their paycheck. Here, the performances feel intentional. Whether it’s the way Oliver looks at Wilde across a crowded room or the banter between the siblings, there is a level of craft that deserves a bit of recognition.
It’s easy to be a critic. It’s harder to make a movie that actually makes people feel good for 90 minutes.
The Impact of Casting Choices
When you cast people like Frey and Massey, who have huge followings in the Broadway world, you’re bringing in an audience that might not otherwise watch a Tubi original. It’s a smart business move. It also elevates the material. You’re getting "triple-threat" talents doing the heavy lifting in a genre that is often maligned for being low-effort.
How to Get the Most Out of Your Viewing
If you're going to watch it, do it right. Put your phone away. The plot isn't complex, but the little character moments in the cast of The Holiday Exchange are what make it worthwhile.
Watch for the chemistry. Watch for the way the actors handle the more ridiculous "small town" tropes.
And honestly? Pay attention to the credits. You’ll see a lot of the same names repeating across different roles—producers, writers, and actors swapping hats. It’s a tight-knit community of filmmakers who have mastered the art of the holiday feel-good flick.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
- Follow the actors on social media: Many of the cast members, especially Taylor Frey and Rick Cosnett, share "behind the scenes" photos that show the reality of filming holiday movies in the summer. It’s usually pretty funny.
- Check out the director's filmography: If you liked the vibe of this movie, look up Jake Helgren. He has a very specific style, and you'll likely enjoy his other projects like A Christmas to Treasure.
- Look for the Broadway connections: If you’re a fan of musical theater, look up the stage credits for Frey and Massey. It’ll give you a whole new appreciation for their acting range.
- Verify the title: Before you buy or rent, make sure you have the 2024 version. There are at least three other movies with "Holiday Exchange" in the title, and they are definitely not all created equal.
The cast of The Holiday Exchange proves that you don't need a hundred-million-dollar budget to make something that resonates. You just need the right people in the right roles, a bit of fake snow, and a script that doesn't take itself too seriously.
Next time you’re looking for something to watch while wrapping presents or just avoiding the cold, give this one a shot. You might find yourself becoming a fan of a few actors you hadn't really noticed before. That’s the real "gift" of these types of movies—they’re a gateway to discovering talent that’s been working hard in the industry for years, just waiting for the right snowy backdrop to shine.