Everyone loves a good underdog story. The narrative of the janitor who saved a billion-dollar company with a bag of spicy snacks is basically the American Dream in a red-and-yellow bag. For years, the world believed that one man, Richard Montañez, single-handedly came up with the idea for Flamin' Hot Cheetos after a broken machine left some corn puffs un-cheesed. He took them home, dusted them with chili powder, and the rest was history. Right?
Well, it’s complicated.
If you’ve seen the movie Flamin' Hot or read Montañez's memoir, you know the legend. But if you look at the corporate records from Frito-Lay in the late 1980s, you’ll find a much more corporate, less cinematic reality. The question of who invented Flamin' Hot Cheetos doesn't have a one-sentence answer. It’s a collision between a powerful personal legacy and the cold, hard receipts of a multinational snack empire.
The Legend of Richard Montañez
Richard Montañez started at the Frito-Lay plant in Rancho Cucamonga, California, as a janitor in 1976. He didn't speak much English at the time. He worked hard. By his own account, he took a CEO's "act like an owner" video message to heart. When a machine malfunctioned and produced plain Cheetos, he took a bunch home and experimented with flavors inspired by elote—Mexican street corn.
He pitched it. He wore a tie for the first time. He called the CEO, Roger Enrico.
According to Montañez, this was the birth of the spicy snack revolution. It’s a beautiful story about Latino ingenuity and the power of looking at a product through a different cultural lens. For decades, he traveled the world as a high-level executive at PepsiCo (which owns Frito-Lay), telling this story to packed rooms of inspired listeners. He became a folk hero. People saw him as the man who taught a massive corporation how to talk to the Hispanic market.
The 2021 Los Angeles Times Bombshell
Everything changed in May 2021. The Los Angeles Times published a massive investigative report that threw a giant wrench into the "Janitor-to-Executive" narrative. They interviewed dozens of former employees and dug through archived files. Their conclusion?
✨ Don't miss: Is US Stock Market Open Tomorrow? What to Know for the MLK Holiday Weekend
Richard Montañez didn't invent Flamin' Hot Cheetos.
The report pointed toward a group of professionals in Plano, Texas, led by a junior marketing executive named Lynne Greenfeld. According to Frito-Lay's internal records, the project started in 1989. The goal was simple: create a spicy product that could compete with the local snacks popping up in corner stores in the Midwest, specifically Chicago and Detroit.
Frito-Lay issued a statement that was surprisingly blunt for a company that had celebrated Montañez for years. They stated that "none of our records show that Richard was involved in any capacity in the Flamin’ Hot test market." They credited the product’s creation to a team of scientists and marketers.
So, Was It Lynne Greenfeld?
Lynne Greenfeld was tasked with developing the brand name and the "Flamin' Hot" identity in 1989. While scientists in the lab were busy perfecting the chemical heat and the specific red dye that stains everyone's fingers, Greenfeld was the one pushing the product through the corporate pipeline.
By 1990, the product was already being tested in stores.
This timeline is the biggest hurdle for Montañez’s version of events. Roger Enrico, the CEO he supposedly called to pitch the idea, didn't even start at Frito-Lay until 1991. If the product was already on shelves in 1990, the math just doesn't work. It’s a classic case of corporate memory vs. personal myth-making.
🔗 Read more: Big Lots in Potsdam NY: What Really Happened to Our Store
Greenfeld eventually contacted Frito-Lay in 2018 after seeing Montañez’s story gain mainstream steam. She wanted the record set straight. To the corporate world, she is the "mother" of the brand.
The Al Carey Connection and the "Two Truths" Theory
Is it possible both stories are true in some way?
Al Carey, a former Frito-Lay executive who rose to become the CEO of PepsiCo North America, has been one of Montañez's biggest supporters. He maintains that Richard’s contribution was real. Carey argues that while a "Flamin' Hot" product might have been in development in Texas, Montañez was simultaneously working on his own spicy concoctions in California.
Corporate silos are a real thing. It’s entirely plausible that a marketing team in Texas was working on a spicy snack while a motivated employee in California was pitching something similar to his local plant managers.
Why the distinction matters
- The Product: The actual chemical seasoning was likely developed in a lab by food scientists like Fred Lindsay.
- The Brand: Lynne Greenfeld spearheaded the "Flamin' Hot" name and rollout.
- The Culture: Richard Montañez undoubtedly helped the company understand how to market to Latino communities, even if he wasn't the "inventor" of the specific Cheeto in the bag.
Montañez’s impact on Frito-Lay’s business strategy was massive. He helped launch a line of "Sabrositas" products aimed specifically at Hispanic consumers. Whether he "invented" the original spicy dust or not, he changed the way the company operated. He was a pioneer of "multicultural marketing" before it was a buzzword.
The Cultural Impact of the Spicy Snack
Regardless of who gets the patent, Flamin' Hot Cheetos became a cultural phenomenon that transcends snack food. It’s a lifestyle. We’ve seen Flamin' Hot apparel at New York Fashion Week. There are Flamin' Hot Mountain Dew flavors and Flamin' Hot Mac & Cheese.
💡 You might also like: Why 425 Market Street San Francisco California 94105 Stays Relevant in a Remote World
The snack hit a nerve because it arrived at the exact moment when the American palate was shifting toward bolder, more diverse flavors. It wasn't just for the "Hispanic market" anymore; it was for everyone.
The controversy over who invented Flamin' Hot Cheetos actually highlights a bigger issue in business history: the erasure of individual contributions in large bureaucracies. Sometimes, the "official" version of history misses the ground-level innovations that happen on the factory floor. Other times, the "hero’s journey" is a bit too polished to be entirely true.
Where Does Richard Montañez Stand Now?
Montañez retired from PepsiCo in 2019. Despite the LA Times report, he hasn't backed down. He argues that Frito-Lay’s records are incomplete and that he was pushed out of the narrative because he was "just a janitor."
"I was their greatest ambassador," he told Variety. "But I will say this—you're going to love your company, but sometimes your company won't love you back."
It’s a sentiment that resonates with a lot of people. It’s why the movie directed by Eva Longoria focused on his feeling of the events rather than a forensic audit of Frito-Lay’s 1989 tax returns. People want to believe in the janitor. They don't want to believe in the "Junior Marketing Executive" and a team of lab scientists.
Practical Takeaways from the Flamin' Hot Saga
If you’re an entrepreneur or a creative, there’s a lot to learn here. History is rarely written by just one person.
- Document everything. If you have a "billion-dollar idea" at work, put it in an email. Keep a paper trail. Corporate memory is notoriously short and biased toward whoever has the most power.
- Context is king. Part of the reason Montañez’s story was so believable for so long is that he genuinely did change the culture at Frito-Lay. Even if he didn't invent the spice, he invented a new way for the company to see its customers.
- The Power of Storytelling. The reason we are still talking about this is that Montañez is a master storyteller. A good story will always travel further than a dry corporate memo, even if the memo is more "accurate."
- Question the "Solo Inventor" Myth. Almost nothing in the modern world is invented by a single person in a vacuum. From the lightbulb to the Cheeto, innovation is usually a messy, collaborative, and parallel process.
The truth of who invented Flamin' Hot Cheetos is likely a mix of lab-grown chemistry, corporate strategy, and the very real passion of a man who wanted more for his community and himself. The red dust on your fingers doesn't care who gets the credit, but the business world certainly does.
To dig deeper into this, you can look at the original LA Times investigation or read Montañez’s book Flamin' Hot: The Incredible True Story of One Man's Rise from Janitor to Top Executive to see how the two narratives diverge. Comparing the dates of Roger Enrico's tenure at Frito-Lay against the initial test markets in 1990 is the most effective way to see the factual gaps for yourself.