You might think a single, shadowy figure in a trench coat just decided one day that America needed a global spy network. It wasn't that clean. Honestly, the story of who established the CIA is more about bureaucratic infighting, a massive failure in Hawaii, and a President who was actually pretty terrified of creating an "American Gestapo."
World War II changed everything. Before the 1940s, the U.S. was basically flying blind, with different military branches hoarding their own secrets and refusing to share. Then Pearl Harbor happened. That disaster proved that if you don't have a central place to glue all your intelligence snippets together, people die.
The Man with the Vision: "Wild Bill" Donovan
If you're looking for the literal spark, it’s William J. "Wild Bill" Donovan. He was a Medal of Honor recipient and a total loose cannon in the best way possible. Franklin D. Roosevelt tapped him to run the Office of Strategic Services (OSS) during the war. The OSS was the CIA’s wild older brother—full of Ivy League professors, safecrackers, and socialites who spent their time blowing up bridges and running agents behind Nazi lines.
Donovan knew the OSS wouldn't last once the peace treaties were signed. He pushed hard for a permanent, centralized agency that reported directly to the President. He wanted a "Central Intelligence Service." But he had enemies. A lot of them.
J. Edgar Hoover, the legendary and terrifying head of the FBI, hated the idea. He wanted the FBI to handle all overseas intelligence. Military generals didn't like it either; they didn't want some civilian "super-spy" looking over their shoulders. When FDR died in 1945, Donovan lost his biggest protector. Harry S. Truman, the new guy in the Oval Office, didn't trust Donovan. He thought the OSS felt too much like a secret police force.
So, Truman did what politicians do. He shut the OSS down.
👉 See also: Clayton County News: What Most People Get Wrong About the Gateway to the World
Harry S. Truman and the National Security Act of 1947
Wait, if Truman shut down the OSS, how did he end up being the one who established the CIA?
Reality hit him fast. By 1946, the Cold War was starting to simmer. The Soviet Union wasn't playing nice, and Truman realized he was getting 50 different intelligence reports that all said different things. He was frustrated. He famously complained about getting a "shoebox full of cables" every morning. He needed a filter.
First, he created the Central Intelligence Group (CIG) in 1946. It was a weak middleman. It didn't have its own budget or the power to actually do much. It was basically a library with no late fees.
The real hammer blow came with the National Security Act of 1947. This is the legal birth certificate of the Central Intelligence Agency. Truman signed it on July 26, 1947, while aboard his presidential aircraft, the Sacred Cow. It wasn't just about the CIA; this law created the Department of Defense and the National Security Council too. It was a total teardown and rebuild of how the United States handled its survival.
Why Truman Regretted It
Interestingly, Truman spent the rest of his life arguing that the CIA had morphed into something he never intended. In a 1963 op-ed for the Washington Post, he wrote that he wanted the agency to be a "quiet intelligence arm" for the President—basically a news clipping service for top-secret info. He was horrified that it had become a "cloak and dagger" outfit involved in coups and assassinations.
✨ Don't miss: Charlie Kirk Shooting Investigation: What Really Happened at UVU
The Quiet Architect: Rear Admiral Roscoe Hillenkoetter
History books often skip over the first actual Director of Central Intelligence (DCI) under the 1947 Act: Roscoe Hillenkoetter. He wasn't a master spy. He was a Navy guy.
Being the first person to run the CIA was a nightmare. He had to build an office from scratch while the State Department and the Pentagon tried to steal his lunch money every single day. Hillenkoetter struggled because the National Security Act was actually pretty vague about what the CIA could "officially" do. It had a "catch-all" clause that said the agency could perform "other functions and duties related to intelligence."
That tiny, vague sentence is what allowed the CIA to move from just reading foreign newspapers to toppling governments in Iran and Guatemala just a few years later.
The Ivy League Influence
We can't talk about who established the CIA without talking about the "Wise Men." These were the Wall Street lawyers and bankers who shaped the agency's culture. Men like Allen Dulles—who would later become the most famous DCI—were instrumental. They believed that the U.S. needed to fight the Soviets using their own dirty tactics.
Dulles was a key player in the "Committee on the National Security Organization," also known as the Eberstadt Committee. They were the ones whispering in the ears of Congress, making sure the CIA had the power to conduct "covert action." They didn't just want to know what the enemy was doing; they wanted to stop them before they did it.
🔗 Read more: Casualties Vietnam War US: The Raw Numbers and the Stories They Don't Tell You
The Evolution of the Role
- Phase One (OSS): Purely wartime sabotage and intelligence gathering.
- Phase Two (CIG): A brief, failed attempt at coordination without any real teeth.
- Phase Three (CIA): A permanent, independent agency with its own budget and the legal right to exist.
What Most People Get Wrong
A common misconception is that the CIA was created to be a global police force. It wasn't. The primary goal in 1947 was simply coordination. The U.S. had just survived a war where the Army and Navy sometimes refused to talk to each other. The CIA was supposed to be the "central" hub.
Another myth? That it was a secret project nobody knew about. While the details were classified, the debate over the National Security Act was very public. Americans were genuinely worried about creating a domestic spy agency. That’s why the CIA is legally barred from spying on U.S. citizens on American soil—a rule that has, let’s be honest, been "stretched" a few times over the decades.
Nuance and Limitations
It's easy to point at Truman and say "he did it." But the CIA was really the product of a massive, panicked bureaucracy trying to adapt to the nuclear age. The agency we have today, with its drones and cyberwarfare divisions, would be unrecognizable to the guys in 1947 who were mostly worried about whether or not Stalin was going to march into West Berlin.
The establishment of the CIA wasn't a single event. It was a series of failures (Pearl Harbor), experiments (OSS), and legislative compromises.
Moving Forward: How to Verify the History
If you really want to dig into the primary sources of how this went down, don't just take a YouTuber's word for it. There are specific places where the "receipts" are kept.
- The National Security Archive: Located at George Washington University, they have declassified memos from Hillenkoetter and Dulles that show the internal fighting.
- The Truman Library: You can read Truman's personal letters where he vents about the "intelligence mess" in Washington.
- FOIA Electronic Reading Room: The CIA’s own website has a "Historical Review Program" where they release documents about their own founding. It’s surprisingly candid about their early screw-ups.
Actionable Insight: To understand the CIA today, look at the National Security Act of 1947. Most of the debates we have now about government surveillance and "deep state" overreach started in the committee rooms of 1946. If you want to see how an agency is built, start by reading the "Summary of the National Security Act" on the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) website. It provides the most accurate legal framework for how the agency operates within the federal government.