Honestly, if you were looking for a clean, tied-with-a-bow ending to the Jackie Howard love triangle this season, you probably walked away from your TV feeling a little bit personally victimized. Netflix’s My Life with the Walter Boys has never exactly been a show about making easy choices. Season 1 gave us that frantic escape to New York, and season 2 basically spent ten episodes amping up the tension until the whole thing exploded in the front yard of the Walter ranch.
So, let's just get the big question out of the way. Who does Jackie end up with in season 2?
Technically? Nobody. But emotionally? She finally stopped lying to herself. In the final moments of the season 2 finale, "Showdowns and Sparkles," Jackie admits to Cole that she is in love with him. It’s a huge, messy confession that honestly feels like it was pulled out of her by force. But here is the kicker—her current boyfriend, Alex, is standing right there in the shadows, hearing every single word.
It’s a brutal cliffhanger. Just as the truth comes out and the love triangle reaches a breaking point, real-life tragedy strikes. An ambulance pulls up because George Walter has collapsed, effectively freezing the romantic drama in its tracks.
💡 You might also like: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The Alex Problem: Safe vs. Spark
When Jackie came back from New York at the start of the season, she was determined to do things "the right way." She felt immense guilt for how she left Alex hanging after her secret kiss with Cole. So, what did she do? She doubled down on the "safe" choice. She and Alex actually got back together for a significant chunk of the season.
They even had this weird, secret relationship for a while. Alex came back from his summer at rodeo camp with a serious "glow-up"—new cowboy boots, more confidence, and a bit of a sharper edge. He wasn't just the sweet, dependable kid from season 1 anymore. He was winning competitions and getting sponsorships. On paper, he was exactly what a grieving perfectionist like Jackie thought she needed.
But you could tell she was trying to convince herself. She even told Alex she loved him, but it felt... heavy. Like she was saying it because she wanted it to be true, not because it was.
📖 Related: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
Why Cole Walter is the "Out of Control" Choice
Cole spent most of season 2 trying to find a version of himself that didn't involve a football. It was actually kind of nice to see him grow. He started helping with college applications, got his SAT scores up, and even stepped in as an assistant coach for the Bighorns. He and Jackie fell into this "just friends" rhythm that was clearly a lie.
The chemistry between Nikki Rodriguez and Noah LaLonde is basically the engine of the show, and it was firing on all cylinders during the Día de los Muertos scenes. When Jackie finally breaks down, she tells Cole the real reason she’s been pushing him away: he makes her feel out of control.
For someone who lost her entire family in a split second, "out of control" is the scariest thing in the world. Alex represents stability; Cole represents the kind of passion that can break your heart.
👉 See also: Tim Dillon: I'm Your Mother Explained (Simply)
That Shocking Finale Breakdown
The finale really didn't hold back. Here’s how the final sequence actually went down:
- The Sparkler Award: Jackie gets honored at the festival for her work on the fall formal. It's a high point for her character's integration into Silver Falls.
- The Confrontation: Outside the house, Cole finally calls her out. He knows she’s been hiding her rekindled thing with Alex.
- The Confession: Jackie snaps. She admits she loves him. No hesitation, no "maybe." Just a direct, "I love you. Are we done?"
- The Witness: Alex is there. He hears it all. His face is a total mask of heartbreak and betrayal.
- The Interruption: Before a fight can even start, Will runs up. George has collapsed on the ranch.
Basically, Jackie "chose" Cole with her words, but the circumstances of the Walter family means she hasn't actually ended up with him yet. They are in a state of romantic limbo.
What This Means for Season 3
If you're waiting for a happy ending, you're going to be waiting a while. Season 3 is already confirmed, and it’s going to have to deal with the fallout of Alex knowing the truth. There’s also the Blake factor—Alex’s rodeo trainer, Blake, clearly has a thing for him, and they had a brief romance while Jackie was being distant.
The most interesting shift is that Cole is actually getting his life together. He’s looking at college. He’s maturing. If he’s no longer the "bad boy" and Alex is becoming more cynical and hardened, the dynamic of the triangle has completely shifted.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
If you want to dive deeper into the differences between the show and the source material, check out Ali Novak’s book sequel, My Life with the Walter Boys: The Next Chapter. In the books, things actually lean a bit more definitively toward one brother, though the show has already proven it’s willing to deviate from the page to keep the drama high. For now, the best thing to do is keep an eye on Netflix's production schedule—with season 3 greenlit, we'll likely see the resolution to that ambulance cliffhanger by late 2026.