Fantasy football is basically a high-stakes guessing game disguised as a spreadsheet. You spend all Tuesday night staring at the waiver wire like it’s a magic crystal ball. Then Wednesday hits. Suddenly, your star receiver is listed as "Limited" with a hamstring issue, and your entire plan for the weekend goes up in smoke. By the time Sunday morning rolls around, the panic sets in. You’re frantically texting the group chat, asking "Who do I start Week 4?" while hoping someone has a better intuition than your own gut feeling.
It's a weird time in the season. We finally have enough data to know which teams are actually terrible, but not enough to know if that rookie's breakout game in Week 3 was a fluke or a sign of greatness.
The Week 4 Pivot Point
By now, the "wait and see" approach is dead. If you’re 0-3, you’re playing for your life. Even if you’re 3-0, you’re probably looking at a roster that has a few cracks. Week 4 is traditionally when NFL defensive coordinators have enough film on new offensive schemes to start shutting them down. This is where the "Who do I start Week 4" question becomes less about who is the biggest name and more about who has the best path to 15 touches.
Honestly, the biggest mistake people make is chasing last week’s points. You see a random tight end catch two touchdowns on three targets and suddenly he’s the top waiver add. Don't do it. Regression is a monster.
Why Matchups Matter More Than Talent Right Now
We need to talk about the "start your studs" rule. It’s a classic mantra, but it’s often a trap. If your "stud" is a quarterback facing a top-three secondary while playing behind a backup offensive line, you’re just asking for a 12-point disappointment.
Take a look at the defensive splits. Some teams are "funnel" defenses. This means they are so good at stopping the run that they practically beg you to throw the ball 50 times. Others, like the bottom-tier units we've seen recently in places like Jacksonville or Arizona, are just vulnerable everywhere. When you’re deciding who to start, look at the Vegas totals. High over/under games are where the fantasy gold lives. If a game has a total of 51, you want every piece of that action you can get. If it’s 37.5? Stay away unless you’re desperate.
Navigating the Injury Minefield
Injuries are the great equalizer in fantasy. They turn bench warmers into league winners overnight. But they also create a "Who do I start Week 4" headache because of the dreaded "Game-Time Decision" tag.
If a player doesn't practice on Friday, they usually aren't playing. Even if they are "active," they might be used as a decoy. Remember when Mike Evans or Davante Adams would suit up just to stand on the sideline and pull the best cornerback away from the actual play? That’s a fantasy manager's nightmare. Always have a "pivot" player ready for the late afternoon games. If your questionable starter is playing at 4:25 PM, make sure your backup isn't someone who already played at 1:00 PM.
Running Back Committees and the Death of the Bell Cow
The era of the 30-carry running back is mostly over. It's sad, but it's true. Now, we’re looking at "touches per game" rather than just carries. A running back who gets 12 carries and 5 targets is infinitely more valuable than a guy who gets 18 carries and zero targets, especially in PPR (Point Per Reception) leagues.
💡 You might also like: Danny Amendola: What Most People Get Wrong About the Retired Star
When you're looking at your roster and wondering who to slot into that RB2 spot, check the snap counts from Week 3. Is the "starter" actually on the field for third downs? If not, their ceiling is capped. You want the guy who is out there when the team is trailing. Garbage time points count exactly the same as touchdowns in the first quarter.
Wide Receiver Volatility and the Slot Advantage
Wide receivers are the most frustrating position to project. One week they have 140 yards; the next, they disappear because the safety sat over the top of them all game. This is why slot receivers are the "safe" answer to who do I start Week 4.
Slot guys usually face the third-best cornerback. They run shorter routes. They get the "layup" throws from the quarterback. If you're in a pinch, a high-volume slot receiver is almost always a better play than a deep-threat boom-or-bust guy who relies on one 50-yard bomb to have a good day.
The Quarterback Streaming Game
Unless you drafted Josh Allen, Patrick Mahomes, or Lamar Jackson, you might be considering a stream. Week 4 usually offers some juicy matchups for mid-tier quarterbacks. Look for the "bridge" quarterbacks—the veterans playing for bad teams who are forced to throw constantly to keep up.
Efficiency is the enemy of fantasy points for quarterbacks. You want volume. You want a guy who is going to throw 40 times because his defense couldn't stop a high school team. It’s ugly football, but it’s beautiful for your scoreboard.
Identifying the "Trap" Players
Every week, there’s a player everyone says you must start, but the numbers say otherwise. This usually happens when a player has a "revenge game" narrative or just came off a massive performance on Monday Night Football.
Narratives don't score points. Targets do.
💡 You might also like: Week 13 NFL Games: What Most People Get Wrong
If a receiver's target share is trending down over the last three weeks, don't expect it to magically spike in Week 4 just because he’s playing his old team. Look at the actual usage. Is he being moved around the formation? Is he the first read in the red zone? If the answer is no, he belongs on your bench, regardless of what the experts on TV are screaming.
The Tight End Wasteland
Let’s be real: unless you have one of the top three guys, the tight end position is a literal coin flip. You’re basically praying for a touchdown. When deciding who to start at TE in Week 4, look at "Red Zone Target Share." Some teams use their tight ends as glorified offensive tackles. Others, like the Chiefs or Falcons, view them as the primary engine of the offense. If your tight end isn't getting targets inside the 20-yard line, he’s useless to you.
Practical Steps for Your Week 4 Lineup
Forget the "projections" that the apps give you. Those numbers are often generated by algorithms that don't account for weather, locker room vibes, or late-breaking injury news.
- Check the Weather: High winds (over 15 mph) matter way more than rain. Rain actually helps receivers because defensive backs can't cut as quickly on a slippery surface. Wind, however, kills the deep ball and the kicking game.
- Follow the Money: Check the betting lines on Saturday night. If the line moves significantly toward one team, something happened. Maybe a key offensive lineman is out.
- Trust Volume Over Everything: If you have to choose between a talented player who gets 6 looks a game and a mediocre player who gets 12, take the 12. Volume is the only thing we can somewhat accurately predict.
- Don't Overthink the Flex: Put your latest-starting player in the Flex spot. It gives you the most flexibility if someone is a surprise inactive.
The reality of the "Who do I start Week 4" dilemma is that there is no perfect answer. You make the most informed decision possible, click "Submit Lineup," and then spend three hours on Sunday screaming at the television because a backup fullback took a goal-line carry away from your RB1. That’s the game.
Look at the snap shares from the last two weeks. If a player's involvement is growing, start them. If they are losing work to a rookie, get out now while you can still trade them for something of value. Consistency wins championships; flashy one-hit wonders win you a single week and leave you stranded for the rest of the season.
👉 See also: NFL Super Bowl on What Channel: Don't Miss a Second of the Action
Scan your waiver wire for "handcuff" running backs who might see an increased role due to minor injuries. Sometimes the best Week 4 starter isn't even on your roster yet. Check the Friday injury reports one last time before you go to sleep. If your guy is "Questionable," have a backup from the Monday Night game ready just in case.