Kalen DeBoer had some massive shoes to fill, didn't he? Taking over for Nick Saban is basically like trying to paint a new Mona Lisa while the whole world watches over your shoulder. For the most part, the 2025 season was a resounding success—Alabama finished 11-4, which most programs would sell their souls for. But "most programs" aren't Alabama.
When people ask who did Alabama Crimson Tide lose to this year, they’re usually looking for that one moment where the armor cracked. In reality, it happened four times. Each loss told a different story about where this team is heading. From a shaky start in the humidity of Tallahassee to a cold, humbling afternoon in the Rose Bowl, the Tide's losses in 2025 weren't just scores on a ticker. They were statements.
The Shocking Week 1 Stumble in Tallahassee
Nobody expected the season to start like this. Alabama went down to Florida State on August 30, and honestly, they looked like a team still trying to find their ID badges. Florida State took them down 31-17. It wasn't just that Bama lost; it was how they looked doing it.
The offensive line struggled with the noise, and the timing just wasn't there. You’ve gotta remember, this was the first real test of the post-Saban era. Florida State played like they had something to prove, and the Tide played like they were still reading the playbook.
The Mid-Season Reality Check vs. Oklahoma
After that opening loss, Alabama went on a tear. They beat Georgia in Athens—which, let's be real, was huge—and handled Tennessee and LSU. By November 15, fans were starting to whisper "National Championship" again. Then the Oklahoma Sooners showed up in Tuscaloosa.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
Oklahoma walked out of Bryant-Denny Stadium with a 23-21 win. It was a classic "trap game" feel, even though Oklahoma is a powerhouse. Alabama’s offense went stagnant in the second half. Ty Simpson had been playing great, but the Sooners' defense managed to confuse the protection schemes just enough to stall out three crucial drives. Losing a home game in November is a bitter pill for Tide fans to swallow.
The SEC Championship Heartbreak
Alabama actually managed to get revenge on Oklahoma later in the playoffs, but before that, they had to face the Georgia Bulldogs again. This time it was for the SEC title on December 6.
The first time these teams met in the regular season, Bama pulled off a 24-21 thriller. The rematch? Not so much. Georgia won 28-7. It was a defensive masterclass by Kirby Smart. Alabama’s "Swarm" defense, which had been so good all year, finally met an offense that could move the chains consistently. The Tide's only score came late, and by then, the Bulldogs were already celebrating on the sidelines.
The Rose Bowl Disaster: Indiana’s Statement
If you haven't been paying attention to what Curt Cignetti is doing at Indiana, you're missing the wildest story in college football history. But for Alabama fans, Indiana is now a name that brings back nightmares. On January 1, 2026, in the Rose Bowl (a CFP Quarterfinal), Alabama didn't just lose—they were dismantled.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
Indiana 38, Alabama 3.
Read that again. Three points. For a program that prides itself on offensive explosion, getting held to a single field goal on one of the biggest stages in sports was jarring. The Hoosiers outgained the Tide 407 to 193. It was the kind of loss that makes a fan base question everything. Indiana’s defense jumped routes, lived in the backfield, and basically told the world that the "New Alabama" still has a long way to go to reach "Old Alabama" levels of dominance.
Every Loss for Alabama in the 2025-26 Season
To keep it simple, here is the list of teams that took down the Tide:
- Florida State Seminoles (31-17) - Regular Season Week 1
- Oklahoma Sooners (23-21) - Regular Season Week 12
- Georgia Bulldogs (28-7) - SEC Championship Game
- Indiana Hoosiers (38-3) - Rose Bowl / CFP Quarterfinal
What This Means for the Future
The 2025 season proved that Alabama is still a top-10 program, but they aren't the "invincible" force they used to be. Losing to Florida State and Oklahoma shows a lack of consistency. Getting blown out by Georgia and Indiana shows a gap in top-tier talent or scheme execution that Kalen DeBoer has to bridge.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
If you're a Tide fan, you're probably looking at the transfer portal right now. The biggest takeaway from these four losses is that the offensive line needs a complete overhaul if they want to protect Ty Simpson (or whoever starts in 2026) against elite pass rushes.
Actionable Insights for the Offseason:
- Watch the Portal: Keep an eye on tackle and guard transfers. Bama's losses to Georgia and Indiana were won in the trenches.
- Scheme Adjustments: Look for Ryan Grubb to simplify some of the Air Raid concepts that seemed to stall against elite secondaries.
- Recruiting Focus: The "Swarm" defense needs more depth at linebacker to handle the RPO-heavy offenses that gave them fits this year.
The dynasty isn't dead, but it's definitely in a "remodeling" phase. One thing is for sure: nobody is going to take Alabama lightly in 2026, but the fear factor has definitely dipped a bit.