You’ve probably seen the headlines. A new President-elect stands on a stage, gestures toward a row of serious-looking people, and announces them as the next heads of State, Defense, or Treasury. It looks official. It feels like a done deal. But in reality, those people are just nominees. They have no actual power yet. They can’t move into the big corner offices or start issuing directives to federal agencies.
So, who confirms cabinet appointments?
The short answer is the United States Senate. But the "how" and the "why" are way more chaotic and interesting than what you probably learned in a high school civics class. It’s not just a polite thumbs-up. It is a grueling, often partisan gauntlet that can make or break an administration before it even starts. Honestly, the process is designed to be a headache. The Founding Fathers didn’t want a King picking his cronies without anyone checking his homework.
The Advice and Consent Clause: Where the Power Comes From
The whole process is baked into the U.S. Constitution under Article II, Section 2. It’s called "Advice and Consent." That’s a fancy way of saying the President can’t just hire whoever they want for the top jobs. They need the Senate to sign off on it.
Think of it like a job interview where the interviewers are 100 people who might actually hate your future boss.
It starts with a formal nomination. The President sends a name to the Senate. From there, the "advice" part is mostly historical—nowadays, it’s all about the "consent." The Senate holds the keys. If they don’t like a nominee, or if they just want to stick it to the President, they can stall the process indefinitely. It's a massive lever of power.
The Gauntlet: From FBI Background Checks to Public Grilling
Before a nominee even steps foot in a hearing room, they get poked and prodded by the FBI and the Office of Government Ethics. We're talking deep dives into tax returns, past business deals, and even old social media posts.
You’d be surprised what trips people up.
🔗 Read more: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
Sometimes it’s a "nannygate" situation where someone didn’t pay taxes on household help. Other times, it’s a controversial comment made twenty years ago. Once the paperwork is cleared, the nominee goes to a specific Senate committee. For example, the Secretary of State nominee goes to the Foreign Relations Committee. The Secretary of Defense goes to Armed Services.
These committee hearings are where the drama happens.
They are televised. They are tense. Senators use their five minutes of questioning to either praise the nominee or, more likely, try to get them to admit to something embarrassing. It’s theater, but it’s theater with consequences. After the hearing, the committee votes. If they give a "favorable" report, the nomination moves to the full Senate floor.
The Simple Majority Rule (And How It Changed)
For a long time, it was harder to confirm people. You basically needed a supermajority to overcome a filibuster.
But things changed in 2013 and 2017.
Democrats first lowered the threshold for most nominees, and then Republicans did the same for Supreme Court justices. Now, to answer who confirms cabinet appointments in terms of the "math," you only need a simple majority. If there are 100 Senators, you need 51 votes. If it’s a 50-50 tie? The Vice President steps in to break it.
This change made the process faster but way more partisan. It used to be that Cabinet members were confirmed with 80 or 90 votes because everyone agreed the President deserved their team. Those days are mostly gone. Now, it’s a dogfight.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
When Nominees Fail: The Ones Who Didn't Make It
Not everyone gets through. Sometimes the heat is too much.
Take John Tower in 1989. President George H.W. Bush wanted him for Secretary of Defense. Tower was a former Senator himself, so you’d think he’d have an easy ride. Nope. Concerns about his personal life and ties to defense contractors led the Senate to reject him. It was the first time in history a former Senator was rejected for a Cabinet post.
More recently, we’ve seen nominees withdraw because they realized they didn't have the votes. Neera Tanden, nominated for Budget Director by President Biden, withdrew in 2021 after it became clear that key Senators wouldn't support her because of her past tweets.
It’s a brutal reminder that the Senate’s power is very real. They aren't just a rubber stamp.
The "Acting" Secretary Loophole
President Trump famously used "Acting" officials a lot. Why? Because an "Acting" Secretary doesn't need Senate confirmation.
But there’s a catch.
The Vacancies Act limits how long an acting official can serve—usually around 210 days. It’s a way to bypass the Senate temporarily, but it creates a lot of instability. Critics argue it undermines the whole "Advice and Consent" thing. If a President just keeps cycling through "Acting" heads, the Senate loses its oversight power. It’s a legal gray area that constitutional scholars argue about constantly.
📖 Related: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
Why the Process Matters to You
You might think, "Who cares who the Secretary of Agriculture is?"
You should.
These people run massive departments that affect your daily life. They decide what goes into school lunches, how much interest you pay on student loans, and how the country responds to a pandemic. The Senate's job is to make sure these people are actually qualified and not just political donors getting a reward.
When the confirmation process works, it acts as a filter for incompetence. When it breaks down, we get gridlock.
Actionable Insights for Following the Process
If you want to track who confirms cabinet appointments during the next transition, don't just wait for the evening news. The real work happens in the details:
- Check the Committee Calendars: The Senate.gov website lists every upcoming hearing. If you want to see a nominee's real personality, watch the live stream of their committee hearing rather than the 30-second clip on social media.
- Follow the "Blue Slips" and Holds: Individual Senators can sometimes "hold" a nomination to extract concessions from the White House on unrelated issues. If a nominee is stuck, look at who is blocking them and why.
- Watch the Vote Counts: A nominee who squeaks by with 51 votes has a much shorter leash than one who gets 70. The margin of victory tells you how much political capital that Secretary actually has.
- Read the Financial Disclosures: These are public documents. They show where a nominee’s money is. It’s often the best way to predict where their potential conflicts of interest might lie.
The process of who confirms cabinet appointments is one of the most powerful tools the legislative branch has. It’s a messy, loud, and deeply political system, but it is the primary reason why a President can't just operate in a vacuum. The Senate ensures that the Cabinet is accountable—not just to the person who picked them, but to the law.