It happens every few years. The news alerts start screaming. People start worrying about national parks closing or their tax refunds getting delayed. You’ve seen it before. But whenever a lapse in funding actually hits, the first question everyone asks is: who caused the government shutdown?
Politics isn't a clean sport. It's more like a messy divorce where both sides are fighting over who gets the dog, but in this case, the dog is the federal budget and the "house" is the entire United States economy. If you’re looking for a single name to pin a tail on, you’re going to be disappointed. It’s almost never just one person. It’s a collision of timing, ego, and fundamentally different visions for what the country should spend money on.
Essentially, a shutdown occurs when Congress fails to pass—and the President fails to sign—twelve different appropriation bills. Or, more commonly, a "Continuing Resolution" (CR) to keep the lights on. It sounds like a technicality. It’s actually a high-stakes game of chicken.
The Usual Suspects: Why It’s Rarely One Person
To understand who caused the government shutdown in any given year, you have to look at the "Three-Legged Stool" of Washington power: the House of Representatives, the Senate, and the White House.
Historically, shutdowns are triggered by a "poison pill." This is a piece of legislation that one side loves and the other side absolutely loathes. Think back to 2013. That 16-day ordeal was largely driven by a push to defund or delay the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare). Republican Senator Ted Cruz famously spoke for 21 hours on the Senate floor. Democrats refused to budge. The result? A shuttered government.
But wait. Was it Cruz? Was it then-Speaker John Boehner for allowing the vote? Or was it President Obama for refusing to negotiate on his signature law? Depending on which news channel you watched, the answer changed. That’s the trick. Both sides spend millions of dollars in advertising just to convince you that the other guy did it.
The Power of the "Holdout" Faction
Sometimes, the culprit isn't even a party leader. It’s a small group of rebels. In recent years, we’ve seen the "Freedom Caucus" in the House wield massive influence. Because the margins of power are so thin—sometimes just a handful of seats—a tiny group of about 10 to 20 lawmakers can block a spending bill.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
They basically tell their own leadership: "Give us these deep spending cuts, or we let the whole thing burn."
When a Speaker of the House (like Kevin McCarthy or Mike Johnson) tries to work with Democrats to avoid a shutdown, they risk losing their job. We saw this play out in 2023. McCarthy kept the government open, and a few days later, he was ousted. This creates a "perverse incentive." Leaders become more afraid of their own fringe members than they are of a government shutdown. So, they let the clock run out.
The Role of the President's Veto Pen
Don't let the White House off the hook. The President has the final say. In late 2018 and early 2019, the U.S. endured the longest shutdown in history—35 days.
Why? Border wall funding.
President Donald Trump insisted on $5.7 billion for a wall. Congressional Democrats, led by Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer, said no. Trump famously stated in a televised Oval Office meeting that he would be "proud to shut down the government for border security."
That quote was a goldmine for his opponents. Usually, politicians try to distance themselves from the blame. Trump leaned into it. But even then, supporters argued that Democrats "caused" it by refusing to fund a core campaign promise. It’s a circle of blame that never really ends.
👉 See also: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
Why Does This Keep Happening?
Money is power. It’s that simple.
Budgeting used to be a boring, clerical process. Now, it’s a weapon. Since the 1974 Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act, the process has become increasingly polarized. We don’t do "regular order" anymore. Instead of debating twelve separate bills over six months, everything gets shoved into one giant "Omnibus" bill at 2:00 AM.
Nobody reads it. Everyone hates it. And because it’s so big, there’s always something in there for someone to get mad about.
The Real-World Cost of the Blame Game
While politicians are pointing fingers at each other on X (formerly Twitter) or Sunday morning talk shows, real people get squeezed. We’re talking about 800,000 federal employees.
Some are "essential" (like TSA agents or FBI officers). They have to work but don't get a paycheck until the shutdown ends. Others are "non-essential" and get sent home. They eventually get back pay, but try telling your landlord that your rent will be three weeks late because a subcommittee in D.C. couldn't agree on a line item.
Small businesses near national parks lose millions. Federal contractors? They often never get that money back. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that the 2018-2019 shutdown alone cost the U.S. economy about $11 billion. That’s not "government money"—that’s actual economic productivity gone forever.
✨ Don't miss: 39 Carl St and Kevin Lau: What Actually Happened at the Cole Valley Property
Spotting the Spin: How to Tell Who Is Actually Responsible
Next time you're trying to figure out who caused the government shutdown, look past the press releases. Follow the "Motion to Table."
- Check the House Floor: Is the Speaker refusing to bring a "clean" bill to the floor? A clean bill is just the budget without any extra political demands. If a clean bill would pass with bipartisan support but the Speaker won't allow a vote, the blame often sits with the House leadership.
- Watch the Senate Filibuster: Does a bill have 50 votes but not 60? If one party is using the filibuster to block a spending bill that the majority wants, they’re the ones holding the lever.
- The Veto Threat: Is the President promising to veto anything that doesn't include a specific, non-budgetary policy? That’s a leverage play that often leads to a stalemate.
Honestly, it’s usually a game of "chicken." Both sides wait until the very last second, hoping the public gets so mad at the other side that they cave. It’s a strategy built on your frustration.
Misconceptions About Shutdowns
A lot of people think a shutdown means the entire government stops. It doesn't. Social Security checks still go out. The military stays on duty. The Post Office keeps delivering (mostly because they're self-funded).
The stuff that stops is the "discretionary" stuff. Passport processing. Small Business Administration loans. Research at the National Institutes of Health. It’s a targeted kind of chaos.
Practical Steps to Protect Yourself
Knowing who caused the government shutdown doesn't pay your bills. If you see the rhetoric heating up in Washington, you need a personal "shutdown plan."
- Build a "Buffer" Fund: If you are a federal employee or a contractor, aim for at least one month of essential expenses in a high-yield savings account. Do not rely on "back pay" to arrive on time.
- Front-load Government Paperwork: Need a passport? Applying for a federal loan? Getting a specialized permit? Do it the moment you hear rumors of a budget stalemate. Once the "closed" sign goes up, the backlog grows exponentially every day.
- Check Your Travel Plans: National parks often close their gates. Some stay open with limited services (and no trash pickup), which can be pretty gross. Check the NPS website before you drive four hours to see a closed gate.
- Watch the "Drop Dead" Date: Keep an eye on the fiscal year-end (September 30) or the expiration date of the current Continuing Resolution. The week leading up to these dates is when the real "who caused it" drama unfolds.
The reality of Washington is that "who caused it" is usually a matter of perspective. But the impact is felt by everyone. Stay informed, look at the voting records rather than the soundbites, and always have a backup plan for your finances when the beltway starts bickering.