Everyone asks the same thing after every Super Bowl. They ask it during the draft. They ask it when the schedule drops in May. Who can beat the Chiefs? It’s the question that defines the modern NFL.
Honestly, the answer isn't just "a better team." There might not be a "better" team in terms of pure, situational execution and late-game poise. Patrick Mahomes, Andy Reid, and Steve Spagnuolo have built a machine that thrives on your mistakes. They don't just win; they wait for you to lose.
To beat Kansas City, you don't need a miracle. You need a specific blueprint that very few teams actually possess.
The Spagnuolo Problem and the AFC Gauntlet
If you want to know who can beat the Chiefs, you have to start with the defense. It’s weird, right? For years, we talked about Tyreek Hill and the "Legion of Zoom." Now, the conversation starts with L’Jarius Sneed (well, before he left) and Trent McDuffie. Steve Spagnuolo is a mad scientist. He brings pressure from places that don't make sense.
Look at the Baltimore Ravens. In the 2023 AFC Championship, they had the MVP. They had the home crowd. They had the best defense in the league. They lost because they panicked. They stopped running the ball. That’s the first rule of beating KC: don't abandon your identity.
The Cincinnati Bengals Blueprint
Joe Burrow is the only active quarterback who seems completely unfazed by the Arrowhead mystique. Why? Because he plays the game like a surgeon. He doesn't try to out-Mahomes Mahomes. He takes the five-yard checkdown. He trusts Ja'Marr Chase to win a 50/50 ball once a quarter.
The Bengals beat the Chiefs by being comfortable in the mud. They don't mind a 21-20 game. Most teams get into a shootout and start pressing. When you press against Kansas City, you throw a pick to Justin Reid or get sacked by Chris Jones on third-and-long. Cincinnati stays patient.
✨ Don't miss: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
The Buffalo Bills: A Tale of "Almost"
Josh Allen is a physical freak. He can do things Mahomes can't. He can run through a linebacker. He can throw a 70-yard rope while falling sideways. But the Bills have a "closer" problem. To beat the Chiefs in the playoffs, you have to win the final two minutes.
Buffalo usually wins the first 58 minutes. Then, something breaks. A wide-right kick. A 13-second defensive lapse. A dropped pass by Stefon Diggs. To actually be the team that beats the Chiefs consistently, the Bills have to stop playing scared in the fourth quarter.
The NFC Contenders: Can Anyone Stop the Three-Peat?
The San Francisco 49ers were this close. Twice. Kyle Shanahan is arguably the best play-designer in the history of the sport, but he’s running into a wall named Patrick.
The 49ers have the roster. They have Christian McCaffrey, Deebo Samuel, and a defensive line that should, theoretically, live in the Chiefs' backfield. But games aren't played on paper. In Super Bowl LVIII, the Niners had the lead. They had the momentum. Then, they forgot to account for Mahomes’ legs.
The Detroit Lions and the "Dan Campbell" Factor
There is something to be said for raw, unadulterated aggression. The Lions don't care about your rings. They play a brand of "kneecap-biting" football that actually bothers the Chiefs.
Kansas City relies on timing. They rely on you playing a standard zone so they can find the soft spots. Detroit plays man-to-man. They hit you in the mouth. Penei Sewell and that offensive line can actually bully the Chiefs' defensive front. If you want a dark horse for who can beat the Chiefs on the biggest stage, it’s a team that isn't afraid to go for it on 4th-and-4 from their own 40-yard line.
🔗 Read more: Navy Notre Dame Football: Why This Rivalry Still Hits Different
Why the "Mahomes Tax" Is Real
The math is simple. If you play the Chiefs, you start the game down by seven points mentally. That’s the Mahomes Tax. You feel like you have to score on every possession.
This leads to bad coaching decisions. Coaches who usually punt will go for it. Coaches who usually run will pass. They try to "keep up" with an offense that actually isn't as explosive as it used to be. The 2023-2024 Chiefs weren't a high-flying circus. They were a gritty, defensive-minded squad that waited for the opponent to blink.
The recipe for beating them is boring:
- Run the ball 30 times.
- Limit Mahomes to under 5 possessions in the second half.
- Play "two-high" shells to take away the deep ball (though Travis Kelce makes this hard).
- Pressure the interior. Chris Jones is a Hall of Famer, but if you can move him, the whole system cracks.
The Personnel Requirements
You can't beat the Chiefs with a rookie quarterback. You just can't. Stroud might do it eventually, but the learning curve is too steep. You need a veteran who has seen Spagnuolo’s "Simulated Pressures" before.
You also need a "bracket" defender. Someone who exists solely to follow Travis Kelce. Derwin James used to do this well for the Chargers. Kyle Hamilton is starting to do it for the Ravens. If Kelce gets 10 catches for 110 yards, you lose. Period.
The Salary Cap Constraint
The Chiefs are paying Mahomes a fortune, but they keep finding cheap talent in the draft. George Karlaftis. Isiah Pacheco. These guys are on rookie deals. To beat them, a team like the Texans or the Colts has to capitalize now while C.J. Stroud or Anthony Richardson are still cheap.
💡 You might also like: LeBron James Without Beard: Why the King Rarely Goes Clean Shaven Anymore
Once your quarterback takes up 20% of the cap, you can't afford the depth needed to survive a four-quarter war with Kansas City.
Misconceptions About the "Chiefs Weakness"
People keep saying the Chiefs receivers are bad. They aren't "bad." They are inconsistent. But in the playoffs, Andy Reid simplifies the menu. He uses Rashee Rice on crossers. He uses Kelce on "find the hole" routes.
Don't fall for the trap of thinking the Chiefs are "vulnerable" because they lost to the Raiders on Christmas Day. That was a fluke. A wake-up call. The real Chiefs show up in January. To beat them, you have to be better in January, not September.
Strategic Steps to Toppling the Dynasty
If you're an NFL GM looking for the answer to who can beat the Chiefs, here is the reality-based checklist.
- Invest in Interior Pressure: Don't worry about speed rushers on the edge. Mahomes steps up into the pocket. You need a 320-pounder who can push the center directly into Mahomes' lap. This ruins his vision.
- Draft "Long" Corners: The Chiefs love the intermediate passing game. You need corners with 33-inch arms who can disrupt the catch point.
- The "Middle of the Field" Offense: Kansas City’s safeties are aggressive. You beat them with seams and posts, not sideline fades.
- Psychological Warfare: Don't talk trash. Travis Kelce and Mahomes feed on it. Be the quietest team in the league and just execute.
The era of the Chiefs isn't over. Not by a long shot. But the blueprint is out there. It requires a mix of Cincinnati's nerves, Detroit's violence, and San Francisco's talent.
Actionable Takeaways for the Next Matchup
- Watch the turnover margin. The Chiefs rarely lose when they are +1.
- Look at the "Time of Possession." If the opponent isn't holding the ball for 34+ minutes, they aren't winning.
- Monitor the health of the Chiefs' offensive tackles. That is the one true "on-field" weakness they haven't fully solved.
The next time you sit down to watch a Sunday night game and wonder who can beat the Chiefs, look at the team across the line. If they are trying to be "flashy," they've already lost. If they look like they’re preparing for a 15-round boxing match, they might just have a chance.