It is a story we think we know by heart. Two kids meet at a dance, fall in love instantly, and everything goes to hell because of a neighborhood turf war. But if you actually look at the characters in West Side Story, they aren’t just cardboard cutouts from a Shakespeare play. They are messy. They are scared. Honestly, most of them are just children trying to find a sense of belonging in a city that clearly doesn't want them there. Whether you are watching the original 1957 Broadway run, the iconic 1961 film, or Steven Spielberg’s gritty 2021 reimagining, the DNA of these people remains the same: desperate, vibrant, and doomed.
The Heart of the Conflict: Tony and Maria
Tony is often played as a "golden boy," but that's a bit of a simplification. He’s a co-founder of the Jets who is actively trying to outrun his own shadow. When we first meet him, he’s working at Doc’s drugstore, trying to be "good." He feels something "coming," a sort of spiritual restlessness that Leonard Bernstein captured so perfectly in the music. Tony isn't just a romantic; he's a guy looking for an exit strategy from a violent life.
Then there’s Maria. People sometimes mistake her for being naive. Big mistake. Especially in the 2021 version, we see a Maria who is fiercely independent, someone who is balancing the weight of her brother’s expectations with her own desire to be an American woman. She’s the emotional anchor. When she meets Tony, it isn't just "love at first sight"—it’s a collision of two people who see a way out through each other.
Why Their Romance Fails (Beyond the Ending)
It's easy to blame the stabbing or the miscommunication at the end. But the tragedy of the characters in West Side Story is that they are living in a pressure cooker. Tony and Maria are trying to build a private world in a public war zone. You've got two different cultures, two different languages, and a whole lot of generational trauma standing between them. Tony thinks he can stop the rumble with a few words. That's his fatal flaw—he underestimates how deep the hate actually goes.
👉 See also: Billie Eilish Therefore I Am Explained: The Philosophy Behind the Mall Raid
The Leaders: Riff vs. Bernardo
The dynamic between Riff and Bernardo is the engine that drives the plot toward the morgue. Riff is the leader of the Jets, and he is a fascinating study in frantic insecurity. He doesn't have a family; the Jets are his family. He’s charismatic, sure, but there’s a frantic edge to him. He knows the neighborhood is changing. He knows the Jets are losing ground. He’s fighting for a "turf" that the city is planning to bulldoze anyway to build Lincoln Center.
Bernardo, the leader of the Sharks, is his mirror image but with much higher stakes. As an immigrant in 1950s New York, Bernardo isn't just fighting for pride; he’s fighting for respect in a country that treats him like a second-class citizen. He’s protective of Maria to a fault. He sees the Jets not just as rivals, but as the face of the systemic racism he deals with every day. When these two face off, it isn't just a gang fight. It’s a clash of two different kinds of desperation.
Anita: The Real Soul of the Show
If you ask any theater nerd who the best character is, they will say Anita every single time. Chita Rivera, Rita Moreno, and Ariana DeBose all won or were nominated for massive awards for this role for a reason. Anita is the bridge. She loves Bernardo, she cares for Maria, and she actually tries to navigate the "American Dream."
✨ Don't miss: Bad For Me Lyrics Kevin Gates: The Messy Truth Behind the Song
She’s pragmatic. In the song "America," she argues for the benefits of the U.S. while Bernardo points out the flaws. But her arc is the most tragic of all the characters in West Side Story. She’s the one who suffers the most "collateral damage." The scene in the drugstore—where the Jets harass and nearly assault her—is the turning point of the whole show. It’s the moment the "fun" of the gang rivalry turns into something truly ugly and unforgivable. Anita’s decision to lie to Tony about Maria’s death isn't "evil." It’s a reaction to trauma. She’s broken, and in her brokenness, she breaks the last hope for a happy ending.
The "Other" Jets: Anybodys and the Lost Boys
We have to talk about Anybodys. For decades, this character was written as a "tomboy" who just wanted to be one of the guys. In modern interpretations, Anybodys is often portrayed as a trans-masculine or non-binary individual. This adds a whole new layer to the Jets. They are a group of outcasts who are, ironically, excluding someone else who is an outcast. Anybodys is the one who sees everything, hears everything, and eventually tries to help Tony.
Then you have the rest of the crew:
🔗 Read more: Ashley Johnson: The Last of Us Voice Actress Who Changed Everything
- Action: The one with the shortest fuse. He’s pure adrenaline.
- A-Rab and Baby John: Usually the youngest, showing how this cycle of violence recruits kids before they even know what they’re fighting for.
- Diesel/Ice: The muscle. In "Gee, Officer Krupke," these characters show a rare moment of self-awareness, basically telling the audience: "We aren't bad; we're just a product of a broken system."
The Adults: A Study in Failure
Doc, Officer Krupke, and Glad Hand represent the world that failed these kids. Doc is the only one who actually cares, but he’s powerless. He watches Tony, a kid he loves, throw his life away. Krupke and Lieutenant Schrank represent the law, but they are either incompetent or overtly racist. Schrank, in particular, is a loathsome character because he tries to manipulate the gangs against each other. He doesn't want peace; he just wants the "elements" he doesn't like to wipe each other out.
Key Takeaways for Understanding the Cast
To truly grasp why these characters resonate decades later, you have to look past the finger-snapping.
- The age factor matters. These are teenagers. When Tony kills Bernardo, it's a panicked mistake by a kid who doesn't know how to handle a knife. When Maria screams at the end, it's the sound of a girl whose childhood was stripped away in 48 hours.
- The "Villian" is invisible. The real villain isn't Riff or Bernardo. It’s the poverty, the lack of opportunity, and the urban renewal projects that were literally tearing these neighborhoods apart while the story was being written.
- Language is a weapon. Notice how the characters use language to exclude others. The Jets use slang to feel superior; the Sharks use Spanish to create a safe space that the Jets can’t enter.
What to Do Next
If you want to dive deeper into the world of characters in West Side Story, your next step shouldn't just be re-watching the movie. Start by listening to the original Broadway cast recording from 1957. Pay close attention to the lyrics Stephen Sondheim wrote for "Gee, Officer Krupke" and "A Boy Like That." The lyrics reveal more about the character motivations than almost any dialogue in the script.
After that, look up the history of San Juan Hill in New York City. Understanding the actual neighborhood that was destroyed to build the set for the film gives you a haunting perspective on why the Jets and Sharks were so desperate to hold onto their "turf." Seeing the real-world displacement makes the anger of characters like Bernardo feel much more grounded in reality rather than just stage drama.
Finally, compare the 1961 and 2021 versions of the "Drugstore" scene. Observe how the portrayal of the Jets' behavior toward Anita has evolved. It’s a masterclass in how modern directors re-interpret classic characters to reflect our changing understanding of social dynamics and consent. This isn't just a musical; it's a mirror.