The energy at the Ovens Auditorium in Charlotte wasn't just loud; it was vibrating. If you've ever been to a live taping of the world's biggest weekly comedy podcast, you know the vibe is part high-wire act, part public execution. But the killers of Kill Tony Charlotte didn't just survive the bucket—they dismantled the room. Tony Hinchcliffe, Brian Redban, and the panel (which featured the legendary Shane Gillis and Mark Normand) weren't exactly taking it easy on the locals.
North Carolina has a sneaky good comedy scene. It’s not just the big clubs in Raleigh or Charlotte; it's the grit of the open mics where these people actually sharpen their teeth. When the show rolled into the Queen City, the stakes felt different. It wasn't just another tour stop. It was a chance for a random person working a 9-to-5 at a bank in Uptown to become a "regular" or at least get a fist bump from the Young Bull himself.
The Standouts Who Crushed the Ovens Auditorium
Most people who get pulled from the bucket on Kill Tony bomb. Hard. It’s the nature of the beast. You have 60 seconds to prove you aren't a total waste of space, and then you have to survive a 15-minute interrogation from a guy who makes a living finding your deepest insecurities. But a few names rose above the noise during the Charlotte stop.
Heath Cordes is a name that comes up often when talking about the killers from this specific era of the tour. While he’s now a staple of the Austin scene, his appearances during the tour run showed exactly why Tony keeps him around. He has that "it" factor—a mix of vulnerability and a total lack of fear. In Charlotte, the local pulls were a mixed bag, but the ones who hit, hit big.
There was a specific energy with the local comics. You could tell who had been grinding at The Evening Muse or The Comedy Zone. The difference between a "killer" and a "casual" on this show usually comes down to the first 15 seconds. If you don't get a laugh by then, Tony is already looking for his bell. The comics who succeeded in Charlotte stayed away from "cliché regional humor." No one wanted to hear 60 seconds of jokes about Bojangles or the 485 traffic. The people who actually "killed" were the ones who brought weird, specific, personal observations that caught Shane Gillis off guard.
Why Shane Gillis and Mark Normand Changed the Dynamic
Having Shane and Mark on the panel is basically a cheat code for a good episode. They are "comics' comics." When a bucket pull is struggling, Mark Normand can save a segment with a single pun that lands like a heat-seeking missile. Shane, on the other hand, acts like the audience’s proxy. If someone is being fake or trying too hard to be "woke" or "edgy," he calls it out instantly.
The killers of Kill Tony Charlotte had to navigate a panel that was arguably more talented than any group of judges in late-night TV. That’s the irony of the show. You’re performing for the crowd, yeah, but you’re really trying to make the guys behind the table laugh. If you get a genuine cackle out of Gillis, your career just changed.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
The Mechanics of a Kill Tony "Killer"
What does it actually mean to kill? It’s not just about the jokes. It’s the interview. Honestly, the set is only 20% of the battle. The real killers are the ones who can riff.
In the Charlotte show, we saw a couple of performers who had "bad" sets but "great" interviews. That’s the secret sauce. Tony loves a character. If you’re a weirdo, be the weirdest version of yourself. The moment you try to act like a polished professional, Tony smells the blood in the water.
- Commitment to the Bit: You can't half-ass a joke about your divorce or your weird toe. You have to go all in.
- Reading the Room: The Ovens Auditorium is big. It’s not a cozy club. You have to project. You have to own the stage physically.
- Handling the Roast: If Tony says you look like a "failed magician who lives in a Kia Sorento," you can't get offended. You have to lean into it.
The people who failed in Charlotte were the ones who got defensive. The killers were the ones who laughed along and then fired back a decent line.
The "Hans Kim" Factor in Charlotte
Hans Kim’s opening set is always a barometer for the night. In Charlotte, the crowd gave him a hero’s welcome. It sets a high bar. When a regular like Hans or Kam Patterson comes out and destroys, it puts an immense amount of pressure on the bucket pulls. You’re following world-class talent.
Kam Patterson, specifically, has a style that resonates in the South. His high-energy, "I don't give a damn" attitude worked perfectly for the Charlotte demographic. He’s a killer by definition because he doesn't just tell jokes; he commands the room's attention. When he’s on stage, nobody is looking at their phone.
The Dark Side of the Bucket: The Bombs
We can't talk about the killers without talking about the deaths. Charlotte had its fair share of "cringe" moments. There was one pull—I won't name names to be kind—who spent 45 seconds explaining the premise of a joke and never actually got to the punchline.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Tony’s reaction was legendary.
That’s part of the draw, though. You aren't just watching for the talent; you’re watching for the train wreck. The "killers" look even better when contrasted against someone who is visibly shaking and forgetting their own name. It’s gladiatorial.
Local Comedy Scene Impact
Ever since that show, the Charlotte comedy scene has seen a bit of a bump. People realize that the "Kill Tony" path is a real thing. If you’re good enough, you can get noticed. You don't necessarily have to move to LA or New York immediately anymore. Austin is the mecca, but the tour stops prove that talent is everywhere.
The killers of Kill Tony Charlotte weren't all seasoned pros. Some were just people who had the guts to put their name in a bucket and the presence of mind to stay cool under the brightest lights in the industry.
How to Prepare if the Bucket Comes for You
If you're a comic in a city like Charlotte and you hear Kill Tony is coming to town, you don't just "show up." You prepare. But you don't prepare a "tight five." You prepare a "perfect one."
Most comics make the mistake of trying to cram three jokes into sixty seconds. It’s too much. The killers usually pick one strong premise, one tag, and leave room for the audience to breathe.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Watch the regulars. Study William Montgomery. He’s the "Big Red Machine" for a reason. He doesn't just tell jokes; he creates a chaotic environment where he is the only one who knows the rules. In Charlotte, his closing set was a masterclass in controlled insanity. He’s the ultimate killer because he is completely unpredictable.
Know your "Why."
Why are you on stage? If it’s just to be famous, you’ll fail. If it’s because you have something genuinely funny or weird to say, you have a chance. The Charlotte audience was savvy. They could tell who was "doing a bit" and who was actually being themselves.
Master the "Save."
If a joke bombs, you need a "save." A quick comment about how much that joke sucked often gets a bigger laugh than the joke itself would have. This is what separates the killers from the amateurs.
Actionable Steps for Aspiring Killers
If you're looking to replicate the success of the standouts from the Charlotte show, here is the blueprint:
- Record every set you do. Listen back to the silences, not just the laughs. That’s where you’re losing the room.
- Practice the "Interview." Have a friend ask you uncomfortable questions about your life and try to stay funny. This is harder than writing jokes.
- Go to open mics at least four nights a week. There is no substitute for stage time. The comics who killed in Charlotte were clearly the ones who lived in the clubs.
- Study the "Kill Tony" format religiously. Understand when Tony wants you to keep talking and when he wants you to shut up.
The Charlotte show was a reminder that comedy is alive and well in the South. It wasn't just a podcast taping; it was a showcase of what happens when preparation meets a massive opportunity. Whether you're a fan who was in the crowd or a comic looking to be the next big thing, the "killers" of that night provided a template for how to handle the pressure of the bucket.
Go to an open mic this week. Write three new minutes. Stop overthinking it. The bucket is always waiting.