Let’s be real for a second. If you’re scrolling through Marvel forums or arguing with friends at a bar, the question of which Spider-Man has all 3 powers—organic webbing, the "Peter Tingle" spider-sense, and the classic super strength—comes up way more than you'd think. It's a debate that usually ends in people shouting about Tobey Maguire’s wrists or Tom Holland’s high-tech suits. But honestly? The answer isn't just about who has the coolest CGI. It’s about how these three specific pillars of the Spider-Man mythos actually function across the different cinematic universes.
Spider-Man isn't just one guy anymore. We’ve moved past the era where there was only one Peter Parker on screen. Now, we have a literal multiverse of them. When fans ask which Spider-Man has all 3, they’re usually looking for the "Perfect Spider-Man"—the one who doesn't need a gadget to swing, can sense a bullet before it fires, and can stop a literal train with his bare hands.
The Organic Webbing Controversy: Tobey Maguire’s Secret Weapon
Let’s talk about the 2002 Sam Raimi era. Back then, the idea of a teenager building high-tech web-shooters in his bedroom felt a little too "sci-fi" for a general audience. So, they gave Tobey Maguire organic webbing. It comes right out of his wrists.
People freaked out. Some loved it because it made him feel more "mutant-y," while others thought it was gross. But here’s the thing: Tobey is essentially the only cinematic Spider-Man who natively possesses the first of the "Big 3" traits without external help. He doesn't run out of web fluid unless he’s having an emotional crisis (remember Spider-Man 2?).
If we are strictly looking at which Spider-Man has all 3 in terms of biological capability, Tobey gets a massive head start. He has the strength. He has the sense—though his Spider-Sense is often portrayed as a slow-motion cinematic effect rather than the frantic buzzing we see with the newer guys. But the webbing is the kicker. It’s part of his DNA.
Andrew Garfield and the Tech-Heavy Approach
Then we get to the "Amazing" era. Andrew Garfield’s Peter Parker went back to the comic roots. He’s a scientist. He’s a tinkerer. He built his web-shooters using Oscorp technology.
Now, does he have "all 3"? Technically, no. He has the strength and arguably the most reactive Spider-Sense of the bunch. Remember the Times Square scene in The Amazing Spider-Man 2? The way the world freezes as he calculates exactly where every person is standing before the electricity hits them? That’s peak Spider-Sense. But he fails the "all 3" test on the biological front because if he loses those bracelets, he’s just a very strong guy who can jump high.
Tom Holland: The Iron Spider Evolution
Tom Holland’s Peter Parker is a bit of a hybrid. In Spider-Man: No Way Home, we finally saw all these versions together, which really highlighted the differences. Holland’s Spidey relies heavily on Stark tech for his webbing. He’s got web-wings, AI interfaces, and instant-kill modes.
However, by the end of No Way Home, he’s stripped back to basics. He’s in a sewing-machine suit, swinging through a snowy New York. Even then, he’s still using mechanical shooters. So, when people ask which Spider-Man has all 3, Holland usually falls into the category of "has them all via a mix of nature and nurture." He definitely has the strongest "Peter Tingle" (as Aunt May called it), which was famously demonstrated when his astral form fought off Doctor Strange. That’s a level of instinct the other two haven't quite touched.
The Comic Book Context: Does Anyone Actually Have All 3?
In the 616 Marvel Comics universe, Peter Parker usually uses mechanical shooters. But there was a weird period in the mid-2000s—specifically during "The Other" storyline—where Peter evolved. He grew stingers (yeah, weird) and actually gained organic webbing to match the movies.
So, if you’re looking for a version that truly, biologically possesses all three traits—strength, sense, and organic webbing—you have to look at:
- Tobey Maguire's Peter Parker (Cinematic)
- Kaine Parker (The Scarlet Spider clone who has organic webs and strength, but actually lacks the Spider-Sense)
- Miguel O'Hara (Spider-Man 2099, though his "sense" works differently and he has talons)
It’s actually surprisingly rare for a version of Spider-Man to have all three as purely biological traits. Usually, there’s a trade-off. You get the webbing, but you lose the sense. You get the strength, but you need the tech.
Why the "All 3" Question Matters for Fans
The reason people obsess over which Spider-Man has all 3 is because it defines the power ceiling of the character. A Spider-Man with organic webbing is technically "more" of a spider, but a Spider-Man with mechanical shooters is "more" of a genius.
Most fans argue that Tobey Maguire is the definitive answer to which Spider-Man has all 3 because he is the only one who doesn't need a lab to be a superhero. He woke up after a bite and was a fully-functional, web-slinging machine. There is a certain purity to that which resonates with people who find the high-tech suits of the MCU a bit too "Iron Man Junior."
Breaking Down the Power Sets
If we were to look at a checklist of these three legendary traits, here is how the big screen favorites stack up:
The Strength Factor
All three movie Peters are absurdly strong. Tobey stopped a subway train. Andrew caught a speeding car like it was a frisbee. Tom held a literal ferry together with some help from his webs. They all pass the strength test with flying colors.
The Spider-Sense Factor
This is where it gets murky. While they all have it, the "No Way Home" bridge fight showed that Tom Holland’s sense might be the most "supernatural," allowing him to react even when his soul is literally removed from his body. Tobey’s sense is more about combat awareness, and Andrew’s is about environmental scanning.
📖 Related: Why the actors in Grand Budapest Hotel are still the best ensemble in cinema
The Webbing Factor
This is the divider.
- Tobey: Organic.
- Andrew: Mechanical.
- Tom: Mechanical.
So, in the strictest sense of the word, if the "3" you are looking for are organic webs, spider-sense, and super strength, Tobey Maguire is the only one who fits the bill.
Real-World Implications of the Webbing Debate
Interestingly, Stan Lee and Steve Ditko originally chose mechanical shooters because they wanted to show that Peter Parker was a brilliant scientist. They wanted him to have a "flaw"—the possibility of running out of webs. Giving a character everything makes them a little too powerful, and Peter is supposed to be the underdog.
When Sam Raimi decided to go organic, he actually consulted with James Cameron, who had written a Spider-Man treatment years prior that featured organic webs. The logic was simple: if he turns into a spider, why can't he make silk? It makes logical sense, but it removes that "tinkerer" aspect of the character.
What You Should Take Away
Identifying which Spider-Man has all 3 isn't just about winning a trivia night. It's about understanding what version of the character you prefer. Do you like the "Mutant" style Spider-Man who is a biological marvel? Or do you like the "Science Hero" who uses his brain to supplement his powers?
If you want the biological "All 3," Tobey is your guy.
If you want the most "Comic Accurate" sense and strength, Andrew Garfield often takes the crown for his agility.
If you want the most "Modern/Evolved" version of the sense, Tom Holland is the clear winner.
Next Steps for the Super-Fan:
- Watch the "No Way Home" Final Battle: Pay close attention to how the three Peters interact. You'll notice Tobey never mentions running out of webs, while the others are constantly managing their tech.
- Check Out "Spider-Man: The Other" (Comics): If you want to see the 616 Peter Parker actually gain organic webs and "all 3" traits for a brief period in comic history.
- Revisit the 1990s Animated Series: This version is famous for having a Peter Parker who is terrified of "mutating" further, which adds a lot of depth to the organic vs. mechanical debate.
Ultimately, the beauty of the character is that there isn't one "perfect" version. Whether they have organic webs or a high-tech suit, the core of the character remains the same: with great power comes great responsibility. Even if that power comes from a biological wrist-gland or a canister of chemical fluid.