It sounds like the setup for a dark joke or a weird creepypasta, doesn't it? But honestly, when people search for which SNL host killed someone, they aren't looking for a "whodunnit" movie plot. They're looking for the very real, very tragic 1987 car accident involving Hollywood golden boy Matthew Broderick.
It's a strange bit of trivia that sits uncomfortably alongside his image as the charming, rule-breaking Ferris Bueller. Most people know him for the vest and the parade float. They don't know about the rain-slicked road in Northern Ireland that changed several lives forever.
The 1987 crash in Enniskillen
The year was 1987. Broderick was at the absolute peak of his "it-boy" status. He was vacationing in Ireland with his then-girlfriend and Dirty Dancing star, Jennifer Grey. They were driving a rented BMW 316 on a wet road near Enniskillen.
Then, everything went wrong.
For reasons that have never been fully explained—and perhaps Broderick himself doesn't even remember due to the trauma—his car crossed into the wrong lane. He struck an oncoming Volvo head-on. The occupants of that Volvo, 28-year-old Anna Gallagher and her 63-year-old mother, Margaret Doherty, were killed instantly.
Broderick didn't walk away unscathed. He spent a month in a Belfast hospital with a fractured leg and ribs, a collapsed lung, and a concussion. Jennifer Grey had minor physical injuries but later spoke about how the psychological trauma of the event basically derailed her career right as it was taking off. She felt a profound "survivor's guilt" that made it impossible to celebrate the success of Dirty Dancing, which premiered just weeks after the accident.
The legal aftermath and the "careless driving" controversy
If you're wondering how someone can be involved in a double fatality and still go on to host Saturday Night Live multiple times, the answer lies in the legal outcome. Originally, Broderick was charged with "causing death by dangerous driving." This carried a potential prison sentence of up to five years.
However, the charge was eventually reduced to "careless driving."
He was fined 100 pounds (about $175 at the time).
To the victims' family, this felt like a slap in the face. Martin Doherty, the son and brother of the women killed, famously called the verdict a "travesty of justice." There was no evidence of drugs or alcohol being involved. It was just a catastrophic mistake on a narrow road. Broderick has since stated he has no memory of the day, starting from when he woke up in his hotel to when he woke up in the hospital.
Why this comes up with SNL
Broderick has hosted Saturday Night Live twice. His first stint was in 1988, surprisingly soon after the accident. He hosted again in 1998. Because SNL is such a massive cultural touchstone, fans often dig into the backgrounds of the hosts, leading to the recurring question of which SNL host killed someone.
It’s one of those "glitch in the Matrix" facts. You see him singing and dancing on a stage in 30 Rock, and it's hard to reconcile that with a tragic roadside in Ireland.
But he isn't the only one associated with the show who has a dark history. While Broderick is the most common answer to the specific "host" question, the show's history is littered with tragedy. We could talk about the various cast members who died young, but when it comes to "killing someone," the conversation usually starts and ends with that BMW in Enniskillen.
The nuance of celebrity "cancellation" before the internet
In the late 80s, information didn't move the way it does now. There was no Twitter to dissect every detail of the police report. There were no viral threads demanding he be removed from his next project.
Broderick's career continued almost seamlessly. He did Glory. He did The Lion King. He became a Broadway legend.
Does that mean he "got away with it"? Legally, he paid the fine the court mandated. Morally, that's a much heavier conversation. Broderick did eventually meet with the family members years later, though the details of that meeting remained largely private. It wasn't a PR stunt; it was a quiet attempt at some form of closure.
Other SNL figures with dark legal histories
While Broderick is the "host" people ask about, there are other names that pop up in these deep-dive threads.
- Don Pardo: The legendary announcer was involved in a car accident in 1949 that resulted in a fatality. Like Broderick, it was ruled an accident, but it’s a grim footnote in the life of a man whose voice defined the show for decades.
- The "SNL Curse": People often conflate these accidents with the "curse" that took Belushi, Farley, and Hartman. It’s a different kind of darkness, but it all feeds into the same morbid curiosity about what happens when the cameras aren't rolling.
Addressing the misconceptions
A lot of people think Broderick was drunk. He wasn't. There were no reports of intoxication.
A lot of people think he fled the scene. He didn't. He was pinned in the wreckage and nearly died himself.
The most likely reality is the simplest and most terrifying one: he forgot which side of the road he was supposed to be on in a foreign country. It’s a common mistake for American tourists in the UK and Ireland, but usually, it results in a honked horn or a minor fender bender. In this case, it resulted in two deaths.
How to process this as a fan
It's okay to feel conflicted. You can enjoy The Producers or Ferris Bueller's Day Off while acknowledging that the man behind the characters was responsible for a horrific event. Life is messy. High-profile figures aren't immune to the physics of a car crash or the consequences of a split-second lapse in judgment.
✨ Don't miss: Travis Barker and Kourtney Kardashian: Why Kravis Still Matters in 2026
If you are looking for more information on the legal specifics of the case, you can find archival reports from the Belfast Telegraph or the New York Times from that era. They provide a stark, non-sensationalized look at the proceedings.
To really understand the impact of this event, look at the timeline of Jennifer Grey’s career. She has been very open about how that moment changed her entire trajectory. It’s a reminder that even when the legal system moves on, the people involved often don't.
Next Steps for Research:
- Check out Jennifer Grey’s memoir, Out of the Corner, where she discusses the emotional toll of the 1987 accident in detail.
- Research the "Enniskillen accident" in Irish newspaper archives for a perspective on how the local community viewed the light sentencing.
- Compare the 1987 case with more recent celebrity driving incidents to see how public perception and "cancel culture" have shifted over forty years.