Which Playboys Are Worth Money: What Most People Get Wrong

You found a stack of old magazines in the attic. Or maybe you inherited a box from an uncle who "collected" them for the articles. Either way, you're staring at a pile of glossy covers and wondering if you’ve just hit the retirement jackpot.

I’m gonna be real with you right now: Most of them are worth less than the paper they're printed on.

It's a tough pill to swallow. People see the name "Playboy" and think dollar signs, but the truth is that by the 1970s, the magazine was printing millions of copies every single month. They were everywhere. Doctors' offices, garages, dorm rooms—everyone had them. And because so many people "saved" them, they aren't rare.

But don't toss that box just yet. There are absolutely specific issues that can pay for a very nice vacation, or in extreme cases, a new car. If you want to know which Playboys are worth money, you have to look for the "Firsts," the "Glitches," and the "Icons."

The Holy Grail: Issue No. 1 (December 1953)

If you have this, you're looking at the only issue that is universally, consistently valuable. It features Marilyn Monroe on the cover and as the first-ever Sweetheart of the Month (before they even called them Playmates).

👉 See also: Draft House Las Vegas: Why Locals Still Flock to This Old School Sports Bar

Hugh Hefner didn't even put a date on the cover because he wasn't sure there would ever be a second issue.

Condition is everything here. A "beater" copy with a split spine or coffee stains might still fetch $700 to $1,500. But if you have one that looks like it was bought yesterday? We’re talking different levels of wealth. In 2023, a copy graded 9.4 by CGC sold for a staggering **$120,000**. Even mid-grade copies can easily pull $5,000 to $10,000 at auction.

How to spot a fake

Because this issue is so valuable, there are tons of reprints out there. Look at the price. The original says "50c" on the cover. If you see a "Commemorative Edition" or a $5.00 price tag, it’s a reprint. Nice for a coffee table, but worth about ten bucks.

The Rest of the 1950s: The Rarities

Basically, if the magazine was printed before 1960, it has value. In the early days, the circulation was low. People weren't hoarding them yet.

✨ Don't miss: Dr Dennis Gross C+ Collagen Brighten Firm Vitamin C Serum Explained (Simply)

• January 1954 (Issue #2): This is the first one with a date and the first appearance of the Rabbit logo. It’s significantly rarer than most people realize. A clean copy can land you between $2,000 and $4,000.
• January 1955: This is the Bettie Page issue. She’s the queen of pinups, and her fans are obsessive. Collectors will pay $1,500 to $3,000 for a crisp copy of this one.
• The "Red Star" Variants: Some early issues from 1954 have a small red star on the cover. These are distribution markers and are incredibly sought after by completionists. A Red Star #1 can actually be worth more than a standard #1 to the right buyer because of the rarity.

The "Celebrity Bump" and 1980s Rarities

Once you hit the 60s and 70s, the values take a nose dive. You might get $10 to $20 for a 1960s issue in great shape, but the 70s stuff is often sold in bulk for a dollar a piece.

However, there are "Key Issues" where a specific celebrity appearance drives the price up regardless of the year.

Madonna (September 1985)
This is a weird one. The photos were taken before she was famous, and when they finally ran, it was a massive scandal. Because it was a huge seller, there are many copies out there, but the demand stays high. A truly mint, unread copy can actually pull around $2,000 today, though most "found" copies sell for $50 to $100.

Bo Derek (March 1980)
Bo Derek was the "it girl" of the moment. While you can find average copies on eBay for $40, a professionally graded, Gem Mint copy once sold for nearly $12,000. It’s all about the grade.

🔗 Read more: Double Sided Ribbon Satin: Why the Pro Crafters Always Reach for the Good Stuff

Pamela Anderson (October 1989)
This was her first cover. She eventually did 13 of them, but the first one is the "Rookie Card" of the Playboy world. Collectors look for this specifically. A perfect copy has moved for $3,500 in recent years.

Other honorable mentions:

1. Vanna White (May 1987): Still very popular with collectors of 80s nostalgia.
2. Anna Nicole Smith (March 1992): Her debut as "Vickie Smith" is the one to look for.
3. Drew Barrymore (January 1995): A massive cultural moment that keeps this issue in the $50-$100 range for high-quality copies.
4. Donald Trump (March 1990): Love him or hate him, his cover is a political collectible that carries a premium.

Condition is the Only Thing That Matters

I cannot stress this enough. If your magazines have been sitting in a humid garage and the staples are rusty, the value is gone. Collectors use a 10-point scale.

A "9.8" (Near Mint/Mint) is worth fifty times more than a "5.0" (Very Good).

The Checklist for Value

• The Centerfold: If it’s missing or detached, the value drops by 90%.
• The Spine: Are there "stress lines" (tiny white creases)? Is it split at the bottom?
• The Mailing Label: Magazines sent via subscription have a white address label stuck to the cover. Collectors hate these. "Newsstand" copies (no label) are always worth more.
• Smell: If it smells like a damp basement, it has mold. Mold is the death of paper collectibles.

Where to Actually Sell Them

Don't go to a local used bookstore. They’ll offer you pennies.

If you think you have a "Key Issue" (like the ones mentioned above), your best bet is Heritage Auctions or eBay. For the high-end stuff like a 1953 #1, you absolutely need to get it "slabbed." This means sending it to a company like CGC (Certified Guaranty Company). They grade it and seal it in a plastic case. It’s expensive, but it’s the only way to prove to a buyer that your "mint" copy is actually mint.

For large collections of "common" issues from the 70s and 80s, honestly? Sell them as "Year Sets." A full year of 1974 might get you $50, whereas selling them individually would take forever and cost more in shipping than the magazines are worth.

Actionable Steps for Your Collection

1. Sort by Decade: Pull out everything from the 1950s immediately. These are your "keep" items.
2. Check for Labels: Separate the "Newsstand" copies from the "Subscription" copies.
3. Inspect the "Big Names": Look for Marilyn Monroe, Bettie Page, Madonna, Pamela Anderson, and Bo Derek.
4. Look for the 1953 No. 1: Check the price on the cover. If it says 50 cents and there's no date, take it to a professional.
5. Buy Mylar Bags: If you find anything potentially valuable, get it into a PVC-free plastic bag with a backing board immediately to stop the aging process.