Christopher Columbus was a man obsessed with movement. He spent his life trying to get from point A to point B, usually getting lost in the process, so it’s honestly kind of fitting that his body couldn't just stay in one place after he died. If you’re looking for a simple answer to the question where was Columbus buried, you’re going to be disappointed. There isn't one single spot. Or rather, there are several, depending on who you ask and which DNA test you trust.
He died in 1506. Valladolid, Spain.
At the time, he wasn't exactly the legendary figure he’d later become. He was a bitter, frustrated man who felt cheated out of his riches. He was buried there in a modest ceremony, but he didn't stay long. Not even close. What followed was a 500-year-long game of musical chairs involving two continents, multiple cathedrals, and a box of bones that might—or might not—be the wrong guy.
The Caribbean commute: Why the body kept moving
Columbus actually wanted to be buried in the "New World." He specifically mentioned Hispaniola in his will. But back in 1506, the infrastructure for a grand tomb in the Caribbean just wasn't there. So, he started his posthumous journey. First, his remains were moved to a monastery in Seville.
Then things got complicated.
In 1537, Maria de Rojas y Toledo—the widow of Columbus's son, Diego—sent the remains of both her husband and her father-in-law across the Atlantic to Santo Domingo. They were placed in the Cathedral of Santa María la Menor. This was the dream. He was finally where he wanted to be. But the Spanish Empire was messy. By 1795, Spain lost control of Hispaniola to the French. Not wanting the Great Admiral's bones to fall into French hands, the Spanish dug them up and rushed them to Havana, Cuba.
Fast forward to 1898. The Spanish-American War happens. Spain loses Cuba. Once again, they pack up the crate of bones and ship it back across the ocean to Seville.
📖 Related: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable
The 1877 discovery that changed everything
While the Spanish were convinced they had the real Columbus in Seville, workers in Santo Domingo stumbled onto something weird in 1877. They were excavating the cathedral and found a lead box.
The box had an inscription: "Illustrious and enlightened male, Don Cristobal Colon."
Wait.
If the Spanish took Columbus to Cuba in 1795, whose bones were in this box? The Dominicans immediately claimed that the Spanish had grabbed the wrong body back in the 18th century. They argued that the Spanish accidentally took the remains of Diego Columbus (his son) or perhaps another relative, leaving the Admiral himself behind in the soil of the Americas. This created a massive historical rift. For over a century, two different cities—Seville in Spain and Santo Domingo in the Dominican Republic—both claimed to be the final answer to where was Columbus buried.
The Dominicans eventually built the Faro a Colón (Columbus Lighthouse), a massive, cross-shaped monument that looks like something out of a sci-fi movie, specifically to house these remains.
Science enters the chat: The DNA results
For a long time, this was just a "he said, she said" argument between two nations. But in the early 2000s, forensic scientist José Antonio Lorente from the University of Granada decided to settle it. He got permission to open the tomb in Seville.
👉 See also: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
The remains in Seville are... sparse. It’s basically a handful of bone fragments.
The team compared the DNA from these fragments to the DNA of Columbus’s brother, Giacomo (also known as Diego), who was definitely buried in Seville. In 2006, the results came back. It was a match. The bones in Seville are, at least partially, the remains of Christopher Columbus.
Does that mean the case is closed? Nope.
The Dominican Republic has consistently refused to allow DNA testing on the bones in the Faro a Colón. They’re protective. They argue that because the Seville remains are so incomplete—just a fraction of a skeleton—it’s entirely possible that the body was split up at some point. It’s a very real possibility that parts of Columbus are in Spain and other parts are still in the Caribbean. Bones get lost. Boxes get mixed up. In the 1500s, record-keeping wasn't exactly digital.
Why does this even matter now?
It’s easy to look at this as just a weird trivia point. But the location of his body is tied up in national identity. For Spain, having the remains is a connection to the "Age of Discovery" and their former global power. For the Dominican Republic, it’s a matter of holding onto the history of the land itself.
Honestly, the "where" is less interesting than the "how." The fact that a man who spent his life navigating by the stars ended up as a fragmented puzzle scattered across the ocean he crossed is peak irony.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
When you visit Seville today, you see a massive tomb held aloft by four figures representing the kingdoms of Spain. It’s grand. It’s imposing. It’s also maybe 15% of a person. If you go to Santo Domingo, you see a sprawling concrete monument that beams light into the sky so brightly it can be seen from Puerto Rico.
Making sense of the locations
If you’re planning a trip to see the sites, here is the breakdown of what you're actually looking at.
In the Seville Cathedral, the tomb is a major tourist draw. It’s located in the south transept. Even if only a few ounces of the man are there, the monument itself is a masterpiece of late 19th-century sculpture. It’s a symbolic burial. It represents the return of the explorer to the country that funded his gamble.
The Faro a Colón in Santo Domingo is different. It’s a mausoleum and a museum. It feels more like a claim of ownership. The Dominicans are quite firm: "The Admiral is here." They view the 1877 discovery as the smoking gun. They believe the Spanish, in their haste to flee the French, grabbed the wrong box from the crypt and have been guarding the wrong guy for over a hundred years.
There are even theories about a third location. Some historians have pointed to the fact that during the various moves, pieces of bone were given away as relics. It was common practice. So, small bits of Columbus might be sitting in private collections or forgotten church basements in Italy or elsewhere in Europe.
Actionable steps for the history buff
If you want to experience this mystery for yourself, don't just read the Wikipedia page. There are better ways to get close to the history.
- Visit Seville in the off-season. The cathedral is a zoo in the summer. Go in February. You can actually stand near the tomb and look at the detail of the four kings carrying the pall without being elbowed by a tour group.
- Check out the Archivo General de Indias. It’s right next to the Seville Cathedral. It holds the actual logs and maps from the voyages. Seeing the handwriting of the man whose bones you just looked at makes the whole "where is he buried" thing feel much more human and less like a science experiment.
- Don't skip the Faro a Colón if you're in the DR. It’s controversial because of the cost and the displacement of local residents when it was built, but as a historical site, it’s unparalleled. The lead box found in 1877 is the centerpiece.
- Look into the DNA study updates. Dr. Lorente’s team is still working. With modern 2026-era sequencing technology, they are trying to narrow down Columbus's exact origins—whether he was truly Genoese, or perhaps Spanish, Jewish, or Greek. This context might eventually lead the Dominican Republic to finally open their box for a definitive comparison.
The reality of where Columbus is buried is that he is probably in two places at once. He’s a divided man for a divided legacy. Whether he’s in a lead box in the Caribbean or a bronze sarcophagus in Spain, his travels haven't really stopped; we're still moving his story around today.
Keep an eye on the University of Granada's research updates. They are the primary source for any new DNA breakthroughs that might finally convince the authorities in Santo Domingo to settle the score. Until then, the Admiral remains a permanent traveler.