You've probably seen the headlines. Maybe you caught a blurry yellow sonar image scrolling through your feed and thought, Finally, they found it. It’s been almost 90 years since Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan vanished into the Pacific blue on July 2, 1937. Since then, we’ve been obsessed. Every few years, someone claims to have found the "smoking gun."
But honestly? The answer to where was Amelia Earhart's plane found is still a bit of a gut-punch for history buffs: It hasn't been found. At least, not yet.
There was a massive wave of excitement in early 2024 when a company called Deep Sea Vision released imagery of a plane-shaped blob 16,000 feet deep. It looked perfect. It had the tail fins. It was in the right area near Howland Island. People were ready to pop the champagne. But by late 2024, the team went back with high-res cameras and realized nature has a sick sense of humor. It was just a pile of rocks.
The Deep Sea Vision "Discovery" Near Howland Island
Tony Romeo, a former Air Force intelligence officer, put $11 million of his own money into finding that Lockheed Electra 10E. His team spent months scanning the floor of the Pacific with a $9 million autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV). When they surfaced with a sonar image showing a distinct aircraft shape about 100 miles west of Howland Island, the world stopped.
It made sense. Howland was where they were supposed to land. If they ran out of gas, they should be right there, sitting in the deep.
Romeo called it "the cruelest formation ever created by nature." When they returned for a second look in November 2024, the "plane" turned out to be a natural rock formation. It’s a classic example of pareidolia—our brains wanting to see a familiar shape in the chaos of the seafloor. Even though that lead went cold, it confirmed one thing: if the plane is near Howland, it’s sitting in some of the most rugged, soul-crushing terrain on the planet.
✨ Don't miss: Why Every Tornado Warning MN Now Live Alert Demands Your Immediate Attention
The Taraia Object: Why 2026 is the New Big Year
If you’re looking for where the plane might actually be, you have to look 400 miles southeast of Howland to a tiny, sun-scorched atoll called Nikumaroro. This is the "Gardner Island Hypothesis." The idea is that Amelia missed Howland, followed a navigation line (the 157/337 line she mentioned in her last radio call), and landed on a flat reef at Nikumaroro.
Researchers from Purdue University and the Archaeological Legacy Institute (ALI) are currently zeroing in on something called the Taraia Object.
It’s an anomaly in the island’s lagoon.
It shows up on satellite imagery from 2020.
More importantly, researchers found it on aerial photos from 1938.
They were supposed to go in late 2025, but the South Pacific weather and government permit delays pushed the expedition to 2026. This isn't just another sonar scan. They are planning to use a hydraulic dredge to literally suck the silt away from whatever is buried in that lagoon. If it’s the Electra, we’ll know soon.
Why Nikumaroro feels different
The International Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery (TIGHAR) has been screaming about this island for decades. They’ve found things that are hard to ignore:
🔗 Read more: Brian Walshe Trial Date: What Really Happened with the Verdict
- A size-9 woman’s shoe heel from the 1930s.
- An aluminum panel that matches the Electra’s window patch.
- Remnants of a campfire with bird and turtle bones.
- A sextant box that might have belonged to Fred Noonan.
The theory is that the plane landed on the reef, stayed there for a few days while Amelia sent out radio distress calls, and then was washed over the edge by the tide. If that's the case, the main wreckage might be in deep water off the reef, while smaller bits—like the Taraia Object—could be stuck in the lagoon.
The "Crash and Sink" vs. "The Castaway"
Basically, the world of Earhart experts is split into two camps.
Camp A believes in the "Crash and Sink" theory. They think she ran out of fuel, ditched in the water near Howland Island, and the plane broke up and sank immediately. If they’re right, the plane is 18,000 feet down in a place so dark and pressurized that finding it is like finding a needle in a thousand haystacks.
Camp B is the "Nikumaroro/Castaway" group. They think she landed safely, lived as a castaway for weeks, and eventually died on the island. This theory is way more romantic, but it’s also backed by those weird artifacts. Skeptics, like Ric Gillespie (who actually leads TIGHAR), have been to the lagoon before and haven't found the plane yet, so the Purdue 2026 mission has a lot of pressure on it to deliver something real.
Is there any truth to the Marshall Islands theory?
You might have seen a documentary a few years back about a photo showing Amelia and Fred in the Marshall Islands, suggesting they were captured by the Japanese.
💡 You might also like: How Old is CHRR? What People Get Wrong About the Ohio State Research Giant
I’ll be blunt: most serious historians think this is bunk.
The photo was later found in a Japanese travelogue published before Amelia even disappeared. While it makes for a great spy movie plot, there is zero physical evidence—no serial numbers, no plane parts, no DNA—to support the idea that they were taken to Saipan.
What happens next?
We are currently in a waiting game. The technology has finally caught up to the mystery. In the 1930s, the Navy was looking for a plane with binoculars and slow boats. Today, we have AUVs that can map the ocean floor in 4K resolution and satellite tech that can see through water.
Actionable Next Steps for Enthusiasts:
- Track the Purdue Expedition: Keep an eye on the Purdue Research Foundation updates for the 2026 Taraia Object mission. This is the most "active" lead we have.
- Check the TIGHAR Archives: If you want to see the actual photos of the artifacts found on Nikumaroro, their website is a rabbit hole of forensic reports.
- Visit the Hangar Museum: The Amelia Earhart Hangar Museum in Atchison, Kansas, has a restored Lockheed Electra 10E (the "Muriel"). Seeing the size of that thing in person makes you realize how tiny it was against the vastness of the Pacific.
The search for where Amelia Earhart's plane was found continues, but the map is shrinking. Whether it's a pile of aluminum in a lagoon or a crushed fuselage three miles down, we are closer than we've ever been.