It is a beautiful estate, really. If you saw Fox Hollow Farm without knowing its history, you’d probably think it was just another multimillion-dollar piece of Indiana real estate. But for anyone who follows true crime, that name carries a heavy, suffocating weight. This was the hunting ground of Herb Baumeister. In the mid-90s, while he was playing the part of a successful businessman and family man, he was allegedly luring men back to this property. They never left.
If you are looking for where to watch the fox hollow murders specials or documentaries, you’ve probably noticed that the content is scattered across half a dozen different streaming platforms. It is frustrating. You find a title on Google, click it, and realize it’s "currently unavailable" or requires a subscription to a service you’ve never heard of.
The story is resurfacing lately because, honestly, the investigation isn't over. Even though Baumeister took his own life in 1996 before he could be tried, investigators are still identifying remains found on the property. As of 2024 and 2025, new DNA technology has allowed coroners to put names to bone fragments that sat in storage for decades. It makes these documentaries feel less like history and more like active crime scenes.
The Most Comprehensive Documentaries on the Baumeister Case
If you want the full story from the beginning, you basically have to start with the classics. A lot of people go straight to Investigative Reports or American Justice. These were produced back when the case was fresh, and they have that gritty, 90s newsroom feel that actually makes them feel more authentic.
You can usually find the American Justice episode titled "The Secret Life of Herb Baumeister" on A&E Crime Central. If you have an Amazon Prime Video account, you can add the A&E channel as a trial to watch it. It’s worth it because they interview the actual detectives who were there when the bones were first uncovered by Baumeister's young son. That detail always gets me. Imagine being a kid and finding a skull in your backyard while your dad tries to explain it away as a "medical mannequin."
Then there is The 11th Hour. This one is a bit harder to track down but occasionally pops up on YouTube through official true crime channels like Real Stories. It’s a deeper look into the psychology. Baumeister wasn't just a killer; he was a guy who owned a chain of thrift stores called Sav-A-Lot. He was a pillar of the community. Seeing the contrast between his public life and the "Vary" persona he used at the gay bars in Indianapolis is chilling.
Paranormal Leanings: Ghost Adventures and More
Now, some people aren't just looking for the facts; they want the "spooky" side. Because Fox Hollow Farm is still a private residence (and yes, people actually live there), it has become a magnet for paranormal investigators.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Zak Bagans and the Ghost Adventures crew did a famous episode there. If you want to see that specific take on the fox hollow murders, you need to head over to Discovery+ or Max. It’s Season 9, Episode 9. They spend a lot of time in the woods and the indoor pool area. Even if you’re a skeptic, seeing the layout of the house—the "man cave" area where Baumeister spent his time—gives you a spatial understanding of how he kept his secrets hidden from his wife and kids.
There is also Paranormal Witness. The episode "The Fox Hollow Farm" is widely considered one of the scariest things ever aired on the Syfy channel. You can find this on Peacock or for purchase on Apple TV. It focuses on the experiences of subsequent tenants who moved into the property after the murders. They describe seeing a man in a red shirt wandering the woods. Interestingly, Baumeister was often seen in a red shirt.
New Developments and Recent Specials
You shouldn't just stick to the old stuff. Because the Hamilton County Coroner’s Office has been so active recently, newer news specials are actually more informative regarding the victims. For years, there were dozens of unidentified remains.
ID (Investigation Discovery) has featured the case in several anthology series like Evil Lives Here. This is arguably the best produced version of the story. You can stream this on Max or Discovery+. They focus heavily on the perspective of the people who knew him. It’s one thing to hear a narrator talk about a killer; it’s another to see the look in the eyes of someone who shared a bed with one.
The recent identification of victims like Manuel Resendez and Allen Livingston has sparked a wave of local news documentaries. While these aren't always on the big streaming apps, WRTV Indianapolis has an extensive archive on their website and YouTube channel. This is where you get the "E-E-A-T" (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) of the case. Local journalists like Kara Kenney have been hounding this story for years. They have the documents. They have the raw footage of the excavations.
Why the Fox Hollow Story is Hard to Categorize
Is it a serial killer documentary? A haunting story? A failure of 90s policing? It's all of them. One of the reasons it's so hard to find a "definitive" place to watch everything is because the case covers so many angles.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
- The Legal Angle: How did he evade police for so long?
- The Social Angle: The targeting of the LGBTQ+ community in the 90s.
- The Forensic Angle: How DNA is finally bringing closure in 2026.
If you are looking for the most "human" side of the story, look for interviews with the survivors. Yes, there were people who got away. Tony Harris is a name you’ll see pop up. He was a man who went to the farm, sensed something was deeply wrong, and managed to leave. His testimony was eventually what helped break the case wide open. You can see his interviews in most of the ID Channel specials.
A Quick Reference for Where to Stream
Honestly, the streaming landscape changes every month. Licensing deals expire, shows move from Netflix to Hulu, and then they vanish into "rent only" territory. But as of right now, here is the best way to navigate it:
- Max (formerly HBO Max): This is your best bet for high-quality production. It houses the Ghost Adventures episode and various Discovery ID specials.
- Discovery+: Since they merged with Warner Bros, the content is similar to Max, but sometimes they have the older "Legacy" ID shows that haven't migrated yet.
- Peacock: Great for the Paranormal Witness episodes and NBC news archives.
- YouTube: Don't sleep on this. Search for "Fox Hollow Farm news archive." You’ll find raw footage from 1996 that hasn't been edited for "entertainment" value. It’s sobering.
- Amazon Prime: Best for renting specific episodes of American Justice or Cold Case Files that deal with Baumeister.
What Most People Get Wrong About Herb Baumeister
When you watch these shows, you'll see a lot of sensationalism. They talk about the "Pool of Death." But if you dig into the actual reports from the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Department, the reality was much more mundane and much more terrifying.
Baumeister wasn't a "supervillain." He was a man who took advantage of the fact that, in the mid-90s, missing persons cases involving gay men weren't always given the priority they deserved. This is a recurring theme in true crime—from Dahmer to Gacy—and Fox Hollow is no different. The documentaries that acknowledge this systemic failure are the ones worth your time.
Also, people think the "bones" were just found in a pile. In reality, they were scattered across the back acres of the property. Thousands of fragments. The task for the coroners wasn't just finding them; it was the painstaking process of DNA sequencing. We are talking about 10,000+ bone fragments.
Actionable Steps for True Crime Enthusiasts
If you’re serious about following this case beyond just a Friday night movie, here is what you should actually do:
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Check the Hamilton County Coroner’s Office official updates. They are still actively asking for DNA samples from families who had loved ones go missing in the Indianapolis area between the 1980s and 1990s. This is a living investigation.
Follow local Indianapolis news outlets. National media only cares when there’s a "spooky" update. Local reporters are the ones doing the actual work of tracking which victims have been identified this year.
Watch the documentaries in chronological order of their production. Start with the 90s news reports, move to the 2000s psychological profiles, and finish with the 2020s forensic updates. It gives you a much better perspective on how our understanding of serial killers has evolved.
The story of Fox Hollow Farm isn't just about a "haunted house." It’s about the names of the men found in the dirt. Whether you watch on Max, Peacock, or YouTube, keep that in mind. The identification process is still happening, and for many families, the story is only just beginning to reach its end.
Next Steps:
- Search for "Fox Hollow Farm" on Max to start with the most recent ID specials.
- Visit the WRTV YouTube channel and search their archives for "Herb Baumeister" to see the original 1996 crime scene footage.
- Look up the Hamilton County Coroner’s Facebook page for the most recent press releases on DNA identifications made in late 2024 and early 2025.