So, you finally decided to see what all the fuss is about with the Bayview Four. It’s that classic Breakfast Club setup but, you know, with a dead body and a lot more blackmail. If you’re hunting for where to watch One of Us Is Lying, the answer is actually pretty straightforward, but there are a few regional quirks that might trip you up depending on where you're sitting right now.
It's a Peacock original. That’s the big takeaway.
If you are in the United States, you're headed to Peacock. Simple as that. The show ran for two seasons before the streamers decided to pull the plug—a move that honestly still stings for a lot of fans who wanted to see the "One of Us Is Back" cliffhanger resolved. But despite the cancellation, both seasons are still living on the platform. If you’ve already got a subscription, you’re golden. If not, you’re looking at their standard monthly tier to get through all 16 episodes.
The Peacock Situation and the Global Shuffle
Peacock is the home base, but what if you’re not in the States? This is where things get a bit more interesting and, frankly, a little more convenient for some. In a huge chunk of the world, including the UK, Canada, Australia, and much of Europe, where to watch One of Us Is Lying is actually Netflix.
It’s one of those weird licensing deals.
Because Peacock doesn’t have the same global footprint as the red "N," they farmed out the international distribution rights. For fans in London or Toronto, this is great news because you probably already have a Netflix login saved on your TV. You get the same polished, high-definition drama, just under a different digital roof. It’s worth noting that even though it’s on Netflix internationally, it is still branded as a Peacock Original in the credits.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why the platform matters for your binge
Choosing where to watch isn't just about finding the play button. It’s about the experience. Peacock’s interface has improved, sure, but Netflix still has that "next episode starts in five seconds" feature that makes losing an entire Saturday to a teen murder mystery way too easy.
If you’re someone who cares about the technical side, both platforms support 4K streaming for this show, assuming you're on the right plan. The cinematography in the second season, especially those outdoor shots around the hidden guest house, looks crisp. It’s a moody show. Lots of shadows. Lots of teenagers looking stressed in dimly lit hallways. You want a decent bitrate for that, otherwise, those dark scenes just turn into a blocky, pixelated mess.
Buying vs. Streaming: Is it Worth Owning?
Maybe you’re a digital hoarder. Or maybe you just hate the idea of a show you love disappearing because some executive decided to save a few bucks on licensing fees. It happens more than we'd like to admit.
You can actually buy the episodes.
Platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV (the iTunes store side of it), and Vudu offer the show for purchase. Usually, it's about $2.99 an episode or $15-$20 for a full season. If you’re worried about Peacock eventually purging their library—a trend that started getting really popular with streaming services in late 2023 and 2024—buying a digital copy is the only way to ensure you’ll always have access to Bronwyn’s overachieving or Nate’s brooding.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Honestly, buying makes sense if you’re a re-watcher. If you’re the type of person who needs to go back and check the background of every scene once you know who the killer is, owning it saves you from the "is it still on this service?" anxiety.
The Tricky Part: What About Season 3?
Here is the cold, hard truth that most "where to watch" guides try to dance around: there is no Season 3.
It’s gone.
Peacock officially canceled the show in early 2023. Showrunner Erica Saleh has talked openly about having plans for where the story was going to go—especially after that blood-stained graduation photo cliffhanger—but as of right now, no other network has picked it up. There was a huge fan campaign, #SaveOneOfUsIsLying, which put up a decent fight on social media, but the streamers didn't budge.
So, when you’re looking for where to watch One of Us Is Lying, understand that you are watching a complete-ish but ultimately unfinished story. You get 16 episodes. That’s it. If you want the "real" ending, or at least the one that doesn't leave you hanging, you’re going to have to pivot back to the source material by Karen M. McManus. The show deviated a lot from the books—especially the ending of the first season—but the books provide a sense of closure the TV show was never allowed to film.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Regional availability at a glance
- USA: Peacock (Exclusive streaming home).
- UK/Ireland: Netflix.
- Canada: Netflix.
- Australia: Netflix / Stan (Availability can fluctuate here, check both).
- Brazil/Latin America: Netflix.
- Purchase options: Amazon, Apple TV, Google Play (Global).
Don't Fall for the "Free" Scams
Look, we've all been there. You search for a show and a dozen sketchy websites pop up promising a free stream. Don't do it. Aside from the obvious malware risks, these sites usually have terrible quality, subtitles that don't match, and enough pop-up ads to melt your browser.
If you really want to watch it for "free" and you're in the US, keep an eye on Peacock's promotional cycles. Sometimes they offer the first episode or two for free to entice new subscribers. Also, if you’re an Xfinity or Cox internet customer, check your plan; some of those older bundles still include Peacock Premium at no extra cost, though those deals have been phasing out lately.
Why this show is still ranking high on watchlists
There’s a reason people are still searching for where to watch One of Us Is Lying years after it premiered. It hit a very specific sweet spot. It took the "prestige" teen drama vibe of Euphoria but kept the fast-paced, "who-done-it" hook of Pretty Little Liars.
The casting was also surprisingly good. Annalisa Cochrane as Addy Prentiss probably had the best character arc of the bunch, moving from the "fallen queen bee" to something much more interesting. Seeing her development is worth the subscription price alone. Plus, the chemistry between the lead actors felt genuine, which is why the cancellation hurt the fanbase so much.
Final verdict on the best way to watch
If you want the most seamless experience, just bite the bullet and get the Peacock (US) or Netflix (International) sub for a month. You can easily knock out both seasons in a weekend. The episodes are roughly 45 to 50 minutes long, and the pacing is brisk enough that you won't feel the "mid-season sag" that plagues a lot of 20-episode network shows.
Once you finish, if you're feeling that void, go grab the book One of Us Is Back. It’s the third book in the trilogy and gives you the resolution that the TV show couldn't.
Next Steps for the Bayview Obsessed:
- Check your region: Open Netflix first if you are outside the US. If you're inside the US, Peacock is your only native streaming option.
- Verify your tier: Ensure you have a "Premium" (not necessarily "Premium Plus") Peacock account, as the free tier rarely includes their original scripted dramas anymore.
- Sync with friends: If you're watching for the first time, use a "Watch Party" extension. This show is built for "I knew it!" moments that are better shared.
- Read the books: Start with One of Us Is Lying, then One of Us Is Next, and finish with One of Us Is Back to fill in the narrative gaps left by the show's cancellation.