If you’ve been scrolling through social media lately, you’ve probably seen a lot of buzz about a quirky little show involving a Christmas-themed shop and, well, dead bodies. It’s called Mistletoe Murders. People are obsessed. It captures that specific vibe of wanting to be cozy under a blanket while also trying to figure out who the killer is before the protagonist does. But figuring out exactly where to watch Mistletoe Murders has been a bit of a puzzle for some, mostly because streaming rights are getting more fragmented than ever.
Honestly, the show is a breath of fresh air. It stars Sarah Drew—who many of us still associate with the chaotic energy of Grey's Anatomy—as Emily Lane. She runs a shop called "Under the Mistletoe." Sounds adorable, right? It is, until you realize Emily has a secret past and a weirdly sharp instinct for investigating local homicides. It's based on the popular Audible series by Ken Cuperus, which already had a massive following before it ever hit the screen. If you're a fan of Only Murders in the Building or the Aurora Teagarden mysteries, this is right up your alley.
The Short Answer on Where to Watch Mistletoe Murders
So, let's get right to it. If you are in the United States or Canada, the primary home for the show is Hallmark+.
Wait, Hallmark+? Yeah, it's the rebranded version of Hallmark Movies Now. They launched this updated streaming service in late 2024 to house their more "prestige" or episodic content that doesn't always fit the 24/7 loop of the linear cable channel. Mistletoe Murders is one of their flagship scripted series for the holiday season. You can’t just find this one on Netflix or Hulu. It’s a specialized play for the Hallmark crowd.
- For US Viewers: You need a Hallmark+ subscription. You can get it as a standalone app or as a "channel" add-on through platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, or Roku.
- For Canadian Viewers: It usually airs on the W Network or streams on STACKTV, given Hallmark’s long-standing partnership with Corus Entertainment.
- International Markets: This is where it gets tricky. In the UK and Australia, distribution often lags. Keep an eye on services like Acorn TV or certain localized Amazon channels that specialize in cozy mysteries.
The show isn't just a movie. It’s a series. That matters because the rollout is episodic. You can't just binge the whole thing in one sitting the second it drops; they want you to savor the mystery.
Why Everyone is Talking About Emily Lane
Emily Lane isn't your typical Hallmark heroine. Usually, these characters are just trying to save a bakery or find a boyfriend before the Christmas Eve gala. Emily is different. She's smart. She’s guarded. She’s definitely hiding something that happened before she moved to the sleepy town of Fletcher’s Grove.
📖 Related: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
The show works because it balances the "warm and fuzzy" aesthetic with actual stakes. Sarah Drew brings a groundedness to the role. She’s joined by Peter Mooney, who plays local detective Sam Wilner. Their chemistry is the engine of the show. It’s that classic "civilian consultant vs. skeptical cop" trope, but it’s done with enough charm that you don't mind seeing it again.
What’s interesting about Mistletoe Murders is its origin. Because it started as an Audible Original, the storytelling is very tight. Audio dramas rely on dialogue and pacing to keep listeners from hitting the "stop" button. When you translate that to TV, you get a script that doesn't waste much time. Every decoration in Emily's shop feels like it could be a clue. Every side character feels like a suspect.
Technical Details and Streaming Costs
If you're looking at your budget and wondering if another streaming service is worth it, here is the breakdown for Hallmark+. As of early 2026, the service typically runs around $7.99 a month, or you can grab an annual pass for roughly $79.99.
Is it worth it just for one show?
Maybe. But they also have The Chicken Sisters and Holliston Stars, along with a massive library of those "comfort food" movies we all pretend not to watch but actually love. If you’re a mystery buff, the investment makes more sense than if you’re just a casual viewer.
👉 See also: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
If you aren't ready to commit, look for the free trial. Most people sign up for the 7-day trial through Amazon Prime Video Channels, binge the available episodes of Mistletoe Murders, and then decide if they want to stick around. Just remember to cancel before the week is up if you're only there for the crime-solving.
Common Misconceptions About the Show
A lot of people think this is a "movie of the week." It's not. It's a six-episode arc.
Another big mistake people make is searching for it on the standard Hallmark Channel cable app. While Hallmark+ and the cable channel are cousins, they aren't the same. Exclusive "Plus" content stays on the streaming side for quite a while before it ever trickles down to traditional TV. If you’re waiting for it to pop up on your DVR while recording the 24-hour Christmas movie marathon, you might be waiting a long time.
How to Get the Best Viewing Experience
If you’re going to dive into Fletcher’s Grove, do it right. This isn't a show to watch while you're folding laundry or staring at your phone. The clues are often visual.
- Watch in 4K if possible: Hallmark+ has stepped up their production value. The colors in the "Under the Mistletoe" shop are vibrant and really pop in high definition.
- Listen to the Audio Series First (or After): If you find yourself wanting more, go back to the Audible version. It features the same lead voice (Sarah Drew) and gives a bit more internal monologue that you don't always get on screen.
- Check the Episode Count: Make sure you are starting from episode one. Because the titles are all holiday-themed, it’s easy to get them mixed up if your streaming interface is clunky.
The Future of the Mistletoe Murders Franchise
Given the success of the first season, there’s already chatter about where this goes next. Cozy mysteries thrive on longevity. Think about Murder, She Wrote or Midsomer Murders. There is no reason Emily Lane can't be solving crimes in Fletcher’s Grove for years to come.
✨ Don't miss: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
The fan base is incredibly vocal. On platforms like X and Reddit, "Mistletoe Maniacs" (yes, that’s a thing) are already dissecting the finale and looking for hints about a second season. The show has managed to bridge the gap between the traditional Hallmark audience and the "True Crime" crowd, which is a massive win for the network.
Final Steps for the Mystery Fan
Now that you know exactly where to watch Mistletoe Murders, it's time to actually get into it. Don't wait until the spoilers hit your TikTok feed.
First, check if you already have a subscription to a service that offers "Channels"—Amazon is the easiest path here. Search for Hallmark+ within that interface. If you see the "Start Your Free Trial" button, you’re golden.
Second, if you're outside the US or Canada, consider using a high-quality VPN to access your home subscriptions while traveling, or check local listings for "Global" or "Acorn" TV acquisitions.
Finally, if you find yourself hooked, go back and listen to the original Audible production. It provides a different perspective on Emily's backstory that helps fill in the gaps between episodes. You'll realize that the "cozy" part is just a mask for a much deeper, more complex thriller.
Get your cocoa ready. Fletcher’s Grove is waiting, and there’s a killer on the loose.