You’re probably thinking about Seven Mile Beach. Most people do. It’s that iconic, crescent-shaped stretch of sand on Grand Cayman that ends up on every postcard and Instagram feed. But honestly, if you just book a room at the first big resort you see, you might miss the actual point of these three islands.
Deciding where to stay in the Cayman Islands isn't just about picking a bed; it’s about choosing a personality. Grand Cayman is the flashy, cosmopolitan sibling. Cayman Brac is the rugged, outdoorsy middle child. Little Cayman? Well, that’s the tiny, quiet one where the iguanas outnumber the humans.
I’ve seen plenty of travelers land in George Town and realize they actually wanted the solitude of the East End, or worse, they head to Little Cayman and find out they’re "too bored" without a shopping mall. Let’s break down the geography so you don't end up in the wrong spot.
The Seven Mile Beach Reality Check
Everyone calls it Seven Mile Beach, but it’s actually closer to 5.5 miles. It’s the heart of the action. If you want to walk out of your lobby and immediately sink your toes into white powder, this is it.
The Kimpton Seafire Resort + Spa has basically rewritten the luxury playbook here. It’s modern, it’s got those floor-to-ceiling windows, and the service feels less "stiff" than your traditional high-end hotels. Then you have the Ritz-Carlton, Grand Cayman, which is the grand dame of the strip. It’s where you go for the Afternoon Tea and the Seven South suite—which is currently the largest luxury suite in the Caribbean.
If you're looking for something that feels more like a curated home and less like a corporate hotel, Palm Heights is the one. It’s got this incredible 70s-glam-meets-island-cool vibe that’s made it a magnet for the fashion crowd lately. The yellow striped umbrellas are unmistakable.
- Pros: Best sand, dozens of restaurants within walking distance, endless watersports.
- Cons: It’s expensive. Like, "don't look at the bill until you get home" expensive.
- Vibe: Sophisticated, bustling, and very polished.
Getting Away from the Crowds: The East End and North Side
Drive about 45 minutes east from the airport and the high-rises disappear. This is the "real" Grand Cayman. You’ll pass blowholes where the ocean sprays 20 feet into the air and tiny fish shacks where they serve conch fritters on paper plates.
📖 Related: How to track flights without losing your mind at the airport
Staying at Wyndham Reef Resort or Morritt’s Tortuga Club feels like a different country compared to Seven Mile Beach. Everything slows down. You’ll need a rental car here—don't even try to rely on taxis unless you want to spend your life savings on fares.
Then there’s Rum Point and Cayman Kai. This is villa territory. If you’re traveling with a big family, you rent a private house like those managed by Grand Cayman Villas & Condos. You get your own pool, a private dock, and you're ten minutes away from the Bioluminescent Bay. It’s basically the suburban dream version of the Caribbean.
A Quick Sidebar on West Bay
Just north of Seven Mile Beach is West Bay. It’s a mix of residential grit and hidden gems. VIDA Cayman is a newer boutique spot here that focuses on wellness and adventure—perfect if you want to be near the Kittiwake shipwreck for diving but don't want the Seven Mile crowds.
The "Sister Islands": Brac and Little
You haven't really experienced the archipelago until you hop on a Twin Otter plane to the smaller islands.
Cayman Brac is dominated by "The Bluff," a massive limestone cliff that rises out of the sea. It’s a rock climber’s paradise. Stay at the Cayman Brac Beach Resort if you’re a diver. The diving here is world-class, especially the MV Captain Keith Tibbetts, a sunken Russian destroyer you can actually swim through.
Little Cayman is the soul of the islands. It’s ten miles long and has a population of about 150 people. The Southern Cross Club is the place to stay—it’s a collection of colorful beachfront bungalows where everyone eats together at a big long table. It’s intimate. You’ll spend your days at Bloody Bay Wall, a vertical coral drop-off that starts in 15 feet of water and plunges to over 6,000 feet. It’s dizzying in the best way possible.
What Most People Miss About the Budget
"Affordable" is a relative term in Cayman. You won't find $50-a-night hostels here. However, you can find value if you look away from the shoreline.
Sunshine Suites Resort is a classic "hack." It’s located just across the street from the beach, tucked behind the Westin. You pay significantly less than the oceanfront properties but you get full access to the Westin Grand Cayman's beach facilities and pools. It’s the best way to get a luxury experience on a mid-range budget.
The Locale Hotel is another solid choice for the business-minded or younger traveler. It’s sleek, situated on the Seven Mile corridor, and has a great craft pizza spot downstairs. It feels more like a Brooklyn boutique hotel that happened to land in the tropics.
The Verdict on Where to Stay
If you want the glitz, the spas, and the fine dining (like Blue by Eric Ripert), stay on Seven Mile Beach.
If you want to spend your mornings snorkeling with sea turtles and your afternoons reading in a hammock with zero noise, head to the East End.
If you are a hardcore diver or just want to disappear from the grid entirely, book a flight to Little Cayman.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check the Cruise Schedule: If you’re staying near George Town or Seven Mile Beach, check the cruise ship arrivals. On days with five ships in port, the beaches get packed. Plan your excursions to the East End on those "heavy" ship days.
- Rent a Car Early: Especially if you're staying outside the main tourist hub. The supply is limited and prices spike during the winter high season.
- Pack a Mask: Even if you aren't a "diver," the shore snorkeling at spots like Cemetery Beach or Smith Barcadere is free and better than most paid tours in other countries.
- Book the Bio-Bay: If you stay on the North Side, book a kayaking tour for the Bioluminescent Bay during a "New Moon" for the best visibility.