Timing is everything in Hollywood. In 2011, the "casual hookup" trope was suddenly everywhere. Two major movies with nearly identical plots—No Strings Attached and Friends with Benefits—hit theaters within months of each other. Amidst that cultural obsession, NBC tried to capture the magic on the small screen. The Friends with Benefits TV cast was tasked with bringing that same "it's complicated" energy to a weekly format, but the show struggled to find its footing before it even aired.
Honestly? Most people forgot this show existed.
It was a "burn-off" series. That's industry speak for a show a network doesn't believe in, so they air it during the summer when nobody is watching just to fulfill contracts. But looking back at the ensemble today, it’s actually wild how much talent was packed into that single season. We’re talking about actors who went on to lead massive sitcoms, star in DC superhero movies, and dominate the voice-acting world.
The Core Chemistry of the Friends with Benefits TV Cast
The show centered on a group of friends in Chicago navigating the blurred lines of modern dating. At the heart of it were Ben and Sara.
Ryan Hansen played Ben Lewis. If you recognize Ryan, it’s probably because he’s the king of playing the "lovable douchebag." Before this, he was Dick Casablancas on Veronica Mars, a role so iconic he eventually got his own meta-spin-off. In Friends with Benefits, he played a guy looking for the perfect woman while settling for a "no-strings" arrangement with his best friend. Hansen has a very specific type of kinetic energy. He’s tall, blonde, and has this smirk that makes you want to roll your eyes and grab a beer with him at the same time. Since the show ended, he’s stayed incredibly busy with projects like Party Down and Bachelorette.
Then there was Danneel Ackles (credited then as Danneel Harris) as Sara Maxwell.
Sara was the pragmatic doctor looking for "The One" while constantly falling back into bed with Ben. Danneel was already a fan favorite from her time on One Tree Hill as Rachel Gatina. She brought a grounded, slightly cynical edge to the show that balanced out the goofier elements. While she’s stepped back from acting a bit to focus on family—she’s married to Supernatural star Jensen Ackles—she remains a huge figure in the "CW-verse" fandom and recently appeared in The Winchesters.
The Supporting Players Who Stole the Show
You can’t talk about this cast without mentioning Zach Cregger. He played Aaron, the hopeless romantic of the group. Cregger came from the legendary sketch comedy troupe The Whitest Kids U' Know. Watching him play a "normal" sitcom lead was always a bit jarring if you knew his darker comedy roots.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Fast forward to today, and Zach Cregger is one of the most exciting names in horror.
He wrote and directed the 2022 smash hit Barbarian. It’s a massive pivot. Going from a generic NBC sitcom to creating one of the most talked-about horror films of the decade is the kind of career trajectory you just can't predict.
André Holland was also in the mix as Julian "Fitz" Fitzgerald. Holland is, quite frankly, an acting powerhouse. It’s almost strange seeing him in a lighthearted sitcom when you consider his later work in Moonlight, The Knick, and Castle Rock. He provided the "cool" factor for the group, playing the successful friend who seemingly had it all figured out.
Rounding out the main quintet was Jessica Lucas as Riley Thomas. Riley was the bartender, the friend who often acted as the voice of reason (or chaos, depending on the episode). Lucas has had a remarkably steady career, starring in the Evil Dead remake and holding down a long-running role on Gotham as Tabitha Galavan.
Why the Show Didn't Become the Next Friends
NBC really wanted this to be their next big ensemble hit. They needed something to fill the void left by their aging comedy blocks. But Friends with Benefits faced an uphill battle from day one.
First, there was the title. It felt dated the second it was announced. Because it shared a name with the Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis movie, audiences were confused. Was it a spin-off? A remake? A cheap knock-off?
The writing also struggled to find a unique voice. In the pilot, the dialogue tried very hard to be "edgy" for network TV. It wanted to be Sex and the City but felt more like a filtered version of a cable show. The Friends with Benefits TV cast had great chemistry, but they were often hamstrung by scripts that relied on tired tropes about "men being from Mars and women being from Venus."
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
- The show sat on the shelf for a year.
- It was originally slated for midseason, then pushed to summer.
- NBC aired episodes out of order, which killed any character development.
- The pilot episode that actually aired wasn't even the original pilot filmed.
It's hard for a cast to find a rhythm when the network is constantly shuffling the deck.
A Strange Production History
Interestingly, the show was co-created by Scott Neustadter and Michael H. Weber. These are the guys who wrote (500) Days of Summer and The Disaster Artist. They are incredibly talented writers who understand the nuances of relationships. On paper, this should have been a masterpiece of romantic comedy.
So, what happened?
Network interference is the likely culprit. When you take writers who excel at subverting tropes and force them into a 22-minute multi-cam or single-cam hybrid structure, the soul often gets sucked out of the project. The cast felt like they were in a different show than the one the producers were trying to sell.
The Legacy of the Cast Members
Even though the series only lasted 13 episodes, the actors didn't miss a beat. If you look at where they are now, the Friends with Benefits TV cast might be one of the most successful "failed" casts in history.
Ryan Hansen became a cult comedy icon.
Danneel Ackles became a powerhouse producer and entrepreneur with Family Business Beer Co.
Zach Cregger is a top-tier Hollywood director.
André Holland is an Academy Award-level dramatic actor.
Jessica Lucas is a staple of genre television.
It’s a testament to the casting directors that they were able to identify this much raw talent before most of these actors became household names. If the show were made today for a streaming service like Netflix or Hulu, it probably would have been a massive hit. The "friends with benefits" concept works much better when you don't have to worry about FCC broadcast standards.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Does It Hold Up?
If you go back and watch the episodes now—they’re occasionally available on various streaming platforms or for purchase—it feels like a time capsule of 2011. The fashion, the flip phones, the specific brand of "hipster" culture in Chicago.
It’s not a bad show. It’s just a "fine" show.
The humor is safe. The stakes are low. But the charisma of the performers makes it watchable. You can see the flashes of brilliance in André Holland’s delivery or Ryan Hansen’s physical comedy.
What We Can Learn From the Show's Failure
The biggest takeaway from the Friends with Benefits saga is that a great cast cannot save a project that lacks a clear identity. You can put five of the most talented young actors in a room, but if the network doesn't know how to market them, the show is dead on arrival.
For fans of these actors, the show is a fun "deep cut" in their filmography. It’s the project that paved the way for better things.
If you are looking to revisit the work of this specific ensemble, don't just stop at this sitcom. Check out their later work where they were actually given the freedom to shine.
Next Steps for TV History Buffs:
- Watch Party Down (Starz): If you want to see Ryan Hansen at his absolute best, this is the show. It’s a masterclass in ensemble comedy.
- Check out Barbarian (HBO Max/Digital): See how Zach Cregger traded sitcom jokes for genuine cinematic terror. It is a wild ride.
- Explore André Holland's Dramatic Work: Watch The Knick. It’s a period piece about medicine in the early 1900s, and Holland's performance is transcendent.
- Track Down the "Lost" Episodes: If you're a completist, try to find the international versions of Friends with Benefits. Sometimes the edit is slightly different and gives a better sense of what the creators originally intended before the NBC scissors got to it.
The show might be a footnote in TV history, but the people who made it are currently shaping the future of the industry. That’s the real story.