He was a high-flying GE Energy executive. A man with a six-figure salary, a family, and a respectable life in the suburbs of Atlanta. Then, on a chilly November morning in 2010, Hemy Neuman pulled a trigger outside a Dunwoody daycare center and changed everything. He killed Rusty Sneiderman in broad daylight, a crime that launched a decade of legal drama, salacious headlines, and enough twists to fill a prestige TV series.
But the headlines eventually faded. The cameras moved on to the next tragedy. For those who remember the shocking details of the case, one question usually sticks: Where is Hemy Neuman now?
Honestly, the answer isn't a secret, but it is a stark contrast to the life he once lived. As of 2026, Hemy Neuman is still very much behind bars. He's residing at the Augusta State Medical Prison in Georgia. This isn't your standard penitentiary. It's the primary facility for Georgia inmates who require long-term medical or mental health care. For Neuman, who spent years trying to convince juries and judges that he was legally insane at the time of the murder, this location is fittingly ironic.
The long road to Augusta
You might remember that Neuman's path to a permanent cell wasn't a straight line. It was a mess.
His first trial in 2012 was a circus. The defense argued he was "not guilty by reason of insanity," claiming he saw visions of angels and demons—one of which supposedly looked like Barry White—ordering him to kill Sneiderman. The jury didn't buy the "not guilty" part, but they did find him guilty but mentally ill. That verdict usually means you go to prison, but you're supposed to get psychiatric treatment while you're there.
🔗 Read more: Elecciones en Honduras 2025: ¿Quién va ganando realmente según los últimos datos?
Then things got weird.
In 2015, the Georgia Supreme Court actually overturned his conviction. Why? Because of a technicality involving attorney-client privilege. The prosecution had been allowed to see notes from mental health experts that should have been off-limits. For a brief moment, it looked like Neuman might have a shot at a different outcome.
He didn't.
The 2016 retrial was even more brutal for him. This time, the jury didn't include the "mentally ill" tag. They just found him straight-up guilty of malice murder. The judge sentenced him to life without the possibility of parole. No exits. No second chances. Basically, he was told he'd die in prison.
💡 You might also like: Trump Approval Rating State Map: Why the Red-Blue Divide is Moving
Life inside the medical prison
Augusta State Medical Prison is a unique spot in the Georgia Department of Corrections system. It’s located in Grovetown, near Augusta. It houses about 1,300 inmates. Because it's a medical facility, it has a more clinical feel than the high-security blocks at Reidsville or Jackson.
Neuman has been there for years now. People who have tracked his time inside note that he’s aged significantly. The sharp-suited executive is gone. In his place is an older man, often seen in court appearances with a long, grey beard and a yarmulke.
His legal team hasn't been quiet, though. As recently as 2021, Neuman was still fighting. He tried to argue that the second jury shouldn't have been allowed to find him "guilty" without the "mentally ill" qualifier, since the first jury had already established he had mental issues. The Georgia Supreme Court basically told him "no." They upheld the conviction, and that was pretty much the end of the line for his direct appeals.
What most people get wrong about the case
When people ask about where he is, they usually start debating the motive again. Was it really the visions? Or was it just a cold, calculated plan to be with Rusty's wife, Andrea Sneiderman?
📖 Related: Ukraine War Map May 2025: Why the Frontlines Aren't Moving Like You Think
The prosecution’s theory was simple: Neuman was obsessed. He was having an affair with Andrea (which she has always denied, though she served time for perjury and hindering the investigation). They argued he killed Rusty to clear the path.
The insanity defense was, in their eyes, a performance. A way to avoid the harshest penalties. Whether you believe the "Barry White angel" story or not, the law has made its final call. Neuman is a convicted murderer who will never see the outside of a fence again.
What's next for Hemy Neuman?
There aren't many "next steps" for a man serving life without parole.
- Medical Monitoring: Given his age and the fact that he's in a medical prison, his day-to-day life is mostly about managing health.
- Habeas Corpus: While his direct appeals are exhausted, inmates in his position often file "habeas corpus" petitions—civil lawsuits claiming their imprisonment is illegal due to constitutional violations. These are rarely successful but keep the case files active.
- The Finality of the Sentence: For the Sneiderman family, the fact that Neuman is tucked away in Augusta provides a grim sort of closure.
If you're following this case because you're interested in the intersection of mental health and the law, it's worth looking into how Georgia's "guilty but mentally ill" status actually works in practice. Often, it doesn't change the prison experience as much as people think. It certainly didn't save Hemy Neuman from a life behind bars.
He’s exactly where the court said he would be: in a cell, far away from the life he destroyed.
Actionable Insight: If you're researching this case for legal or true crime purposes, the most definitive record is the 2021 Georgia Supreme Court opinion (Neuman v. State). It provides the most recent and final legal standing on his conviction and explains why his attempts to overturn the second trial failed. Reading the actual court transcripts gives a much clearer picture of the evidence than the sensationalized news reports from the time of the shooting.