The lights at Acrisure Stadium didn't just go down on the Pittsburgh Steelers’ season this past Monday; they might have dimmed on one of the most polarizing careers in NFL history. Watching Aaron Rodgers walk off the field after that 30-6 thumping by the Houston Texans felt heavy. A pick-six to end the game? It’s the kind of scripted irony that football gods love, especially considering how his Green Bay tenure ended with a similar thud. Now, the question of where is Aaron Rodgers going is essentially the only thing anyone in Western Pennsylvania—or the NFL at large—is talking about.
Honestly, the situation is a mess. Just a week ago, there was this sense of "run it back" optimism. Rodgers had a decent year, all things considered. He threw for 3,322 yards and 24 touchdowns. For a 42-year-old coming off a nightmare stint with the Jets, that’s actually impressive. But then Tuesday happened. Mike Tomlin, the man Rodgers literally came to Pittsburgh to play for, stepped down.
Without Tomlin, the map for Rodgers' future looks a lot more like a blank sheet of paper.
The Pittsburgh Problem: Is the Door Actually Closed?
Before the playoff loss, NFL Network's Ian Rapoport was reporting that the Steelers were "more than open" to bringing Rodgers back for the 2026 season. They won the AFC North. They had a winning record (10-7). On paper, it worked. But the dynamic has shifted violently in the last 72 hours.
Rodgers is currently a free agent. He signed a one-year, $13.65 million deal last June after the Jets basically showed him the door. Because he’s not under contract, he doesn't need a trade to move. He just needs a pen and a team willing to ignore his age.
💡 You might also like: Anthony Davis USC Running Back: Why the Notre Dame Killer Still Matters
The Steelers have 12 draft picks this year. They are hosting the draft in Pittsburgh. There’s a very loud contingency of the fanbase that thinks it’s time to stop the "Band-Aid" approach at quarterback and actually draft a kid like Dante Moore or Ty Simpson. If the new head coach—whoever that ends up being—wants a fresh start, Rodgers isn't the guy. He’s the opposite of a fresh start. He’s a beautiful, expensive antique that requires a very specific shelf.
The Retirement Factor
"I'm not going to make any emotional decisions," Rodgers told reporters in the locker room after the Texans game. He looked tired.
Back in July, he was "pretty sure" 2025 would be his last dance. But Rodgers has always been a "mercurial talent," as some scouts put it. He likes to wait. He likes the darkness retreats—metaphorical or otherwise. The odds of him retiring are currently sitting around 77% on prediction markets like Kalshi, especially now that his "Tomlin connection" is gone.
If he walks away, he finishes fourth in NFL history in passing touchdowns. That’s a hell of a legacy. But if he still has that itch, there are really only two places he could feasibly land.
📖 Related: AC Milan vs Bologna: Why This Matchup Always Ruins the Script
Where Is Aaron Rodgers Going Next? (The Short List)
If he doesn't retire, and if Pittsburgh decides to move on to a rookie, where does a 42-year-old quarterback with a 94.8 passer rating go?
- The Minnesota Vikings: This is the one that makes people in Wisconsin throw their beer. Michael Rand of the Star Tribune recently made a case for it. The Vikings have J.J. McCarthy, but if they think he needs another year of "refinement," Rodgers is the ultimate bridge. It’s the Brett Favre path. It’s petty. It’s exactly the kind of thing that might appeal to Rodgers’ sense of narrative.
- The Pittsburgh Steelers (The LaFleur Scenario): There is a wild theory floating around—Mike Florio mentioned it—that if the Steelers want to keep Rodgers, they could trade for Packers coach Matt LaFleur. It sounds like fan fiction, but LaFleur only has one year left on his deal in Green Bay. If that happened, Rodgers would stay in a heartbeat.
- The "One Last Run" Contender: Occasionally, a team like the Dolphins or even a desperate contender with a sudden injury opening looks at a veteran. But let's be real: Rodgers isn't a "plug and play" guy anymore. He wants input on the scheme. He wants his friends (like Davante Adams, wherever he lands) on the roster.
Why the Jets Experience Still Looms Large
You can't talk about where he's going without mentioning where he's been. His exit from New York was ugly. He basically skipped the Jets in his post-game "thank yous" this week, only mentioning Green Bay and Pittsburgh as "special places."
The Jets have moved on to Justin Fields and Brady Cook, and they aren't looking back. But the "turmoil" of those two years in New Jersey clearly weighed on him. His success in Pittsburgh proved he wasn't "washed," but it didn't prove he's still a Super Bowl-caliber ceiling raiser. He’s a high-floor, mid-ceiling veteran at this stage.
What to Watch for in the Coming Weeks
If you're tracking this, don't expect an answer tomorrow. Rodgers is famous for taking his time. Here is the timeline we are actually looking at:
👉 See also: 49ers vs Chargers Super Bowl: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Steelers Coaching Search: If Pittsburgh hires a "Rodgers-friendly" OC or a head coach with ties to him, the odds of him staying skyrocket.
- The Legal Tampering Period (March): This is when we’ll see if teams like the Vikings or Raiders actually make a phone call.
- The Draft (April): If the Steelers use their first-round pick on a QB, Rodgers is gone. Period.
Basically, it's a waiting game. Rodgers has earned the right to deliberate, but the NFL moves fast. Teams won't wait forever while he decides if he wants to play for a 22nd season or go host a podcast full-time.
For now, the most likely outcome is a quiet exit. But with Aaron Rodgers, "quiet" is rarely the word people use. Whether it's one more year in the black and gold or a shocking purple jersey in Minnesota, the next move will be entirely on his terms.
If you're betting on his next move, keep a close eye on the Steelers' head coaching search over the next 14 days; that hire will dictate whether Rodgers stays in Pittsburgh or officially starts looking at NFC North jerseys.