You've probably heard it a thousand times. It’s the kind of question a grandfather asks a kid to make their brain itch, or the icebreaker a bored teacher throws out on a Monday morning. Where does today come before yesterday? The answer isn't tucked away in some high-tech laboratory or a rift in the space-time continuum. It’s sitting on your bookshelf. Or, more likely these days, it’s a dusty app on your phone that you only open when you’re arguing over how to spell "bureaucracy."
The dictionary.
📖 Related: What Time Do Applebee's Close: The Late-Night Reality
In the English language, "T" comes before "Y." That’s the whole trick. It’s a linguistic quirk, a play on alphabetical order that exploits how our brains prioritize temporal logic over literal spelling. We think in sequences of time—morning, noon, night—so our instincts reject the idea of today preceding yesterday. But the alphabet doesn't care about your schedule.
The Linguistic Logic of the Alphabet
Alphabetical order is a rigid, unforgiving system. It doesn't matter that yesterday represents the past and today represents the present. When you flip through a standard Merriam-Webster or Oxford English Dictionary, you’re navigating by characters, not by the flow of time.
Think about it.
The letter "T" is the 20th letter of the alphabet. "Y" is the 25th. Because "T" shows up significantly earlier in the sequence, any word starting with "T" will always appear before a word starting with "Y," provided the dictionary is sorted conventionally.
It’s almost funny how much this messes with us. We are so hard-wired to perceive time as a linear progression that seeing the words out of their "natural" order feels like a glitch. But a dictionary isn't a timeline. It’s a database. In a database, metadata (the letters) trumps the definition (the concept).
Why Our Brains Struggle With This Riddle
There’s a reason this specific riddle works so well. It’s a classic example of a "lateral thinking" puzzle. According to researchers like Edward de Bono, who coined the term, lateral thinking is about moving sideways across patterns rather than following them straight to the end.
💡 You might also like: The Symbol of Zodiac Sign Cancer: Why Those Sideways 69s Actually Make Sense
When someone asks you "where does today come before yesterday," your brain immediately goes to:
- Time travel?
- The International Date Line?
- A dream?
- A broken watch?
We look for complex, physical explanations because we assume the question is about the experience of time. We rarely stop to look at the words as mere strings of text. This is why kids often solve this faster than adults. They’re still learning the mechanics of language and are more likely to notice the physical properties of the words themselves rather than just the abstract concepts they represent.
Beyond the Dictionary: The International Date Line Exception
Now, if we want to get pedantic—and honestly, who doesn't love a bit of pedantry?—there is a geographical answer to this as well. While the dictionary is the "correct" answer to the riddle, the International Date Line (IDL) provides a real-world scenario where "today" and "yesterday" coexist in a way that feels backwards.
Imagine you are standing in Samoa and looking across the water toward American Samoa. Because the IDL runs right between them, they are in different calendar days despite being physically close.
If it is Monday in Samoa (Today), it is still Sunday in American Samoa (Yesterday).
If you were to fly from Samoa to American Samoa, you would effectively be traveling from "Today" back into "Yesterday." You’d land before you departed, at least on paper. It’s the closest thing we have to a time machine. This isn't just a fun fact; it has massive implications for logistics, shipping, and even the way people celebrate New Year’s Eve. Some people literally fly across the line to celebrate the stroke of midnight twice.
The Philosophy of Time vs. The Structure of Language
Language is a tool, but it's also a trap. We use words to categorize the world, but the words themselves have their own rules. This riddle highlights the disconnect between the signifier (the word "today") and the signified (the actual 24-hour period we are currently in).
Ferdinand de Saussure, a heavy hitter in the world of linguistics, talked about this a lot. He argued that the relationship between a word and its meaning is arbitrary. There is nothing inherently "present-like" about the sound of the word "today." It’s just a label.
Because the label is arbitrary, it follows the rules of labels (the alphabet) rather than the rules of reality (physics).
Other Places Where the Order Flips
The dictionary isn't the only spot. Any indexed system will give you the same result.
🔗 Read more: Why After Shave Lotion Men Use Is Still The Best Part Of Shaving
- Phone Contacts: If you have a friend named "Today" and a friend named "Yesterday," Today is getting called first every time.
- Glossaries in History Books: You could be reading a book about the French Revolution. In the back, under the index, the "Terror (Reign of)" comes before "Yorktown (Battle of)." One happened in 1793, the other in 1781. The index doesn't care about the chronology of the war; it only cares about the letters.
- Library Catalogues: Whether it's the old-school Dewey Decimal card catalogs or modern digital databases, the sorting algorithm is the king.
The Psychological Hook: Why Riddles Like This Persist
We love these puzzles because they offer a "Eureka!" moment. That sudden shift in perspective provides a tiny hit of dopamine. It’s the same reason Wordle or Crossword puzzles are addictive.
When you finally realize the answer is "the dictionary," you feel a mix of satisfaction and mild annoyance at how simple it was. You were looking for a mountain and found a pebble.
Expert puzzle creators often use "semantic priming" to trick you. By using words like "today" and "yesterday," they prime your brain to think about clocks, calendars, and schedules. They lead you down a path where the only logical conclusion involves time. Then, they yank the rug out by revealing the answer is actually about orthography (spelling).
Real-World Practicality: Why This Matters
While it seems like a trivial riddle, understanding where "today" comes before "yesterday" helps us understand how information is organized.
In the digital age, we rely on algorithms to sort our lives. Your email inbox usually sorts by "Newest First," which is a chronological sort. But if you click the "Subject" tab, suddenly your emails from today might be buried under emails from three years ago that happen to start with the letter "A."
Understanding the "Dictionary Rule" is basically understanding how to toggle between different ways of perceiving data. It’s a reminder that the way we see information depends entirely on the filter we apply to it.
Actionable Takeaways for the Curious Mind
If you want to use this logic to sharpen your own thinking or just win your next trivia night, keep these points in mind:
- Question the Context: When faced with a paradox, ask if the problem is with the thing or the label for the thing. Most riddles live in the label.
- Check the Index: In any professional setting—be it law, medicine, or engineering—the index is your map. Remember that indices follow alphabetical logic, which often conflicts with the procedural logic of the actual work.
- Embrace the IDL: If you’re ever traveling near the 180° meridian, check your watch and your calendar. It is the only place on Earth where the riddle's logic takes on a physical, geographical form.
- Teach the Logic: Use this riddle to explain the concept of "metadata" to kids or students. "Today" and "Yesterday" are the data; the letters T and Y are the metadata.
The next time someone asks you where today comes before yesterday, don't look at the sun or your watch. Just think about the alphabet. It's the only place where time is forced to wait its turn behind the letter T.
To truly master this kind of lateral thinking, start looking for other "time" words that the alphabet has "misplaced." You'll find that "Future" comes before "History," and "Birth" comes before "Age." Language is chaotic, but at least the dictionary keeps it in line.