If you’re looking for Jay Cutler, you’ve gotta specify which one. Honestly, it’s the classic name confusion. One is an NFL gunslinger who basically redefined the "I don't care" vibe in Chicago, and the other is a four-time Mr. Olympia with quads larger than most people’s torsos.
Where they live is just as different as their career paths. While one is deeply rooted in the neon glow of the desert, the other has been navigating a very public, very expensive real estate shuffle in the rolling hills of Tennessee.
The Bodybuilder: Jay Cutler’s Las Vegas Stronghold
The "Quadrasaurus" himself, Mr. Olympia Jay Cutler, has been a Las Vegas fixture for decades. He didn't just move there for the weather; he basically built an empire out of a suitcase in the desert.
Basically, he lives in a massive, custom-built mansion in Summerlin, an upscale area on the western edge of Las Vegas.
It’s not just a house. It’s a base of operations. You’ve probably seen the videos of his kitchen—it's geared toward professional-grade meal prep. He often films content at local spots like Powerhouse Gym or grabs sushi at his favorite late-night spots. He’s often spotted at the South Point Casino, especially during his annual Jay Cutler Desert Classic, which is still a massive draw on the 2026 fitness calendar.
For him, Vegas isn't about the Strip. It's about the proximity to high-end gyms and the business climate that supports his supplement line, Cutler Nutrition. He’s mentioned in various "Day in the Life" videos that the heat helps with the joints when you’re carrying that much muscle. Fair enough.
💡 You might also like: Why Everyone Wants to See a Picture of Robert Redford Right Now
The Quarterback: Nashville, Franklin, and the Farm Life
Now, for the other Jay. The former Chicago Bears quarterback. His living situation has been... complicated.
For a long time, Jay and his ex-wife Kristin Cavallari were the king and queen of Nashville real estate. They had the massive "Highbrow Hill" estate in Leipers Fork, just outside of Franklin, Tennessee. We're talking 45 acres, a 10,000-square-foot farmhouse, and enough room for a small army.
👉 See also: Selena Gomez and Eminem Songs: Why Everyone Thinks They Collaborated
But things changed. Fast.
- The Big Sale: In August 2024, Jay finally offloaded that Franklin mansion for $7.9 million. It was a bit of a hit considering he’d originally listed it for way more, but he walked away with an all-cash deal.
- The Condo Audible: He briefly tried the high-rise life. He bought a luxe condo on the 36th floor of the Four Seasons in downtown Nashville for $4.32 million. He didn't stay long. He listed it less than a year later for nearly $5 million.
- Current Status: As of early 2026, Jay is still very much a Tennessee guy. He serves time—literally, he just finished a short stint in the Williamson County Jail following a DUI incident—but his primary residence remains in the Franklin/Nashville area. He’s traded the "Very Cavallari" cameras for a quieter life on the farm, though he does make frequent hunting trips to Montana.
Why They Stay Where They Are
It’s about brand. Bodybuilder Jay needs the fitness Mecca of Vegas. It’s the center of the bodybuilding world. If he lived in, say, Maine, his business would likely suffer. He needs to be where the industry is.
Quarterback Jay is a different story. He grew up in Santa Claus, Indiana, and played college ball at Vanderbilt. Nashville is home base. Despite the messy divorce and the real estate merry-go-round, he’s kept his kids and his business interests (like his meat subscription service) centered in the South.
👉 See also: Weight Loss Surgery How Tall Is Lizzo: The Real Story Behind Her Change
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're trying to keep up with either Cutler, here’s the best way to do it without being a stalker:
- For the Bodybuilder: Check out the NPC Jay Cutler Desert Classic in April at the South Point Hotel in Vegas. It’s the best place to see him in his element.
- For the QB: He’s more private now, but he’s active with his Cutler Wellness brand and his podcasting. He isn't hanging out on Broadway in Nashville; you're more likely to see him in a camo hat at a local Franklin hardware store.
- Real Estate Reality: Don't trust old Zillow listings. Both men have moved significantly in the last 24 months. The "farm" you see on old reality TV reruns has long since been sold to a new owner.
If you’re looking to invest in Tennessee or Nevada real estate because of them, just know the market in Franklin is still holding steady around that $7-10 million mark for celebrity-level acreage, while Summerlin remains the premier spot for athletes in Vegas.