Forget the Cooperstown story. Honestly, the whole idea that a Civil War hero named Abner Doubleday sat down in a cow pasture in 1839 and sketched out the diamond-shaped field is a total fabrication. It’s a myth. It’s a marketing ploy that worked so well it became part of the American DNA, but if you're looking for the real answer to where did baseball originate from, you have to look much further back than a 19th-century field in upstate New York.
It started with a commission. In 1905, Albert Spalding—the sporting goods mogul—wanted to prove that baseball was a purely American invention. He put together the Mills Commission to "investigate." They didn't really investigate; they just waited for a story they liked. They found a letter from a guy named Abner Graves who claimed Doubleday invented it. That was enough for them. They ignored the fact that Doubleday was at West Point at the time and never mentioned baseball in his personal diaries. Not once.
History is messier than a clean origin story.
The British Connection No One Wanted to Admit
If you want to get technical about where did baseball originate from, you’re going to have to talk about England. This makes a lot of people uncomfortable because we want baseball to be "ours." But the truth is, people were playing "base-ball" (with the hyphen) in Britain long before the United States was even a country.
The first known reference to the game by name shows up in 1744. A little book called A Little Pretty Pocket-Book by John Newbery describes a game called "Base-Ball." It even has a woodcut illustration showing boys playing in a field with posts instead of bags for bases. It’s right there. Black and white.
Then you have "stoolball" and "tut-ball." These were medieval games played by milkmaids and villagers. In stoolball, someone would throw a ball at a three-legged stool, and another person would try to hit it away with their hand or a stick. It’s easy to see the DNA of the modern game in those frantic sessions in the English countryside. Even Jane Austen mentions "base-ball" in her novel Northanger Abbey, written around 1798. If Catherine Morland was playing it in a Regency-era novel, it definitely didn't start in Cooperstown in 1839.
Rounders vs. Baseball: The Great Debate
Most people assume baseball came from Rounders. It’s the most common "fact" people throw around at trivia nights. But sports historians like David Block, who wrote Baseball Before We Knew It, argue that both games actually evolved simultaneously from a common ancestor. They’re more like cousins than a father and son.
Rounders and baseball both involve hitting a ball and running around bases. However, the specific rules of the "New York Game"—which is what we recognize as modern baseball—actually diverged quite sharply from the English versions by the mid-1800s. We took the bones of an old English pastime and grafted a uniquely American obsession with statistics, formal rules, and professionalization onto it.
👉 See also: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
The Knickerbocker Revolution
By the 1840s, the question of where did baseball originate from moves from the muddy fields of England to the paved streets of Manhattan. This is where the game starts to look familiar.
Alexander Cartwright is the name you actually need to know. He was a bank clerk and a volunteer firefighter. In 1845, he and the members of the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club of New York drafted a set of 20 rules. This was the "Big Bang" of modern baseball.
Some of those rules changed everything:
- They abolished "soaking." In older games, you could get a runner out by throwing the ball at them and hitting them. Cartwright realized that if you're using a hard ball, you’re going to kill someone. So, they switched to tagging the runner or the base.
- They established the diamond-shaped infield.
- They set the distance between bases.
- They dictated that the ball had to be pitched "underhand."
The first recorded game under these rules happened on June 19, 1846, at Elysian Fields in Hoboken, New Jersey. The Knickerbockers lost to the "New York Nine" 23 to 1. It’s kind of hilarious that the guys who wrote the rules got absolutely smoked in their first official outing. But the score didn't matter. The framework was set.
Why the Civil War Made It "America’s Game"
If the game started in New York and New Jersey, how did it become the national pastime? The answer is grim: the Civil War.
Before 1861, baseball was mostly a regional hobby played by "gentlemen" in the Northeast. When the war broke out, soldiers from different states were thrown together in camps. New York regiments brought their "Knickerbocker Rules." In their downtime between battles or in prisoner-of-war camps, they played.
It was the perfect camp game. You only needed a ball, a stick, and some space.
✨ Don't miss: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Soldiers from the Midwest and the South learned the New York game from the Union soldiers. When the war ended, they took those rules back to their hometowns. It was a viral spread before the internet existed. By 1865, baseball wasn't just a New York thing anymore. It was a national obsession that helped a fractured country find a common language.
Professionalism and the 1869 Cincinnati Red Stockings
Once the game spread, people started getting really good at it. Naturally, teams wanted to win, and they started quietly paying players.
The 1869 Cincinnati Red Stockings were the first openly all-professional team. They went on a tour and didn't lose a single game for over a year. They were the rock stars of their era. This shifted the narrative of where did baseball originate from away from amateur social clubs and toward the commercial powerhouse it is today.
Technical Evolution: The Ball and the Bat
We shouldn't just talk about the who and the where. The what matters just as much.
Early baseballs were "lemon peels." They were made of a single piece of leather stitched in a cross pattern. They were light, soft, and they didn't go very far. If you hit a lemon peel ball today with a modern bat, it would probably just go "thwack" and die in the infield.
The bats were different too. There were no regulations on size or shape. Some players used flat bats (like cricket bats), while others used heavy, wagon-tongue clubs that were nearly impossible to swing quickly. It wasn't until the late 1800s that the bat became the tapered, cylindrical tool we see today.
The move toward a "dead ball" (which was basically a core of rubber wrapped in yarn) defined the strategy of the game for decades. It was a game of bunts, steals, and "small ball" because the equipment literally wouldn't allow for the home run era we see now.
🔗 Read more: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
Common Misconceptions That Just Won't Die
You'll still see people swearing by the Doubleday story.
There's a reason for that: Cooperstown is a beautiful place. The National Baseball Hall of Fame is there. It feels right. But being an expert on this means acknowledging that the Hall of Fame exists in Cooperstown because of a lie. It’s a wonderful lie that celebrates the sport, but it’s a lie nonetheless.
Another one? That baseball evolved from Cricket.
While they share some DNA—bats, balls, innings—baseball is actually more closely related to "Trap Ball" or "Tip-cat." These were games where you’d hit a piece of wood or a ball into the air yourself and then strike it. Cricket is a much more formal, slower-paced relative. Baseball was always meant to be faster, more urban, and more "scrappy."
The Global Origin Story
While we focus on the Anglo-American roots, it’s worth noting that ball-and-stick games have popped up in almost every culture. The French had la soule. Variations existed in Ancient Egypt.
But the specific evolution of the game we call "Baseball" is a story of migration. It migrated from English meadows to New York social clubs, through the bloody camps of the Civil War, and eventually into the professional stadiums of the 20th century.
So, where did baseball originate from?
It didn't "originate" in one moment. It was a slow-motion collision of English folk games and American urbanization. It was refined by firefighters in New Jersey and popularized by soldiers in Virginia.
What to Do With This Information
If you're a fan or a student of the game, stop looking for a "Founder." Baseball doesn't have a George Washington. Instead, do this:
- Visit the Elysian Fields Marker: If you’re ever in Hoboken, go to 11th and Washington. There’s a simple plaque in the sidewalk. It’s way more authentic than the Cooperstown myth.
- Read "Baseball Before We Knew It" by David Block: This is the definitive text if you want to see the actual woodcuts and diary entries from the 1700s.
- Watch a "Vintage Base Ball" game: There are leagues across the U.S. that play by the 1860s rules (no gloves, underhand pitching). It’s the best way to feel the history.
- Acknowledge the British Roots: The next time someone says baseball is "purely American," you can politely mention the 1744 London references. It makes for great (and slightly annoying) bar trivia.
The game is still evolving. From the pitch clock to the shift bans, baseball isn't a finished product. It never was. It’s a living document that started in the 1700s and is still being written every time someone picks up a bat.