If you’re looking for the gritty, high-stakes (and highly debated) world of Lebanon Levi and his crew, you’re probably finding that tracking down every episode isn't as straightforward as it used to be. The show was a massive hit for Discovery back in the day, but reality TV rights shift like Pennsylvania weather. Finding where can i watch amish mafia depends entirely on whether you want to stream it with a subscription or just buy the seasons outright to keep forever.
Honestly, the show is a trip. Whether you believe every "reenactment" or you’re just there for the buggy-smashing drama, it’s addictive. Here is the actual, current breakdown of where the show is living in 2026.
The Best Streaming Options for Amish Mafia
For most people, a streaming subscription is the easiest way to go. Since this was a Discovery Channel original, the corporate family tree dictates where it lands.
Discovery+ is the primary home for the series. You can find seasons here, though occasionally the platform swaps out specific "special" episodes or behind-the-scenes look-backs. If you already have a Max (formerly HBO Max) subscription, you should check there first, as the Discovery+ library has been largely folded into Max.
If you aren't into the big apps, there are a few "Live TV" streaming services that carry it via their On-Demand libraries:
🔗 Read more: Bad For Me Lyrics Kevin Gates: The Messy Truth Behind the Song
- Philo: This is often the cheapest way to get Discovery content without a long-term contract.
- YouTube TV: If you pay for the full cable replacement, Amish Mafia is usually tucked away in the VOD section.
- DirecTV Stream: Similar to YouTube TV, it’s available if your package includes Discovery.
Buying vs. Renting: Where to Own the Series
Sometimes you just want to own the chaos so you don't have to worry about licensing deals expiring. Digital storefronts are your best bet here. Prices usually hover around $9.99 to $19.99 per season, depending on whether you want SD or HD.
- Amazon Prime Video: They have the most consistent listing of all four original seasons. You can buy individual episodes if you just want to see the famous "exorcism" or the series finale.
- Apple TV / iTunes: Very reliable for high-quality versions of the show.
- Fandango At Home (formerly Vudu): They often sell a "Complete Series" bundle which can save you about ten bucks compared to buying them one by one.
- Google Play Store: Good for Android users, though the interface for TV shows can be a bit clunky compared to the others.
Is Amish Mafia Still on Discovery Plus?
Yes, but there's a catch. Occasionally, reality shows from the 2010s go through "rights refreshes." As of now, you can find the core seasons on Discovery+, but don't be surprised if the "Special Episodes" or the "The Amish Speak" reunion segments are missing.
Those specials were often produced under different contracts. If you’re a completionist, you might have to hunt for those specific one-offs on YouTube or through third-party sellers on Amazon.
What Happened to the Cast?
A big reason people still search for where can i watch amish mafia is the mystery surrounding the cast. Once the cameras stopped rolling in 2015, most of them vanished back into their communities—or at least tried to.
💡 You might also like: Ashley Johnson: The Last of Us Voice Actress Who Changed Everything
Lebanon Levi (Levi Stoltzfus) actually wrote a book after the show ended. It’s called Amish Confidential. If you watch the show and find yourself thinking, "There is no way this is real," his book actually clears up a lot of the "produced" elements versus the real-life tensions in Lancaster County.
Merlin, the rival from Ohio, has popped up in various interviews over the years, mostly maintaining the same persona he had on screen. Esther Schmucker, who was a central figure in the Lancaster crew, has largely stayed out of the public eye following some well-documented legal issues and personal struggles that were partially touched upon in the later seasons.
Why the Show Was So Controversial
You can't talk about watching this show without mentioning that the Amish community itself—and many historians—absolutely hated it. The "National Committee for Amish Religious Freedom" and various Pennsylvania officials went on record saying the show was a total fabrication.
The producers always used a disclaimer saying "Certain scenes have been re-enacted," but that was a bit of an understatement for most viewers. Whether it was "fake" or "real" doesn't change the fact that it’s a fascinating piece of reality TV history. It captured a specific moment in time when we were obsessed with "hidden worlds," much like Moonshiners or Duck Dynasty.
📖 Related: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
Quick Troubleshooting for Streaming
If you're logged into Max or Discovery+ and you can't see the show, check your "Content Rating" settings. Because the show deals with "organized crime" and has a TV-14 rating with some bleeped language, restrictive profiles might hide it from the search results.
Also, if you are traveling outside the United States, your library will change. The show is much harder to find in the UK or Canada due to different international distribution deals. In those cases, buying the seasons on a platform like Apple is usually the only guaranteed way to watch.
Actionable Steps for Your Rewatch
If you’re ready to dive back into the world of Lancaster County, here is the most efficient way to do it:
- Check Max first: It's the most common app people already pay for that houses the Discovery library.
- Use a "Complete Series" bundle: If you're buying, Fandango At Home or Amazon’s bundles are significantly cheaper than buying individual episodes.
- Watch in order: The "mafia war" between Levi and Merlin actually has a narrative arc that gets confusing if you skip around, especially once the Mennonite "crews" get involved in Season 3.
- Grab the book: If you finish the series and want to know what was real and what was "TV magic," find a copy of Amish Confidential. It changes how you see the whole production.