Waiting for Pennsylvania to finish counting votes is basically a biennial tradition at this point. If you've spent any time refreshing a results map at 2:00 AM while staring at a "98% reporting" ticker that hasn't budged in six hours, you know the feeling. It's frustrating. It's confusing. And honestly, it's just how the Keystone State is built.
The question of when will pennsylvania senate race be called doesn't have a single "Aha!" moment on the clock. It’s more of a legal and mathematical gauntlet. Unlike some states that have their business settled by the time the late-night news starts, Pennsylvania is notorious for a slow burn. We saw this in the 2024 showdown between Dave McCormick and Bob Casey, where the "winner" wasn't even a settled concept until weeks after the polls closed.
👉 See also: Why Washington Housing Program Failures Are Getting Harder to Ignore
The Reality of the "Blue Shift" and Late Night Delays
Pennsylvania doesn't let counties even touch mail-in ballots until 7:00 AM on Election Day. This is the big one. Most people think they're seeing a "comeback" or "dump" of votes late at night, but it’s just the law. While states like Florida pre-process their mail-in votes so they can hit "print" the second polls close, Pennsylvania’s workers are basically starting a marathon at the same time everyone else is finishing.
This creates the "Red Mirage" or "Blue Shift." Usually, in-person votes—which tend to skew Republican—are reported first because they are tabulated right at the precinct. The mail-in ballots, which historically lean Democratic, take longer to verify signatures, open envelopes, and scan. If the margin is tight, you’re looking at days of waiting just to get through the paper.
Take the 2024 race as a prime example. The Associated Press called the race for McCormick on November 7, just two days after the election. But wait—Decision Desk HQ didn't call it until November 14. Then you had the major networks like CNN and NBC holding out until November 21. That’s a 14-day gap between "official" calls from different experts. Why? Because the margin was razor-thin, sitting at about 0.22% when all was said and done.
The Automatic Recount: Pennsylvania’s 0.5% Rule
If you want to know when will pennsylvania senate race be called, you have to look at the 0.5% threshold. It’s the magic number. Under Pennsylvania law, if the margin between the top two candidates is less than or equal to 0.5% of the total vote, an automatic recount is triggered.
This isn't optional. The Secretary of the Commonwealth must order it.
- The Timeline: The Secretary has until the second Thursday after the election to order the recount.
- The Work: Counties must start the recount by the third Wednesday and finish by the following Tuesday.
- The Cost: This usually costs taxpayers north of $1 million.
In the McCormick-Casey race, the Secretary of the Commonwealth, Al Schmidt, officially triggered the recount on November 13, 2024. Even though McCormick was leading by roughly 17,000 votes, the law required the process to move forward. It wasn't until Bob Casey conceded on November 21 that the Department of State finally called the whole thing off. Without a concession, we would have been waiting until at least November 27 to see the "final-final" numbers.
Why Some Networks Call It Faster Than Others
It feels sort of shady when one news outlet says a race is over and another says it's too close to call. But it’s actually just different levels of "risk tolerance."
The Associated Press (AP) is the gold standard, but they’re aggressive. They don't call a race until they are "100% certain" the trailing candidate has no mathematical path to victory. In 2024, they saw the remaining uncounted ballots in McCormick's lead and decided Casey couldn't close the gap. Other networks like NBC or ABC are often more conservative. They want to see the provisional ballots—those "oops" ballots where someone’s registration was wonky or they forgot their ID—processed before they put a checkmark next to a name.
Provisional ballots are the "wild card" of Pennsylvania elections. There are tens of thousands of them every cycle. In a race decided by 0.2%, every single one matters. This leads to legal battles over things you’d never think of, like whether a voter wrote the "correct" date on the outer envelope or if they used a "secrecy envelope."
What to Watch for in 2026
Looking ahead to the 2026 Pennsylvania State Senate elections, the stakes are just as high. We’re talking about control of the General Assembly. If the 2024 results taught us anything, it’s that the "call" depends heavily on where the remaining votes are.
If the uncounted votes are in Philadelphia or Montgomery County, the Democrat is going to gain ground. If they’re in the "T" (the rural middle of the state), the Republican will likely hold firm. You can usually tell a race is about to be called when the "outstanding vote" number drops below the current lead. If McCormick is up by 20,000 and there are only 15,000 ballots left to count, it’s over. Simple math.
Navigating the Wait: Actionable Steps for Voters
If you're following a close race and the suspense is killing you, don't just stare at the cable news map. They’re often 20 minutes behind the actual data.
💡 You might also like: Was there an earthquake in California last night? What the latest USGS data actually shows
- Follow the Pennsylvania Department of State directly. Their election results portal is the raw source for everyone else.
- Watch the "Provisional" and "Overseas" count. These are the very last batches. Military and overseas ballots can arrive up to a week after Election Day as long as they were postmarked by the deadline.
- Check the "Margin of Victory." If it stays above 0.5%, you’ll get a call within 48 to 72 hours. If it dips below 0.5%, settle in for a two-week ride because that recount is coming.
- Ignore the "Percent Reporting" trope. "99% reporting" can still mean 50,000 votes are out there. In Pennsylvania, 50,000 votes is an eternity.
Understanding the mechanics makes the waiting a little easier. It’s not a conspiracy when the lead changes at 3:00 AM; it’s just a tired government employee in a warehouse in Allegheny County finally getting through a stack of envelopes. Pennsylvania is a "purple" battleground with complex laws, and that means "calling" a race is always going to be a test of patience.
Keep an eye on the legal challenges. In 2024, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court had to step in regarding undated ballots. Those court rulings often happen in the "dead zone" between Election Night and the final certification, and they can shift the "called" date by several days. If you see lawyers filing paperwork, the "call" is likely getting pushed back.
Final takeaway: If the margin is wide, expect a call by Wednesday morning. If it’s tight, don't expect a winner until you're planning your Thanksgiving dinner.