Honestly, if you asked this question a couple of years ago, the answer was a flat "never." For centuries, the idea of a guy from Chicago or New York sitting on the Chair of Saint Peter was basically a punchline in Vatican circles. But things changed. Fast.
In May 2025, the world watched as white smoke billowed from the Sistine Chapel, and for the first time in the 2,000-year history of the Catholic Church, a voice announced a name that didn't just sound different—it represented a seismic shift in global religion. That name was Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost.
The Election of Pope Leo XIV: A First for the U.S.
When was the last American pope? He’s the one we have right now. Pope Leo XIV, born Robert Francis Prevost in Chicago, Illinois, was elected on May 8, 2025. It’s still wild to think about. He succeeded Pope Francis, who had spent years signaling that the "center" of the Church was moving away from Europe and toward the peripheries.
Prevost wasn't your typical "American" candidate.
He didn't spend his career climbing the ladder in D.C. or Los Angeles. Instead, he spent decades as a missionary in Peru. He’s an Augustinian. He’s got that Chicago "regular guy" vibe, but he speaks Spanish and Italian like a native. That’s probably why the College of Cardinals finally broke the "American taboo."
✨ Don't miss: The CIA Stars on the Wall: What the Memorial Really Represents
For a long time, there was this unspoken rule that you couldn't have a pope from a "superpower." The fear was that a U.S. pope would make the Vatican look like an arm of the State Department. But because Prevost had spent so much time in South America and later worked in the Vatican’s Dicastery for Bishops, he was seen more as a "bridge builder" than a representative of American political interests.
Why It Took 2,000 Years
It sounds crazy, but until 2025, the United States had a perfect zero on the scoreboard of popes. Most popes—217 out of 267—have been Italian. The rest were mostly French, German, or Spanish.
The U.S. was basically considered "mission territory" until 1908. We were the new kids on the block. The Church moves slow. Like, really slow.
- The Superpower Problem: Cardinals from Africa, Asia, and even Europe were always wary of giving the U.S. more influence.
- The Italian Tradition: For centuries, it was just assumed the Pope would be Italian. That only really broke in 1978 with John Paul II (Poland).
- The Language Barrier: Historically, American bishops weren't always seen as "Roman" enough. They didn't always speak the linguistic or diplomatic language of the Curia.
The "Papabile" Americans Who Almost Made It
Before Leo XIV, there were a few guys who people thought might actually do it. Cardinal Sean O'Malley of Boston was a huge favorite in 2013. People loved his humble Capuchin robes and his "no-nonsense" approach to fixing the Church’s scandals. Then there was Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York. He’s got the personality of a late-night talk show host and the political chops to match. But both of them ultimately stayed in their home dioceses.
🔗 Read more: Passive Resistance Explained: Why It Is Way More Than Just Standing Still
Who is Robert Francis Prevost (Leo XIV)?
Born in 1955. Chicago native. Tennis player.
Prevost is kind of a fascinating study in contradictions. He’s a Midwesterner through and through, but he spent eighteen years in Peru. He served as the Prior General of the Augustinian Order in Rome twice. That’s a big deal. It meant he already knew how to run a global organization before he even got the keys to the Vatican.
In his first address from the loggia of St. Peter’s, he didn’t start with a big theological lecture. He opened with "Peace be with all of you." He spoke in Italian and Spanish before he ever dropped a word of English. It was a tactical move, honestly. He wanted to show the world he wasn't just "the American Pope," but a pastor for everyone.
What This Means for the Church Today
The election of an American pontiff hasn't been without drama. There’s still a lot of polarization. In the U.S., some Catholics wanted a "culture warrior," while others wanted a radical reformer. Leo XIV seems to be trying to find a middle path, which is basically the hardest job on the planet right now.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
He’s already made headlines for his "Orwellian" comments. In January 2026, he gave a speech warning about the "shrinking space for genuine freedom of expression" in the West. It was a sharp, intellectual critique that showed he’s not just here to smile for the cameras; he’s got a very specific, very sharp view of where modern society is heading.
Actionable Insights for Following the Papacy:
- Watch the Bishop Appointments: Since Prevost used to run the office that picks bishops, keep an eye on who he promotes. This is where he will leave his longest-lasting mark.
- Monitor the Diplomatic Shifts: With an American in the chair, how the Vatican handles relations with China and the Middle East will change. The "superpower" dynamic is still there, even if he's a missionary at heart.
- Look for "Missionary" Rhetoric: Expect a focus on the poor in South America and Africa. He’s likely to spend more time traveling to "the peripheries" than sitting in Rome.
The "last" American pope is actually the only American pope. It took two millennia to get here, but the Chicagoan in the white cassock is now the one calling the shots.
To stay updated on his specific decrees and international travels, you should check the official Vatican News portal or the National Catholic Register, which provide daily updates on his schedule and encyclicals.