Ask most people when was the city of New York founded, and they’ll probably give you a blank stare or mutter something about 1624. Or 1625. Or maybe that famous story about $24 worth of beads.
History isn't a clean line. It's a series of overlapping claims and mud-on-the-boots reality. If you want the technical, "official" answer, the Dutch West India Company established a permanent settlement in 1624. But honestly? People had been living on that rocky island of Manhattan for thousands of years before a European boat ever showed up in the harbor. The Lenape people called it Manahatta. To them, the idea of "founding" a place that already existed was probably pretty confusing.
The 1624 vs. 1625 Debate
So, why the confusion? It comes down to what you count as a "city."
In 1624, the Dutch sent about 30 families over. But they didn't actually land on Manhattan first. They went to Noten Eylandt—which we now call Governor’s Island. It was a small, temporary setup. It wasn't until 1625 that the engineers actually started laying out the grid for Fort Amsterdam on the southern tip of Manhattan. This is why the official seal of the City of New York says 1625, even though the state often points to 1624.
It’s a bit of a bureaucratic headache.
If you’re walking down toward Battery Park today, you’re basically walking on the original footprint of that 1625 "founding." The Dutch weren't exactly looking to build a sprawling metropolis. They wanted beaver pelts. They wanted a trading post. New Amsterdam was essentially a corporate startup. Think of it like a remote office that eventually took over the whole company.
✨ Don't miss: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
Peter Minuit and the $24 Myth
We’ve all heard the story. Peter Minuit bought Manhattan for $24 worth of trinkets in 1626.
It’s one of those history facts that is technically true but totally misleading. First off, the Dutch didn't use dollars; they used guilders. The "60 guilders" figure comes from a letter written by Pieter Schagen, a Dutch merchant. When historians in the 19th century did the math, they landed on the $24 figure.
But here is the real kicker: The Lenape who "sold" the land likely didn't see it as a sale.
In their culture, land wasn't something you owned forever. It was something you shared. They probably thought they were signing a treaty for shared use or a temporary alliance. The Dutch, meanwhile, were operating on European property law. That massive cultural disconnect is basically the foundation of New York real estate.
Life in New Amsterdam
What was it like? Dirty. Loud. Multilingual.
🔗 Read more: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think
By the 1640s, an 18-year-old visitor could walk through the muddy streets of New Amsterdam and hear 18 different languages being spoken. It was never a "pure" Dutch colony. It was a chaotic mix of Dutch, English, French, German, and enslaved Africans who were brought there against their will as early as 1626.
The city was built on trade, not religion. Unlike the Puritans in New England who were obsessed with moral purity, the folks in New Amsterdam just wanted to get rich. This created a weird kind of tolerance. As long as your money was good, they didn't care much about which church you went to—or if you went at all. That’s the DNA of the city. It’s why NYC feels so different from Boston or Philadelphia even today.
The British Takeover of 1664
The city stopped being New Amsterdam on September 8, 1664.
Four English warships sailed into the harbor and demanded the Dutch surrender. Peter Stuyvesant, the director-general with a wooden leg and a legendary temper, wanted to fight. He was ready to go down swinging. But the residents? They looked at the British cannons, looked at their own crumbling walls, and basically said, "No thanks."
They signed the Articles of Capitulation without a single shot being fired. The Duke of York got a new city named after him, and the Dutch got to keep their property and their trade rights. It was a very New York way to handle a war: prioritize the business and skip the bloodshed.
💡 You might also like: Black Red Wing Shoes: Why the Heritage Flex Still Wins in 2026
Why These Dates Still Matter
You might think knowing exactly when was the city of New York founded is just for trivia nights. But it explains everything about the city’s current layout.
- Wall Street: Named because there was an actual wooden wall there to keep out the British and the Native Americans.
- Broadway: Originally a Lenape trail called Wickquasgeck that the Dutch widened.
- The Grid: The messy, winding streets of Lower Manhattan exist because they were built before the 1811 Commissioners' Plan turned the rest of the island into a giant graph paper.
Surprising Facts About the Founding
- The first "New Yorkers" weren't Dutch. Most of the original 1624 settlers were Walloons—French-speaking Protestants from what is now Belgium.
- Manhattan was a hill. The name Manahatta roughly translates to "island of many hills." The settlers spent centuries flattening the terrain to make it easier to build on.
- Slavery was foundational. Enslaved people built the wall that gave Wall Street its name. They cleared the woods. They built the roads. You can't talk about the founding without acknowledging that.
Seeing the History for Yourself
If you want to touch the "founding" era, you have to look closely. Most of the Dutch architecture was burned down in the Great Fire of 1776. But the spirit is still there.
Go to the intersection of Pearl and Broad Streets. There’s a yellow brick outline in the sidewalk. That’s the site of the first City Hall (Stadt Huys), built in 1641. Walk down Stone Street. It’s one of the few places where the narrow, cobblestone vibe of the 1600s still lingers.
New York didn't start with a bang. It started with a few huts, some beaver skins, and a lot of people trying to figure out how to live on top of each other.
Whether you pick 1624, 1625, or 1626, the truth is that the city has always been a work in progress. It’s never been finished. That's probably the most "founded" thing about it.
Actionable Steps for History Buffs
- Visit the New-York Historical Society: They have the original documents, including the "Schagen Letter" that mentions the purchase of Manhattan.
- Walk the "Original Shoreline": Use a historical map app to see where the water used to hit. Most of the land south of Pearl Street is actually "made land" (landfill) added over the centuries.
- Explore the National Museum of the American Indian: It’s located in the old Alexander Hamilton U.S. Custom House, right where Fort Amsterdam used to stand. It gives the essential perspective of the people who were there long before the Dutch.
- Check out the Castello Plan: Look up a high-res version of this 1660 map online. It’s the only detailed map of New Amsterdam that exists from that era, and it’s wild to see how small the "city" actually was.