You’ve probably fired up the grill on the last Monday of May without giving much thought to why we actually get the day off. Most people call it Memorial Day now. But back in the day—we’re talking the 1860s—it had a much more literal name: Decoration Day. If you’re looking for a single, clean date for when was decoration day established, you’re going to be disappointed because history is rarely that tidy.
It wasn't a "one and done" decree from a president.
The tradition grew out of a literal mountain of corpses. By the time the American Civil War ended in 1865, roughly 620,000 soldiers were dead. In some towns, an entire generation of young men simply vanished. People were grieving on a scale we can't really wrap our heads around today. They needed a way to process that collective trauma. So, they started grabbing flowers. Lilacs, peonies, whatever was blooming in late spring. They went to the cemeteries and they decorated the graves. That’s it. That’s the "establishment" of the holiday—a grassroots movement of grieving mothers and widows long before the politicians got involved.
The Official Proclamation of 1868
While local towns were already doing their thing, the formalizing of the event happened on May 5, 1868. This is the "official" answer most historians point to. General John A. Logan, who was the commander-in-chief of the Grand Army of the Republic (a massive organization of Union veterans), issued General Order No. 11.
He designated May 30 as a day for "strewing with flowers, or otherwise decorating the graves of comrades who died in defense of their country during the late rebellion."
Logan didn't just pick May 30 out of a hat. He chose it because flowers across the country would be in full bloom by then. It wasn't the anniversary of a specific battle. It was a practical choice. He wanted the graves to look beautiful. The first large-scale celebration under this order happened at Arlington National Cemetery that same year. Imagine five thousand people gathered around the flower-draped veranda of the Arlington mansion. James Garfield, a future president, gave a speech that lasted for nearly two hours. Then, the crowd wandered through the rows of white headstones, placing blossoms on both Union and Confederate graves.
The Waterloo Contradiction
If you drive into Waterloo, New York, you’ll see signs everywhere claiming they are the "Birthplace of Memorial Day." This gets confusing. In 1966, President Lyndon B. Johnson signed a proclamation officially declaring Waterloo as the birthplace. According to the federal government, Decoration Day was established there on May 5, 1866.
📖 Related: Finding the Right Words: Quotes About Sons That Actually Mean Something
But here is the thing: a dozen other places say Waterloo is full of it.
Boalsburg, Pennsylvania, claims they started it in 1864. Carbondale, Illinois, says they had a parade in 1866 that Logan actually attended. Even Columbus, Mississippi, has a claim because in 1866, a group of women there decorated the graves of both Union and Confederate soldiers, an act of reconciliation that made national headlines. History is messy. People want to be the "first," but the reality is that the impulse to remember the dead was popping up everywhere simultaneously like wildflowers.
The Charleston Discovery: A Forgotten Beginning
For a long time, the story of Decoration Day was told through a very specific, northern lens. But in the late 1990s, historian David Blight uncovered a narrative that had been largely erased from the history books.
It happened in Charleston, South Carolina, right after the war ended in 1865.
The site was a former racetrack that Confederate forces had turned into an outdoor prison. Conditions were horrific. Hundreds of Union soldiers died there from disease and exposure and were buried in a mass grave. After the city fell to the North, a group of formerly enslaved people—nearly ten thousand of them—spent weeks properly reburying those soldiers. On May 1, 1865, they held a parade. They brought flowers. They sang hymns. They called it "The First Decoration Day."
This event predates Logan’s order by three years. It wasn't led by generals; it was led by people who had just found their freedom and wanted to honor the men they believed helped them get it. Why did this story disappear? Probably because of the racial politics of the Jim Crow era. White Southerners didn't want to celebrate a holiday associated with Black liberation, and the North eventually moved toward a version of the holiday that focused more on national "healing" than the specific cause of the war.
👉 See also: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
How Decoration Day Became Memorial Day
The name didn't change overnight. For decades, people used both terms interchangeably. After World War I, the holiday shifted from just honoring Civil War dead to honoring all American personnel who died in any war. This was a massive turning point. The scope got bigger. The grief got more modern.
By the mid-20th century, "Memorial Day" had become the dominant name. However, it wasn't until the Uniform Monday Holiday Act of 1968 (which took effect in 1971) that it became a federal holiday positioned on the last Monday of May. This was basically a move by the government to give federal employees more three-day weekends.
Kinda cynical? Maybe.
But it changed the vibe of the day forever. It went from a somber day of cemetery visits on a fixed date to the "unofficial start of summer." Veterans groups, like the VFW, actually fought against the Monday holiday for years. They felt it made the day too much about barbecues and retail sales and not enough about the actual sacrifice. They weren't entirely wrong.
Why the Distinction Matters Today
Understanding when was decoration day established isn't just a trivia game. It reveals the layers of American identity. If you look at the 1860s, you see a country trying to stitch itself back together with flowers. If you look at 1918, you see a country stepping onto the world stage. If you look at 1971, you see a country embracing consumerism and leisure.
The nuances matter.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
- Local vs. Federal: It started as a local, organic movement before the government ever touched it.
- Reconciliation: Early ceremonies often involved honoring "the other side," which was a radical act in 1866.
- Varying Dates: Before the 1971 law, different states celebrated on different days. Some Southern states still have a separate "Confederate Memorial Day."
Honestly, the most authentic way to observe the day is to go back to the original intent of General Logan. He didn't ask for a sale on mattresses. He asked for people to find a grave and put something beautiful on it.
Practical Ways to Honor the Original Decoration Day
If you want to move past the "day off" mentality and tap into the actual history of how this day was established, there are a few things you can do that carry more weight than a social media post.
First, look for local historical societies. They often have records of the very first Decoration Day parades in your specific town. You might find that your local cemetery has a "Grand Army of the Republic" section that hasn't been properly cleaned in years.
Second, understand the "National Moment of Remembrance." In 2000, Congress passed a resolution asking all Americans to pause for one minute at 3:00 p.m. local time. It’s a tiny gesture, but it aligns with the 1868 idea of a collective, national pause.
Finally, if you have ancestors who served, find their gravesite. The act of "decorating"—the literal namesake of the holiday—is a tactile way to connect with the past. Bring some peonies. They were the most common flower used in the 1860s because they were hardy and bloomed right on schedule.
Moving forward, you can use these steps to ground your holiday:
- Visit a local veteran's cemetery between May 1 and May 30 to see the scale of service.
- Research the history of the "Buddy Poppy" and how it connects WWI to the Decoration Day tradition.
- Check the Library of Congress digital archives for "General Order No. 11" to read Logan’s original words for yourself.
The history of this day is a reminder that we don't just move on from tragedy. We build rituals to carry it with us.