If you ask a random person on the street exactly when was Columbus Day established, they’ll probably give you a blank stare before guessing "1492." Obviously, that’s wrong. Christopher Columbus didn’t step off the Santa Maria and immediately file paperwork for a federal holiday. Honestly, the timeline of how this day became a staple on our calendars is way more chaotic than your middle school history textbook let on. It wasn't some grand, unified American gesture. It was actually a desperate move to stop people from being murdered.
History is weird like that.
The first time anyone really made a fuss about the date was in 1792. This was in New York City. The Society of St. Tammany—yeah, the Tammany Hall folks—decided to celebrate the 300th anniversary of the landing. They weren't really thinking about a recurring holiday. It was more of a "hey, we aren't British anymore, let's find a new hero" kind of vibe. But if you're looking for the official, "government-signed-a-paper" answer, we have to fast-forward a hundred years to a very dark moment in Louisiana.
The 1891 Lynchings and the First Presidential Proclamation
Most people don't realize Columbus Day became a thing because of a mass lynching. In 1891, eleven Italian immigrants were murdered by a mob in New Orleans after the police chief was assassinated. It was a diplomatic nightmare. Italy was furious. They cut off relations with the U.S., and there was even talk of war.
President Benjamin Harrison was in a bind.
To smooth things over and court the growing Italian-American vote, he issued a one-time proclamation in 1892. This marked the 400th anniversary. He called it a day of "public celebration." He wanted people to focus on the discovery of the New World rather than the fact that Italian immigrants were being treated terribly in American cities. So, if you want to be technical, 1892 is the first time the federal government officially recognized the day, even if it wasn't a permanent fixture yet.
📖 Related: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
It worked, mostly. People liked the parade. They liked the excuse to close up shop. But the "holiday" as we know it today—the one that gives federal employees a Monday off—didn't actually arrive for several more decades.
How the Knights of Columbus Won the Permanent Holiday
Establishment didn't happen overnight. It was a grind.
The Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal organization, spent years lobbying state legislatures. They saw Columbus as a Catholic hero. In their eyes, making October 12th a holiday was a way to prove that Catholics belonged in a country that was, at the time, pretty hostile toward them. Colorado was the first state to bite. In 1907, Governor Jesse F. McDonald signed it into law.
Other states followed like dominos. But the big win came in 1934.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt, under massive pressure from the Knights of Columbus and Italian-American leaders like Generoso Pope, finally designated October 12th as Columbus Day. But—and this is a big "but"—it still wasn't the "Monday Holiday" we have now. Back then, it was just a day on the calendar. If October 12th fell on a Wednesday, you celebrated on a Wednesday.
👉 See also: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
The Uniform Monday Holiday Act of 1968
This is the boring legal part that actually changed your life. In 1968, Congress passed the Uniform Monday Holiday Act. They wanted to give federal employees more three-day weekends. They figured people would spend more money if they had a long weekend to travel or shop.
Because of this law, which took effect in 1971, Columbus Day was officially moved to the second Monday in October. That is when the modern version of the holiday was truly, finally established as a federal legal holiday.
The Shift Toward Indigenous Peoples' Day
You can't talk about when the holiday was established without talking about when it started to fall apart. By the 1970s, the narrative began to shift. The "Age of Discovery" started looking more like an "Age of Conquest" to a lot of people.
- 1977: A United Nations conference in Geneva first proposed the idea of Indigenous Peoples' Day.
- 1992: Berkeley, California, became the first city to officially swap the names. They did it on the 500th anniversary.
- 2021: President Joe Biden issued the first-ever presidential proclamation for Indigenous Peoples' Day.
Today, the holiday exists in a weird limbo. In some states, it’s still Columbus Day. In others, it’s Indigenous Peoples' Day. In places like South Dakota, it's Native Americans' Day. It’s a bit of a mess, frankly. Some cities ignore it entirely, while others have massive parades with floats and high school marching bands.
Why the Date Keeps Changing (Literally and Figuratively)
When we ask about the establishment of this day, we're really asking about American identity. In 1792, it was about being "not British." In 1892, it was about stopping a diplomatic crisis with Italy. In 1934, it was about Catholic and Italian-American pride.
✨ Don't miss: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
Now? It's about reckoning with the colonial past.
There's no single "Founding Moment" for Columbus Day. It’s a series of layers, like an onion that makes everyone cry. You have the 1792 NYC party, the 1892 Harrison proclamation, the 1907 Colorado law, the 1934 FDR declaration, and the 1968 Act of Congress.
What You Should Actually Do With This Information
If you're researching this for a project or just because you’re curious why the mail isn't coming on a random Monday in October, here is the takeaway:
- Check your local laws. Since the federal government only mandates holidays for federal employees, your state might not actually observe it. For example, Hawaii, Alaska, and Oregon don't recognize Columbus Day.
- Acknowledge the duality. Most modern celebrations now acknowledge both the Italian-American heritage and the impact on Indigenous populations. It's not an "either-or" situation for many communities anymore.
- Look at the primary sources. If you want to see the real deal, look up the 1892 proclamation by Benjamin Harrison. It’s surprisingly poetic for a guy trying to avoid a war over a lynching.
The "establishment" of the holiday is still happening, in a way. Every time a city council votes to change the name or a school board decides whether to stay open, the holiday is being re-established. It's a living piece of legislation that reflects who we think we are at any given moment.
To get a better handle on the current landscape, you should look up your specific state's legislative calendar. Most states have shifted their official stance within the last five years, and the "legal" name of the holiday on your local books might surprise you. Check the "Public Holidays" section of your state's official website—it’s usually buried in the labor or human resources department pages.