The Great Depression wasn't just a "bad patch" for the economy. It was a total collapse of the American dream. By 1933, millions of seniors were literally starving because their life savings had vanished into thin air when the banks folded. This is the messy, desperate backdrop for when social security started. It wasn't some calm, planned bureaucratic expansion. It was an emergency response to a nation in freefall.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt knew he had to do something drastic, but he was also terrified of creating a "dole" system that would make people dependent on the government forever. He wanted a "contributory" system. Basically, if you work, you pay in, and later, you get a check. Simple, right? Well, not exactly. The Social Security Act was signed on August 14, 1935, but the machinery didn't just start humming overnight. It took years to figure out how to track millions of people without computers.
Imagine trying to assign a unique number to every single working adult in the U.S. using nothing but paper, ink, and giant metal filing cabinets. That’s what the Social Security Administration (SSA) had to do in a cramped office in Baltimore.
The 1935 Reality Check
When most people think about when social security started, they picture seniors immediately getting checks in the mail. That’s a myth. The first monthly check wasn't actually cut until 1940. For the first few years, the government was just collecting money.
The very first person to receive a payment was a guy named Ernest Ackerman. He was a motorman from Cleveland who retired one day after the program began. He had five cents withheld from his pay, and the government sent him a one-time lump sum payment of 17 cents. That was the "benefit" back then. It sounds like a joke today, but it was the proof of concept the country needed.
Honestly, the original 1935 Act was pretty limited. It didn't cover farmworkers or domestic servants. This meant a huge chunk of the workforce—especially African Americans in the South—was initially left out of the loop. It took decades of amendments and political fighting to expand the net to include disability insurance and survivors' benefits.
Why 65?
Have you ever wondered why 65 became the magic number for retirement? People often claim FDR just picked it out of a hat or copied Germany's Otto von Bismarck. While Bismarck did influence the idea, the real reason was math. In the 1930s, the average life expectancy was actually lower than 65. The planners figured that by setting the age at 65, they could keep the system solvent because many people simply wouldn't live long enough to collect for decades. It was a grim but practical calculation.
💡 You might also like: Why 25 West 43rd Street is Still the Smartest Address in Midtown
The First Big Check: Ida May Fuller
If you want to understand the scale of how the system grew, you have to look at Ida May Fuller. She’s a legend in Social Security circles. "Aunt Ida" was a legal secretary from Ludlow, Vermont. She retired in November 1939 and started receiving monthly benefits in January 1940.
Her first check was for $22.54.
Here is the wild part: Ida May Fuller lived to be 100 years old. She had paid exactly $24.75 into the system during the three years she worked under the new law. By the time she passed away in 1975, she had collected a total of $22,888.92 in benefits. She became the poster child for why the system is so beloved by those who use it and so scrutinized by those worried about its long-term math.
The Midnight Oil in Baltimore
To get the program off the ground, the SSA had to set up shop in the Candler Building in Baltimore because there wasn't enough office space in D.C. It was a massive operation. They used "Index Visible" cards and early IBM punch-card machines. Every time someone got a job, they had to fill out a Form SS-5.
Think about the logistical nightmare. In an era before digital databases, the government was suddenly the record-keeper for the entire American labor force. If you lost your card, someone had to manually hunt through physical files to find your number.
Misconceptions About the "Trust Fund"
One of the biggest headaches when discussing when social security started is the confusion over where the money actually goes. You’ve probably heard people say the government "raided" the Social Security Trust Fund.
Technically, that's not how it works.
By law, the Social Security Trust Fund must invest its surpluses in special-issue U.S. Treasury bonds. So, the government "borrows" the money to pay for other things, but it leaves an IOU that earns interest. It’s the same way you "lend" money to a bank when you put it in a savings account. The bank uses your money to fund mortgages, but they owe you the balance plus interest. The problem isn't that the money is "gone"—it's that as the population ages, the interest and the principal might not be enough to cover the massive wave of retiring Baby Boomers.
The Evolution of the Tax
When the program kicked off, the tax rate was a tiny 1% on the first $3,000 of income. That was the max. If you made more than that, you didn't pay a penny more in Social Security taxes. Today, that rate has climbed significantly, and the "wage base cap" (the maximum amount of earnings subject to the tax) is adjusted every year.
- 1937: 1% tax rate, $3,000 cap.
- 1950: 1.5% tax rate, $3,000 cap.
- 1980: 6.06% tax rate, $25,900 cap.
- Today: 12.4% (split between employer and employee) with a cap well over $160,000.
The system has constantly shifted to keep up with inflation and changing demographics. It’s never been a "set it and forget it" program. It's a living piece of legislation that gets poked and prodded by every administration.
✨ Don't miss: 850 Third Ave NYC: Why This Midtown Mainstay Is Actually a Huge Deal
Why Social Security Almost Died in the 80s
By the early 1980s, the system was actually running out of money. Fast. It was a crisis.
In 1983, a bipartisan commission led by Alan Greenspan had to swoop in to save it. This is a crucial chapter in the story of when social security started to look like the version we have today. They did two big things that people still complain about: they gradually raised the retirement age to 67 and started taxing a portion of Social Security benefits for higher earners.
It was a bitter pill to swallow. But it bought the system another 50 years of solvency.
Actionable Steps for Your Retirement
Understanding the history is great, but you need to know how it affects your wallet right now. The rules have changed immensely since 1935.
1. Create a "my Social Security" account immediately. Don't wait until you're 62. Go to the official SSA website and set up your portal. This is the only way to verify that your employers have been reporting your earnings correctly. If there’s a mistake from ten years ago, it’s a lot easier to fix now than when you're trying to file for benefits.
2. Run the "Wait or Weight" calculation.
While you can start taking benefits at 62, your monthly check will be permanently reduced by about 30% compared to waiting until your Full Retirement Age (FRA). Conversely, if you wait until age 70, your benefit increases by about 8% for every year you delay. You have to weigh your current health and financial needs against that guaranteed 8% return.
3. Factor in the "Tax Torpedo."
Social Security wasn't originally taxed, but now it is if your "provisional income" exceeds certain thresholds. If you have a large 401(k) or IRA, your required minimum distributions (RMDs) could push you into a bracket where 85% of your Social Security becomes taxable. Talk to a tax pro about Roth conversions early to mitigate this.
4. Check for Spousal and Survivor Benefits.
Even if you didn't work enough credits to qualify on your own, you might be eligible for benefits based on your spouse’s (or even a divorced spouse’s) earnings record. These rules are complex and often overlooked.
👉 See also: Resume accomplishments order format: Why the way you stack your wins matters more than the words themselves
Social Security was never meant to be a full retirement plan. It was designed as a "floor" to prevent poverty. As the system continues to evolve, the best thing you can do is stay informed about the legislative changes and treat your benefits as one piece of a much larger financial puzzle. Knowing the history helps you see that the system has survived crises before, but your personal strategy is what determines your own financial security.