On election night, everyone is glued to the map. Red and blue blocks flicker across the screen while anchors scramble to fill dead air. But there is one specific organization that everyone—from the major networks to the candidates themselves—watches more closely than the rest. The Associated Press. You’ve likely wondered, usually around 11:00 PM when your nerves are shot: When does AP call a state? It isn't a guess. It isn't a projection based on exit polls alone. Honestly, it’s a grueling exercise in math and caution.
The AP has been doing this since 1848. Back then, they used ponies and telegraphs. Now, they use a massive network of over 4,000 stringers and a proprietary system called AP VoteCast. They don’t "predict" winners. They wait until the math makes it physically impossible for the trailing candidate to catch up. That distinction matters because, in a world of "breaking news" tweets and viral misinformation, being first is worthless if you aren’t right. They haven't been wrong in a presidential call in decades.
The Death of the Exit Poll (As We Knew It)
For years, the standard way to understand a race was the traditional exit poll. You know the drill: a person with a clipboard stands outside a precinct and asks people who they voted for. But things changed. In 2018, the AP ditched the National Election Pool's exit polling. Why? Because people don't vote like they used to.
Early voting is now the norm, not the exception. Mail-in ballots have surged. If you only talk to people walking out of a physical building on a Tuesday in November, you're missing millions of data points.
Instead, they use AP VoteCast. It’s a massive survey conducted with NORC at the University of Chicago. They reach out to registered voters days before the election via phone and online panels. This gives them a baseline of what the electorate actually looks like. It’s a more holistic view. It accounts for the person voting from their kitchen table in rural Pennsylvania just as much as the person at a polling station in downtown Philadelphia.
When the "Too Early to Call" Label Disappears
You'll often see a state marked as "Too Early to Call." This happens the second polls close. At that moment, the AP is looking at their VoteCast data. If the survey results show a massive, overwhelming lead that matches the historical voting patterns of that state, they might call it immediately. Think of a Republican in Wyoming or a Democrat in Vermont.
But what about the swing states? That’s where the "Decision Desk" earns its keep.
The Decision Desk is a group of experts—statisticians, political scientists, and veteran journalists—hidden away in a room, isolated from the noise of social media. They are looking at the "raw vote." This is the actual count coming in from county officials. They compare this incoming data against the expected remaining vote.
The Concept of the "Buffer"
They need a margin. If Candidate A is up by 5% with 90% of the vote in, it looks like a win. But what if that remaining 10% of the vote is from a county that historically goes 80% for Candidate B? The AP won't call it. They wait. They calculate the "maximum possible vote" for the trailing candidate. If that maximum number is still lower than the leader's current total, the race is over.
It is pure arithmetic. Brutal, unfeeling arithmetic.
Why Some States Take Days
Remember 2020? Pennsylvania took forever. That wasn't a glitch; it was the process working. When does AP call a state like Pennsylvania or Arizona when the margins are razor-thin? They wait for the "cured" ballots, the provisionals, and the overseas military votes.
Every state has different laws. Some states, like Florida, are pros at counting mail-in ballots before election day and dumping the results the minute polls close. Others, like New York or California, have laws that prevent even opening the envelopes until much later.
The AP also pays close attention to "precincts reporting." But even that metric can be misleading. A precinct in a tiny rural town is not the same as a precinct in a major metro area. The AP analysts know exactly how many votes are outstanding in specific "problem" counties. They won't pull the trigger if there’s a chance a late-night batch of mail-in ballots from a blue city could flip a red lead, or vice versa.
The "Too Close to Call" Nightmare
This is the category that keeps campaign managers awake. A race is "Too Close to Call" when the margin between the top two candidates is less than 0.5%.
💡 You might also like: When Did Poland Leave the Soviet Union: What Most People Get Wrong
At this point, the AP won't call the race until a recount is either finished or the trailing candidate concedes. They are incredibly risk-averse. They would rather wait three days and be 100% certain than be first and have to retract a call. Retracting a call is the ultimate sin in election journalism. It damages the brand, but more importantly, it damages public trust in the democratic process.
The Role of the "Stringer"
Behind the digital maps are real people. The AP has thousands of local "stringers." These are people who literally sit at county clerk offices. They watch the numbers get typed into the official systems. They call in the results to the AP's central hub. This human element is a check against cyber-attacks or technical glitches in state-run reporting websites. If a state website shows a weird spike, the AP can verify it with a human being standing in the room where the votes are being tallied.
Breaking Down the Math: An Illustrative Example
Imagine a state with 1,000,000 expected votes.
Candidate X has 510,000.
Candidate Y has 440,000.
There are 50,000 votes left to count.
Even if Candidate Y wins every single one of those 50,000 remaining votes, their total would only be 490,000. They cannot mathematically win. In this scenario, the AP calls the state for Candidate X.
But it’s rarely that clean. Usually, there are "provisional" ballots—votes cast by people whose eligibility was questioned at the poll. There are also "late-arriving" mail ballots that are legal as long as they were postmarked by election day. The AP’s researchers have to estimate how many of these exist based on historical data and check-ins with local election officials. If the number of potential outstanding ballots exceeds the margin, the "call" stays on ice.
Misconceptions About the AP Call
People often think the AP is part of the government. They aren't. They are a non-profit news cooperative. Their "call" has no legal standing. It doesn't certify the election; only the state’s Secretary of State can do that weeks later.
However, the AP call is the "gold standard" because of their track record. When the AP calls a race, the rest of the world generally accepts it as a fact. This puts an immense amount of pressure on the Decision Desk. They aren't just looking at the top of the ticket, either. They are calling thousands of races simultaneously—House, Senate, Governors, and even local ballot initiatives.
What You Should Look For on Election Night
If you want to watch the returns like a pro, stop looking at the "percentage of precincts reporting." It’s a garbage stat. Instead, look for the "estimated vote remaining."
- Check the geography: Is the outstanding vote from a stronghold for the loser?
- Watch the "overvote": Sometimes more votes are cast in a county than expected. The AP flags these anomalies immediately to ensure no double-counting is happening.
- Listen for the "Why": When the AP finally makes a call, they usually publish a brief "Race Call Explained" article. Read it. It will tell you exactly which batch of votes finally pushed the leader over the finish line.
The process is slow by design. In a world of instant gratification, the AP’s refusal to rush is actually its greatest strength. They don't care about your heart rate or the cable news ratings. They only care about the point where the trailing candidate's path to victory effectively hits a dead end.
Actionable Steps for Following Election Results
To get the most accurate picture during the next cycle, you shouldn't rely on just one source, but you should know which sources to prioritize.
First, bookmark the AP News election map directly. Third-party sites often aggregate this data, but there can be a lag of several minutes. In a fast-moving race, those minutes feel like hours.
Second, pay attention to the margin of lead versus the estimated percent of vote in. If a candidate is leading by 2% but only 60% of the vote is in, ignore the lead. It’s meaningless. You want to see that "vote in" number climb toward 95% before you start believing the current trend.
Third, ignore "projections" from individual pundits on social media. They are often working with partial data or biased filters. The AP's Decision Desk is insulated from the political spin, focusing entirely on the verified count and the statistical probability of a comeback.
Understanding the "why" behind the delay in calling a state can lower your stress levels significantly. It isn't a conspiracy or a failure; it is the deliberate, slow-moving machinery of a system that prioritizes accuracy over speed. Keep your eyes on the remaining vote count and wait for the math to speak for itself.