If you ask a casual fan when Major League Baseball started, they’ll probably point to a dusty black-and-white photo and guess sometime after the Civil War. They aren't exactly wrong, but honestly, the answer is a bit of a mess. History is rarely a clean straight line, and baseball's origin story is more like a chaotic bracket of competing leagues and legal brawls.
Most historians and the league itself pinpoint April 22, 1876, as the day the clock really started ticking. That was the afternoon the National League (NL) played its first official game in Philadelphia. But if you’re a purist, you might argue that professional baseball actually kicked off in 1869 with the Cincinnati Red Stockings. Or maybe you'd say it didn't "truly" become the MLB we recognize today until the American League showed up to pick a fight in 1901.
Basically, the "start" of the majors depends on how much credit you give to the guys playing for beer money before the lawyers got involved.
The 1876 National League: The First Real Foundation
When did Major League Baseball start? If we’re talking about a stable, organized entity that still exists, the answer is 1876. Before this, things were a bit of a wild west. There was a group called the National Association of Professional Base Ball Players (NA) that ran from 1871 to 1875. It was a disaster. Teams would join for a $10 fee, then go bankrupt halfway through the season. Gambling was rampant. Players would jump from team to team whenever someone offered them a few extra bucks.
William Hulbert, a Chicago businessman, had seen enough. He wanted a league run like a business, not a social club. He gathered six teams from the failing National Association and two independent clubs to form the National League of Professional Base Ball Clubs.
The first game took place at the Jefferson Street Grounds in Philadelphia. The Boston Red Caps beat the Philadelphia Athletics 6–5. That single game is widely considered the birth of the "Senior Circuit." Interestingly, two of those original franchises—the Chicago Cubs (then the White Stockings) and the Atlanta Braves (then the Boston Red Caps)—are still playing today. That’s a lot of innings.
The American League and the 1901 "War"
For 25 years, the National League was pretty much the only show in town, though a few "beer and whiskey" leagues tried to compete and failed. Then came Ban Johnson. He was the president of the Western League, a minor league organization, and he had big ambitions. In 1900, he renamed it the American League (AL). By 1901, he declared it a Major League.
The National League didn’t take this well. At all.
What followed was essentially a corporate war. The AL started raiding the NL for talent, offering significantly higher salaries to star players. Because there was no "reserve clause" across both leagues yet, players were free to jump ship. About 100 players did exactly that. This "baseball war" forced the National League to the negotiating table.
👉 See also: When Was Josh Jacobs Drafted: Why That 24th Pick Still Matters Today
In 1903, the two leagues signed the National Agreement. This was the "Peace Pact" that created a three-man commission to govern the sport and established the first modern World Series. The Boston Americans (who later became the Red Sox) beat the Pittsburgh Pirates in that first championship.
The Teams That Time Almost Forgot
While we talk about the NL and AL, the 1969 Special Baseball Records Committee actually recognized four other leagues as "Major."
- The American Association (1882–1891): Known for selling alcohol and playing on Sundays, things the "proper" National League initially banned.
- The Union Association (1884): It lasted exactly one season. It was basically a one-man show run by Henry Lucas.
- The Players' League (1890): This was a fascinating, short-lived experiment where the players actually owned the teams.
- The Federal League (1914–1915): The last major attempt to create a third league.
More importantly, in 2020, MLB officially corrected a massive historical oversight by elevating seven Negro Leagues to major league status. These leagues, which operated between 1920 and 1948, featured some of the greatest talent to ever touch a baseball, like Satchel Paige and Josh Gibson. When we talk about when the majors started, we have to acknowledge that for decades, a huge portion of the best players in the world were excluded from the NL and AL record books simply because of the color of their skin.
Evolution of the Game: It Wasn't Always Like This
In the early days, baseball looked very different. For one, pitchers threw underhand until the 1880s. The balls were often soft and mushy because teams would use the same ball for an entire game until it literally fell apart. This was the "dead-ball era."
✨ Don't miss: How Many Children Does Marcus Freeman Have? Life Inside the Coach's Massive Family
Home runs were rare. Tactics like the bunt and the "hit and run" were king. It wasn't until the 1920s, when Babe Ruth started swinging for the fences and officials started putting clean, hard balls into play more frequently, that the game shifted into the high-scoring spectacle we see today.
Why 1876 Still Matters
The reason we point to 1876 as the definitive start is about structure. It was the moment baseball stopped being a hobby and started being an institution. It introduced player contracts that actually meant something and schedules that teams were required to finish.
Without William Hulbert’s strict (and sometimes harsh) rules in 1876, professional baseball likely would have collapsed under the weight of its own chaos.
How to Explore MLB History Today
If you're a fan of the history, don't just take my word for it. There are a few ways to really dig into this:
- Visit the National Baseball Hall of Fame: It's in Cooperstown, New York. Even if you aren't a huge sports fan, the artifacts from the 1800s are incredible to see in person.
- Check out "Baseball: A Film by Ken Burns": It's a massive documentary series, but the first few "innings" cover the founding of the leagues with incredible detail.
- Research the "Original Eight": Look up the histories of the franchises that survived from the early 1900s—the Reds, Phillies, Giants, Dodgers, Cubs, Braves, Pirates, and Cardinals. Their migrations across the country tell the story of America itself.
Baseball didn't just "start" one Tuesday morning. It evolved. It survived wars, depressions, and its own internal politics to become a permanent fixture of the culture. Knowing when it started helps you appreciate just how unlikely its survival actually was.